Pattinson definitely had the most 'creepily imposing' and haunted presence on screen as Batman since Keaton.
He's really only competing with nostalgia for me. I adore and draw inspiration from Bale's heroic, yet 'primal rage' Batman, and it's hard to understate just how massive a shift it was to go from Adam West to what Keaton brought to life in an extremely restrictive suit in 1989. Pattinson immediately catapulted himself into the top-tier for sure.
I think you can say Rob had a lot of the best qualities of all the best in his portrayal. The mystique of Keaton. The rage and intensity that Bale had. The brutality of Affleck when it came to the fights. He was obviously gifted an enormous amount of screentime in the suit, as well as the cowl that gave him the most room to act and a suit that let him act with his body. But he definitely stepped up to the plate and made Batman fans proud.
Also, I'm sorry....no offense to anyone who loves Batfleck, but performance-wise, I don't understand how anyone could say that's anywhere in the same league as what Rob does in the suit, with his eyes. I could never get past how it just feels like Ben Affleck with a voice modulator. Say what you will about Bale's voice, but he at least committed to something, and I feel he was an entirely different creature when he was in the suit vs. when he was Bruce Wayne.
I think we're due for a come to Jesus moment about how Affleck gets mainly gets praised because of the comics accurate suit, the Martha rescue sequence, and the fact that Ben admittedly got jacked as hell for the role. I think Affleck was a very solid Bruce Wayne in BvS, but his Batman was nothing special for me unless we're strictly talking that one action sequence...which is not Affleck doing the stunts.