Tank Girl (1995) Vs Super Girl (1984)

[OutRiddled]

Which movie is better? Or which sucked more? Which character is better? Which actress is better? etc, etc..

Discuss.

 

[The Sarge]

Tank Girl isn't a great movie, but it's streets ahead of Supergirl in almost every way.
Supergirl has little- to know story, and the main character is an airhead that just bumbles her way through the movie. So many big unanswered questions, like- Krypton exploded, how are you guys around?
Tankgirl had wicked art direction, and Kangaroo People.

 

[kedrell]

Supergirl. Sure it's cheesy and campy and makes little sense and is incredibly stupid(still better than Superman IV though)but at least Helen Slater was a good fit for the role and easy to watch. She should have had a better film behind her. Where as Tank Girl I found to be utterly unwatchable trash. And Lori Petty only knows how to do one thing: be annoying.

 

[Bowie]

Wow. It's like asking me if I'd rather eat vomit or ****.

 

[OutRiddled]

I think they're both underrated. Supergirl is a solid 80's fantasy flick with a strong central performance by Helen Slater. Tank Girl is edgy, punk and offbeat with great one-liners plus Lori Petty was born to play the role.

 

[FIREPHOENIX]

Supergirl hands down. I love this movie. It's something I can't explain. IT'S a cult favorite of mine. Love the cast. Helen Slater is just awesome as Supergirl.

 

[Thundarr]

Supergirl. Sure it's cheesy and campy and makes little sense and is incredibly stupid(still better than Superman IV though)but at least Helen Slater was a good fit for the role and easy to watch. She should have had a better film behind her. Where as Tank Girl I found to be utterly unwatchable trash. And Lori Petty only knows how to do one thing: be annoying.

This