Resident fatty Jason Whitlock has come out with the worst article I've seen in the last five years.
http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/story/sabermetrics-moneyball-stat-geeks-are-ruining-sports-092211
I wont be going to see "Moneyball." The movie celebrates the plague ruining sports: sabermetrics.
Classic misinterpretation of someone making judgments on the story about Moneyball without having read or seen it. It's not about pushing certain statistical analysis over others, it's about the basic concept of, in a competitive business, lesser corporations/teams/business have to do things differently in order to compete with the giants of said industry. It's been almost 10 years since the book came out and certain writers still can't comprehend it.
The stat geeks wont let you argue. They quote sabermetrics and end all discussion. Is so-and-so a Hall of Famer? The sabermeticians will punch in the numbers and give you, in their mind, a definitive answer.
Baseless claim, cliche' position that "stat geeks live in their mother's basement"
Sabermetrics or analytics are overrunning football, too.
Football is more a team sport than baseball, it's harder to separate team chemistry from individual contribution. Not sure why this was included.
The nerds are winning. Theyre stealing the game from those of us who enjoy examining the gray areas of sports. Were about 10 years away from a computer program that will write stats-based opinion pieces on sports.
Nerds are not allowed to enjoy sports? This is the sense I'm getting here. Sports can only be enjoyed by the manly jocks and unmanly nerds aren't allowed
Imagine you applied this argument to slavery. When all the plantation owners (anti-stat nerds) were getting angry about losing their indentured servants that they could no longer abuse and what not because it broke tradition of what they believed to be true, the abolitionists (stat oriented people) had to break the mold of what certain parts of America had accepted.
Sabermetrics/analytics undermines the debate. They try to interject absolutes.
Most people who use Sabre stats may not fully understand everything themselves, and will admit that. Imagine if Microsoft used unconventional economic advantages to gain the upper hand in the industry, would people rail against them with torches and pitchforks because of this? No. Another reason why hating on 'stat geeks' is ******ed. If there weren't people crunching numbers, Wall Street and various other American institutions would cease to function. We can't have those people ruining our lives with their dumb math
The games are about more than stats.
I have seen the light, I never knew this before until now. Thank you, Whitlock.
Again, the stat geeks are winning. Our perception of athletes and their value are primarily being dictated by statistics. Peyton Manning is the king of fantasy football; therefore, he is the king of real football. LeBron James is the king of fantasy basketball; therefore, he is the king of real basketball.
I don't think anyone believes this, especially with LeBron.
The answers and the questions that make sports special, unique, our collective national pastime, cant be found on a stat sheet. Theyre in our imaginations and our individual interpretation of what we witness.
Whitlock is the ICP of sportswriters
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-agl0pOQfs
****ing stat geeks, how do they work?
When the "Moneyball" movie hysteria subsides, I hope the sabermeticians ****.
Yeah, that'll show those nerds, once the movie bombs, it will disintegrate the fabric of baseball analysts as we know it.