Comics !-SHH Spider-Man Comic Awards 2007-!

[Dangerous]

Well, It's that time of year again, almost.
What with the screwy shipping schedule and there being only one remaining core book this year, now is as good a time.

For the last few years I have hosted this questionnaire so we could determine the boards opinions. This year, to make it more meaningful, I'm going to count up all the answers and post the poll results by January 10th 2008.

Now get busy worms!



Best Writer?

Best Pencils?

Best Inks?

Best Colors?

Best Cover?

Best Storyline?

Best Single Issue?

Best Title?

Best Mini Series/One Shot?

Best HC/TPB?



Best Supporting Character?

Best Sub Plot?

Best Fight?

Villain of the Year?



Worst Writer?

Worst Pencils?

Worst Storyline?

Worst Single Issue?

Worst Title?

 

[Kirk Langstrom]

Well, It's that time of year again, almost.
What with the screwy shipping schedule and there being only one remaining core book this year, now is as good a time.

For the last few years I have hosted this questionnaire so we could determine the boards opinions. This year, to make it more meaningful, I'm going to count up all the answers and post the poll results by January 10th 2008.

Now get busy worms!



Best Writer? Sacasa

Best Pencils? Garney

Best Inks? Danny Miki

Best Colors? Richard Isanove

Best Cover? SSM #38

Best Storyline? Back In Black

Best Single Issue? Amazing Spider-Man #542

Best Title? Sansational Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? Spider-Man/Red Sonja

Best HC/TPB? Spider-Man: The Icon



Best Supporting Character? Mary Jane

Best Sub Plot? Last Temptation Of Eddie Brock (I consider this a sub-plot behind the shooting of Aunt MAy)

Best Fight? Peter vs Kingpin (ASM #542)

Villain of the Year? Kingpin



Worst Writer?

Worst Pencils?

Worst Storyline?

Worst Single Issue?

Worst Title?

Avengers/Transformers

 

[The Comedian]

Best Writer? Brian Michael Bendis

Best Pencils? Mark Bagley

Best Cover? [SIZE=-1]Sensational Spider-Man #38 (click to view)[/SIZE]

Best Storyline? Death of the Goblin

Best Single Issue? Ultimate Spider-Man 113

Best Title? Ultimate Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? Spider-Man Reign

Best HC/TPB? Spider-Man Reign HC



Best Supporting Character? Kitty Pryde (Ultimate)

Best Sub Plot? Last Temptation of Eddie Brock

Best Fight? Spidey Vs Kingpin

Villain of the Year? Joe Quesada



Worst Writer? Peter David

Worst Pencils? Todd Nuack (Friendly Neighborhood)

Worst Storyline? The alternate universe Uncle Ben

Worst Single Issue? Spider-Man Fairy Tales # 4

Worst Title? Friendly Neighborhood

 

[SalaciousVC]

Best Writer?Brian Michael Bendis

Best Pencils?Mark Bagley

Best Cover?Cant decide


Best Title?Ultimate Spider-Man



Best HC/TPB?Kravens last hunt

Worst Writer? Fred Van Lente

Worst Pencils? Cory Hamscher

Worst Storyline? almost anything from Marvel Adventures Spider-Man

Worst Title? Marvel Adventures Spider-Man

 

[Spider-ManHero12]

Best Writer? Sacasa

Best Pencils? Ron Garney

Best Cover? SSM Issue #38

Best Storyline? Back in Black

Best Single Issue? Amazing Spider-Man Issue# 542

Best Title? Sensational Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? Spider-Man/Red Sonja

Best HC/TPB? Spider-Man: The Icon/Spider-Man: Birth of Venom



Best Supporting Character? Mary Jane

Best Sub Plot? The Last Temptation of Eddie Brock

Best Fight? Spidey vs. Kingpin

Villain of the Year? The Kingpin

 

[SpideyZERO]

Best Writer? Brian Michael Bendis

Best Pencils? Mark Bagley
Best Cover? Sensational Spider-Man Annual

Best Storyline? Back In Black

Best Single Issue? Sensational Spider-Man Annual

Best Title? Ultimate Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? Spider-Man Reign

Best HC/TPB? Ultimate Spider-Man Clone Saga



Best Supporting Character? Mary Jane

Best Sub Plot? Last Temptation of Eddie Brock

Best Fight? Ultimate Spider-Man VS Doctor Octopus

Villain of the Year? Aunt May

Worst Pencils? Ramon Baschs (SSM)

Worst Storyline? One More Day

Worst Single Issue? Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man 24

 

[USMC]

Best Writer? Brian Michael Bendis

Best Pencils? Mark Bagley
Best Cover? Sensational #38

Best Storyline? There were good storylines?

Best Single Issue? Same as above.

Best Title? Ultimate Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? None.

Best HC/TPB? Ultimate Spider-Man Clone Saga



Best Supporting Character? Mary Jane

Best Sub Plot? Last Temptation of Eddie Brock

Best Fight? Spidey vs. Kingpin

Villain of the Year? Joe Quesada

Worst Pencils? Joe Quesada

Worst Storyline? One More Day

Worst Single Issue? Joe Quesada has been the issue of why Spidey has sucked for so long. So I'm voting for him.

