I think he has alot of talent but you are right about the similar wrapping paper. If they literally gave him the shooting script for say the new jurassic park he'd be forced to apply his interesting vision to 'something new' vs this safe area he resides. I mean these robots and these outskirt cities and corporate folks in chairs and bounty hunter guy, halo weapons...
At the very least I think a switch in genres would be interesting, if I heard he was making a fantasy movie of the lotr vain. Presto. Have Sharlto be an impoverished magic user or something.
Still, D9 was well received for a reason and I refuse to believe it was a fluke, no reason why this film doesn't have just as much going for it. I'd say it has more given he's had a failure.