I know the story on Doomsday I have TPB on my shelf.
But that is my point he could not beat his greatest enemy. And you think he could go put against the strongest hero of all.
now not to sound rude. Everyone who say Supes will beat Hulk is say he would win because of his smarts but he was not smart enough to destroy Doomsday, Mother box has to do it for him.
And a big gripe I have here is most people was to put Hulk as the one word grey hulk. Sorry but he has been going for a very long time. And so has P.C superman.
So you have to weigh the fact you have for the CURRENT versions.
And with that in mind Hulk would win. HANDS DOWN
Again you need to stop comparing a version of Superman that does not exist anymore. We are talking about CURRENT 2007 Superman. Not 1993/1994 Superman. Current 2007 Superman is far superior in power compared to 1993/1994 Superman who battled Doomsday.
When we claim Superman's greatest assest in battle is his super intelligence we are talking about current Superman. After Supes got his powers back after being powerless after the Infinite Crisis his intelligence got a boost. You can't say "Super Intelligence my ass" then give an example from a story that happend years BEFORE he got the recent intelligence boost. That doesn't make sense.
We are weighing the facts of the current versions of these two characters. Did you not read my previous posts in which I give examples of CURRENT 2007 Superman? The Hulk cannot compete, Superman works at a much higher level than Hulk. These recent feats prove that. Hands down it is clear The Incredible Hulk isn't so "incredible" compared to current 2007 Superman.
Here they are again....
Superman's speed..able to move at 99% the speed of light within earth's atmosphere. He's been shown faster in outer space.
Superman's heat vision is as hot as the core of a star!!
Superman's strength...under normal power levels he can push the moon. The greatest strength/lifting feat by Hulk was bracing part of a large mountain. What the Hulk braces was 150 tons of mass. The moon is far heavier than part of a large mountain.
Superman's strength is so powerful that..
(Superman and Kal-L hit each other
once and destroyed Earth 2) or "shattering the boundaries of space and time" with strength alone (again, against Kal-L) -- hitting so hard that Elseworld versions of himself appear (Superman IC TPB).
Imperiex, at the conclusion of the Our Worlds at War story arc, had absorbed suffcient power to destroy the universe (and chain react the destruction of the multiverse). Imperiex, as Our Worlds at War Secret Files and Origins showed, was God's cosmic agent of universal creation and destruction -- Imperiex was the Big Bang, essentially.
(OT: Brainiac had this power trapped inside himself; Imperiex chose the sundipped Superman to break Imperiex out of Brainiac's cell. Later, Superman outmuscled the Imperiex-powered B-13. That should tell you just how powerful sundipped Superman was in that arc -- Superman was powerful enough to break a cell that a Big Bang level force could not; Superman was powerful enough to outmuscle B-13/Imperiex's "full counter thrusters!")
Imperiex's Probes were not as powerful as Imperiex himself. Nevertheless, an entire army of "solar converted" Daxamites could not put a single dent into a Probe. Only Superman, Doomsday and Zod managed to destroy Probes with their bare hands -- the rest had to use magical artifacts (Wonder Woman's shield and lasso, the Trident of Poseidon) or advanced tech (B-13 based nuclear tanks).
Initially, Superman needed intensive training and a power boost to so much as hang with a Probe in a fight -- a Probe who very casually threw Mongul across the galaxy.
Superman's invunerability is up there aswell.
Recent Superman in May's Action Comics, flies from Vega to Earth in seconds, or light years from a spaceship to the inside of a Sun Eater. He wades through Earth's assembled alien forces (J'onn, Powergirl, Kilowog, etc) in a matter of panels. One shots Despero with heat vision. And has his power depleted and is thrown through Earth and into its core and survives,
as well as survives a 700 light year anti-matter explosion when power depleted.
What is World War Hulk going to do against recent Superman, when recent Superman is depicted as that powerful? In my opinion, nothing but lose.
On average, Superman simply operates on a much higher scale than Marvel characters, including Hulk -- especially recently.
Also, Superman's greatest asset over the Hulk,
super intelligence. After Superman gets his powers back from being powerless for that one year after the Infinite Crisis, his intelligence has increased. Everything in his brain has been accelerated and amped up.
The greatest feat Hulk has done is destroying an asteroid twice the size of earth.
As a high end feat, this is very impressive for the Hulk. However, it does not compare to Superman's high end feats, such as:
1) Atomizing Earth 2 as the collateral damage of hitting, and being hit by, Kal-L; that is, the planet received no hit, but was simply destroyed as a collateral effect of a single punch on the two combatants' bodies. (Superman Infinite Crisis TPB)
2) Holding a black hole in one hand; then producing sufficient static electricity (via rubbing his hands) for Green Lantern to corral into a temporary containment force; then actually throwing the black hole into another black hole. (JLA 81 or 82)
(Incidentally black holes are the collapsed remains of super-massive stars that have, at minimum, the mass of at least 30 of our Sun, according to modern science.)
3) "Shattering the boundaries of space and time" by way of his fight against Kal-L; that is, hitting each other so hard that: 1) Superman and Kal-L actually switch into the past, present and future of each other's lives; 2) Elseworld versions of themselves actually manifested in time and space. (Superman Infinite Crisis TPB)
4) Superman reverses the vibratory pattern of an entire alternate Earth; does so from high orbit; that is, not even touching the planet. (Adventures of Superman Cannibal Planet issue)
5) Superman and Kal-L, who came up equal in their fight, manhandle Superboy Prime across galaxies and force him through Krypton's Sun. Superboy Prime, it was said and shown, was strong enough to move planets as easily as someone moves "chess pieces." (Infinite Crisis)
Superman splitting "a small Saturnian moon" in Lex 2000; or nearly knocking the Moon out of orbit merely by pounding on it (as one would pound on a table) while sick from Kryptonite poisoning (Til Death Do Us Part TPB).
When Superman and Flash last raced, Flash explained that, were Superman stopped dead in his tracks, it would destroy everything between the Flash's city and Moscow. That's a far larger tract of land than the Rockies -- it's an immense chunk of the planet.
Superman broke through a dome powerful enough to contain a nuclear blast with a stray backhand when he fought the Eradicator.
Superman also punched Bizarro through the planet, from Metropolis to China, in one hit.