 

[Kraven]

Best Writer? Sacasa

Best Pencils? Garney

Best Cover? Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #23

Best Storyline? Back In Black (The ASM issues)

Best Single Issue? Sensational Spider-Man Annual

Best Title? Sensational Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? Spider-Man: Reign

Best HC/TPB? The Death of the Stacy's HC


Best Supporting Character? Mary Jane

Best Sub Plot? The J. Jonah Jameson confrontation

Best Fight? Spidey vs. The Kingpin

Villain of the Year? Kingpin


Worst Pencils? Ramon Bachs (from the SSM BIB issues)

Worst Storyline? The Ero plot in FNSM

Worst Single Issue? Sensational Spider-Man #41- from this point, it's obvious what's going to happen to the marriage. And as I read from another user, it doesn't even read like a fun story anymore... it's an agenda. With JQ preaching how he hates the marriage, it makes this feel even more forced.

Worst Title? None that I've read... they've all had their ups and downs.

 

[Norman Osborn]

Best Writer? Peter David

Best Pencils? Mark Bagley

Best Cover? ASM 539

Best Storyline? Taking Wing from FNSM

Best Single Issue? FNSM #23 OR SSM Annual 1

Best Title? FNSM

Best Mini Series/One Shot? Reign

Best Supporting Character? Mary Jane

Best Sub Plot? Jonah And Peter Parker

Best Fight? Kingpin

Villain of the Year? Quesada...yes it's cliche but no-one else sticks out in my mind...sadly

Worst Writer? Was indifferent to most of them..none stood out as "brutally bad" like JMS did in 2006

Worst Pencils? Quesada,

Worst Storyline? Probably One more day

Worst Title? ASM

 

[DestinyMakerX]

Best Writer? Brian Michael Bendis

Best Pencils? Joe Quesada

Best Inks? Drew Hennessy

Best Cover? Amazing Spider-Man #543

Best Storyline? Sandblasted (FNSM #1-3)

Best Single Issue? Sensational Spider-Man Annual 2007

Best Title? Ultimate Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? Spider-Man: Reign

Best HC/TPB? Spider-Man: The Icon HC



Best Supporting Character? MJ

Best Sub Plot? J. Jonah Jameson confrontation

Best Fight? Spidey vs Scarlet Spiders vs Vulturians

Villain of the Year? Sandman



Worst Writer? Stuart Moore (Marvel Comics Presents)

Worst Pencils? Ramon Bachs (Sensational Spider-Man)

Worst Storyline? One More Day

Worst Single Issue? Sensational Spider-Man #40

Worst Title? Sensational Spider-Man

 

[ragingdemon155]

Best Writer? Bendis

Best Pencils? Bagley

Best Cover? USM #100

Best Storyline? Ultimate Clone Saga

Best Single Issue? SSM Annual

Best Title? USM

Best Mini Series/One Shot? SSM Annual

Best Supporting Character? Kitty Pryde (Ultimate) and MJ (Ultimate)

Best Sub Plot? I wanted this to be JJJ confrontation with Peter but, I seriously felt like it fell flat. Didn't live up to the hype. I'm going with the "Last Temptation of Eddie Brock". How far the man as fallen.....shell of his former self.

Best Fight? Peter vs. Kingpin. I still don't understand how the hell Kingpin survived as long as he did but, yea that fight was the best so far.

Villain of the Year? Norman Osborn (Ultimate)

Worst Writer? JMS.

Worst Pencils? Quesada

Worst Storyline? One More Day. Yes its worse then Sins Past. Yes its worse then "The Unmasking". Yes it's worse then "the other".

Worst Single Issue? SSM 41. It never had to come down to this.

Worst Title? Any 616 related Spider-title. They've all had some awful moment this year.

 

[SpideyInATree]

One More Day isn't even over yet. Hahaha.

 

[ragingdemon155]

One More Day isn't even over yet. Hahaha.

You really think that a bad story containing of 4 issues can be saved with the last issue? Especially considering it's not hard to figure out how this is all going to end anyway.

 

[SpideyInATree]

Hey! You never know! Stranger things have happened.

Maybe they'll bring back Baby May or something. If they brought back Baby May and Ben Reilly out of this I'd take that deal. May/Scarlet Spider for the marriage.

Meh.

That's about an even trade in my eyes.

It's not like MJ is gonna die. They just won't be married, heh.

 

[Dangerous]

Best Writer? Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa

Best Pencils? Scot Eaton

Best Inks? Mike Allred / SMFT#4

Best Colors? Avalon's Dan Kemp / Sensational Spider-Man

Best Cover?

Best Storyline? Taking Wing / FNSM#14-16

Best Single Issue? Sensational Spider-Man #38

Best Title? Sensational Spider-Man

Best Mini Series/One Shot? REIGN. Fun if unoriginal

Best HC/TPB? Spider-Man Omnibus Vol1



Best Supporting Character? Betty Brant

Best Sub Plot? The Last Temptaion of Eddie Brock. Would have been better if he died.

Best Fight? Spidey Vs Iron Man / ASM#544

Villain of the Year? Joe Quesada



Worst Writer? JMS

Worst Pencils? Ramon Bachs

Worst Storyline? One More Day

Worst Single Issue? Sensational Spider-Man #41. Liked the freaky cover though

Worst Title? ASM

 

[Kevin]

Best Writer? Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa eek:Seriously, WTF type of name...? )

Best Pencils? Phil Jimenez

Best Storyline? ...

Best Single Issue? ... *sigh* Swing Shift. (I feel so dirty and want to cry now)

Best Title? Sensational Spider-Man closely followed by FNSM

Best Supporting Character? Mary Jane Watson forever.:heart:

Best Sub Plot? The unmasking

Best Fight? Peter Parker Vs JJJ.

Villain of the Year? Aunt May.