Aloha,
Great topic my man.
If you haven't already, check out BND Yearbook
It gives a detailed recap of the first year of events. I like your detective work and for what it's worth, that's part of the fun of reading a Marvel comic. They are serialized and you are not supposed to know the whole story in one or two issues.Green Goblin appeared in Amazing #14, we didn't know he was Norman Osborn until #39
.
BTW-I also think your friend is full of it when he says he can tell what MJ said to Mephisto.Talk about Inquiring minds wanting to know
Spidey rules with mystery
Thank you!
The Hobgoblin mystery was even worse. Alot of red herrings and what not, but that helped to make it interesting.
It's a shame that when I actually went back and read the stories (Which were excellent) that the actual identity of the hobgoblin was spoiled by Rodrick Kingsley. (Who has made an appearance in Spectacular Spider-man
)
Thank you very much for tracking down and organizing these clues, Styleshift.
No problem stillanerd, and thanks.
And I agree. I believe that the cause of Peter and MJ's break-up as according to Brand New Day was indeed that she found out about the mindwipe.
It's the only curveball that I see that everyone wouldn't see coming.
People are so fed up with OMD that they are losing themselves in it.
I mean just last year everyone thought her deal was to become a superhero.
You make alot of sense, (I had to cut most of your post for length)
You also made me realize that the whole 90s reboot era does not work in brand new day. The whole reason for that was she wanted Peter to settle down and stop being Spider-man. Girls don't usually do that until after they are married. When shes dating someone that has "dangerous work" they tend to let it slide because that's how they were when they met them and they can't change it. I dunno I really see Mj respecting the webs. (if they were supposed to have been dating)
Also when Mj is "killed" in the "plane accident". He gets her belongings and inside was her wedding ring. (They officially said they were dating. So there was no ring)
I know some people are like "these are comics, get over it". I love continuity, it's why I'm a hardcore Spidey fan. Some people are like "things still make sense. it's just that they were never married".
But it's a bunch of BS
there are
ALOT of stories in the last 20 years that just do not make sense if you go back and read them. Especially the clone saga stuff where Peter and Mj were getting more serious with there marriage. (such as moving to portland) I know some people choose not to get married, but that's just not how they were written.
Alot of stories have to be referenced differently now, and they are very careful over which stories they reference and how they reference them. Such as when Peter says he was dating Mj during the kraven's first hunt arc, and when they referenced things during the clone saga annual.
I just think they really neutered the stories they could tell because of what they did. Now there is a whole lot of stories that are just going to be really awkward when you go back to the issues they reference and see what really happened.
*SIGH* This is why I justify ASM as an "alternate" universe or a "vol. 2".
I really don't think they know what they are doing. Their kinda like "ok suspend your belief even more....yea just go along with this."'
I miss the days when I used to criticize superman's magic glasses. Well....that's what I get.
Bobby Carr (who I imagine she might have met while on a movie set) filled a void and started seeing him, both as a form of escapism, but also because she may have seen a bit of Peter in him, and thought he wasn't all bad. Only she never intended to get as far and as deep into the relationship has he obviously has. When she saw Peter as Spider-Man again, she realized that, despite all she blamed him for and attempting to put everything behind her, she still deeply cared for him and that she was just running away from difficulties like she always did whenever she felt cornered. Furthermore, she realizes that her relationship with Carr, while she probably thought he was sweet, was also just another form of running away.
Hit it on the head. I couldn't have said it better myself.
This, of course, sets the stage for a possible long running subplot involving Carr not only being jealous of Peter--whom he already dislikes because of his stint as a paparazzi--but becoming overly protective of "his girl," unable to let go of MJ because he's convinced himself she's "the one." Maybe it gets to the point where he's practically stalking her and trying everything he can to make Peter's life a living hell. And after all, he's a famous celebrity. He's rich and famous. Peter's just a low-life guttersniping photographer. And he's used to getting what he wants and besides, he loves MJ, more than this Peter Parker does. She can't possibly be still in love with a jerk like him, he tells himself.
Haven't considered that. That would be really interesting.
A while back I considered that they were going to try something like "Mj is torn between two men" (Peter/Spidey) since I took the "nobody remembers who Spider-man is" thing pretty seriously. If that still turns out to be right.
Than I guess those "webheads" are smoking dope in the "braintrust".
As for where the whole whisper to Mephisto fits in? Well, perhaps she told him "let me still remember Peter Parker is Spider-Man" rather than "Let me remember everything." Then, theoretically, this could be allowed to happen but not have Mephisto's direct involvement. Just like, it seems, other things were allowed to happen that didn't involve Mephisto, since Mephisto's deal would have essentially negated itself since it required Peter and MJ to be married. And since they made not to be married, then no deal, technically, ever took place.
That wouldn't fly, because it all happened before he remasked himself.
Mephisto said everything would happen except that they were married.
(I guess that includes the wedding ring I mentioned earlier
)
Styleshift has quickly become my favorite poster here. I love his recaps w/screenies.
Thank you very much. As long as people keep letting me know they appreciate it than I'll continue to do it. I don't do it for nothin! lol
I'll also take requests if I have time.