Dragon said:
Well, first we need to face the fact that ASM #121-122 are long past being trashed. They'll simply have to remain classic reads but have no bearing on present continuity. It's significance was destroyed when Osborn returned, and Peter did nothing to bring the man who murdered Gwen Stacy to justice.
True. But then why undermine it more by having the real Gwen come back? Why not just have Norman Osborn killed off or revealed to be a clone or something?
And as for the Wolfman run, it was pretty clear that Betty was meant to be nothing more than a brief fling. If it was meant to be more, it would have been easy enough to end her marriage and re-unite her with Peter.
Also, I believe it was a set-up to have Peter "explore his options" while apart from MJ. And something tells me, considering that it was during Wolfman's run that we got a glimpse of why MJ was afraid of commitment, he had plans to develop that subplot but his run ended before he could get around to it. It would be another five years, give or take a few issues before we actually learned the circumstances.
Going back to Gwen's resurrection- actually it's pretty simple at this point. And, sorry to say, but ugliness like Sins Past open the door even more to her return, by involving conspiracies, foreign countries and "hyper-aging children". A creative writer can pretty easily find a way to explain how Gwen didn't die.
One way could be that the person we thought was a clone of Gwen Stacy is actually the real Gwen Stacy and that the Gwen that fell of the bridge was a clone that, while complete, never attained life, so technically, the Green Goblin never actually killed her because the Gwen clone that Spidey thought was the real Gwen was never actually alive. How's that scenario?
And honestly, at this point, I'm more hoping they do bring her back. Frankly, all of this "Peter can't go on without MJ" stuff is wearing thin. If anything, Spidey really started to go dry after he married her. MJ has had her shot. 23 years is a good amount of time to give a character to become interesting. Gwen only got 8 and they whacked her. The only downside is that they'll likely drop the ball with Gwen as well. Hopefully Jeph Loeb will handle her return. PAD let me down, maybe Loeb will get it right.
I have a feeling that the Loeb mini, at least the way he hinted, would be structured like an episode of Lost, in which the series takes place in the "present" with flashbacks to the past (most likely the Stan Lee/John Romita run) that revolve around a common occurance, most likely a villain. This way, he can explore the deeper aspects of Peter's relationships between Gwen and MJ that we haven't known before and explore the idea how Peter's past has repercussions in the present and the difficulty in moving on because of it. At least that's what I envision.
As for the proported JMS/Joe Q mini they're planning to "fix Spider-Man," I somehow imagine this ridiculous scenario: Mary Jane gets a new acting gig on Broadway where she co-stars with a handsome actor. She and the actor hit it off well. Because Peter is busy being Spider-Man and juggling two jobs and MJ with preparing for her play, theyre too exhausted for any quality time and their sex-life takes a hit. MJ is invited to rehearse a scene at the actors apartment, one thing leads to another, and they have a one-night stand. Feeling guilty, MJ tries to avoid the actor, but, like the movie Unfaithful, he keeps hounding her. Peter, smart guy that he is, suspects MJ is having an affair and confronts her about it. After she breaks down and confesses, Peter is extremely angry and storms off into the night to vent his frustrations out as Spider-Man and MJ stays behind, sobbing. Meanwhile, the actor has managed to find the web-shooters Peter gave MJ for her wedding anniversary present in Web of Romance, and now knows MJs husband is Spider-Man. Jealous over the fact that MJ is married to a loser like Peter, he sells the info to Doctor Octopus, who rewards him by killing him. When Peter comes home, he finds Doc Ock is there and has captured MJ and Aunt May. Spidey and Doc Ock fight but in the battle, Aunt May is seriously injured. Doc Ock is imprisoned and chooses to hold on to the knowledge of Spider-Mans real identity for himself. Aunt May is hospitalized, which makes Peter feel guilty and finds it very hard to forgive MJ. MJ is guilt-ridden over her affair and how she was indirectly responsible for what has happened. Despite Peters urging that they can work things out, MJ decides to head back to Los Angeles, that while she loves Peter, she feels that her constant presence put him in danger.
So once again, Peter and MJ are legally separated. This leads to the back-to-basics approach JMS/Joe Q want for Spider-Man, in that Peter Parker is single again and, like the Clone Saga, there is no mention of him ever being married to MJ (only that they had a relationship). It also sets up the return and revamp of the original love triangle between Peter (now legally separated) Betty Brant (now a widow) and Liz Allen (now a widow and a single mom) with a jealous Flash (now once more a jock/jerk) from the Stan Lee/Steve Ditko run. They can claim theres added tension because Betty is in love with Peter but blames Spider-Man for being partly responsible for the death of Ned (and Peter feels guilty because the Hobgoblin, who gained his equipment from the Green Goblin, was involved). And Liz, being the widow of Peters best friend Harry, who was also the father of the Green Goblin, who blames him for the death of Harry, makes Peter conflicted, especially with Lizs son being the grandson of his arch-enemy and Flash having eyes for Liz again.