The Battle for Thursday night
Fox's rich beach kid comedy/drama steps into the ring with the WB's chronicles of the young Superman
By: Alan Donahue
Between work, school and homework, college students often have little time to spend watching TV. For college students who only have an hour to spare on Thursday evenings, they must choose between two popular shows that air back-to-back with "Smallville" at 8 p.m. and "The OC" at 9 p.m.
Settings: Now in it's fifth season, "Smallville" still features the nice Kansas landscape. And while the farm scenery is nice and all, it doesn't compare to the beaches of Orange County. The overhead shots of waves crashing onto the sand every episode have me wanting to pack my bathing suit and towel. (Setting: "OC" wins this category.)
Action: Looking back at the first season of "The OC," we saw Ryan get into a fight, and then he got into another fight, Seth got punched and then Ryan fought for him, and they were all very repetitive. Now, most of the fights are verbal, making you yearn for Ryan to pull out his fist one more time. "Smallville" offers much more variety on the action, seeing as the main character is a teenage version of Superman. And the special effects are amazing, especially when Clark Kent goes into Super-speed and everything else appears in slow motion. Smallville's action will keep you on the edge of your seat. (Action: OC - 1; Smallville - 1)
Music: With a hit teen show, you have to have good music to keep the episodes going. Both of these shows do not lack in the musical category. "The OC" has featured live performances from Modest Mouse and Death Cab for Cutie, while Smallville High in Kansas has managed to book Remy Zero (who sing the catchy theme song, "Save Me") and Lifehouse. Both shows have also released soundtracks featuring some of the best music from the show. (Musical quality: Tie.)
Girls: Maybe a female writer will contradict this article with one about the boy of this show, but for now, here is my heterosexual opinion on the females. For "Smallville," they needed to cast iconic characters from the Superman universe such as Lois Lane, Lana Lang and Mrs. Kent. They also added their own character, a go-getter journalist Chloe. Earlier this season in an episode with Aquaman, a trip to the lake proved great for viewers as we got glances at Lois Lane (Erica Durance) and Lana Lang (Kristen Kruek) in all their bikini glory. Sadly, they don't visit the beach too often. Over on the West Coast, though, there is much to see and the two leads Marissa (Misha Barton) and Summer (Rachel Bilson), take advantage of the warm weather with many skimpy outfits that show off their assets. An added bonus is Marissa's mom, Julie Cooper-Nichol (Melinda Clarke), who sometimes outshines her daughter. "The OC" wins this one, mostly due to location.
(Girls: OC -2; Smallville -1).
Storyline: This category is the most important and worth two points. "Smallville" shows the teenage life of the world's most recognizable icon; Superman. And we sit in awe in early seasons as we watch Lex and Clark be friends. But with knowing the future and fate for both of these characters, the writers still manage to keep us watching week after week. Having Lex slowly change into the most evil villian in comic book history is amazing.
With "The OC," we are introduced to new characters but almost immediately, the storylines become almost predictable. soon you find yourself watching it purely for the girls and the comedy. The writers really need to up the ante to keep viewers.
(Storyline: "Smallville" wins this one by a longshot.)
http://www.unlvrebelyell.com/article.php?ID=8633