I tried getting into Evangelion, just couldn't. Watched like 3 episodes and just couldn't keep going. Only anime seres I was ever able to get into hardcore was Death Note
I'll admit, it's one of those series that is very divisive among the anime fandom. You either love it or hate it. Me personally, I absolutely love the series, but only because I have a really good understanding of it from doing my own research on it's background and what thought went into it, and not following the absolutely absurd fan theories which permeate the internet.

t:
If I may suggest, try the
Rebuild of Evangelion movies. They're more easily accessible than the original series. Both
Evangelion 1.11 and
2.22 have been available in the states for some time.
Evangelion 1.11 is a pretty straightforward adaptation of episodes 1-6, with some changes here and there. While there is still proper character development, it "trims the fat" per se (for movie-length purposes), so it doesn't dawdle and moves at a brisker pace while still getting across everything it needs to. It's right at the very end when the story starts to go in a slightly different direction than the original series. It's like 95% original series, 5% new material.
Evangelion 2.22, however, is almost the exact opposite. With the exception of some similar situations, character developments and plot points, it's almost an entirely different take on the Evangelion story. They even introduce a new character (though, at this point in the story, it's kind of hard to say how important her role is). I don't want to spoil anything, but I will say that by the end of the movie, you do kind of gain a new respect for Shinji Ikari.
There are supposed to be two more films, with
Evangelion 3.0 being released in Japan on November 17th this year and
Evangelion: Final being released sometime next year. However, considering how long it takes to license anime like this, we probably won't get them here in the states until probably 2014 or so.