The All New State Your Opinion on a DC Character Thread

[Roose Bolton]

You won't be thrilled when you actually see how they brought him back...

 

[Mystirious]

Preferred her in her own role on the GCPD.

I liked the idea and execution of the passing of the torch in 52, and the way Sage's death and her journy to be worthy of the mantle moreso than any appearance where Renee's actually been The Question though.

Actually the way Sage's death was handled and their arc was probably my favourite thing about 52 in terms of arcs. There were some cool moments, but as an arc I liked their stuff the best.

Renee's story and Batwoman's were definitely my favourite parts of 52 I loved those stories and they were the parts I enjoyed most out of the whole series

Rucka did a fab job with those storylines

Them and Egg Fu

'Cause everyone loves an evil super science egg

 

[Wesley Dodds]

I absolutely LOVE The Question.

I'd love a movie with Michael C. Hall or someone as Vic.

 

[Mystirious]

I'm not a big fan of Vic in the comic books but I loved him in the cartoon

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Yeah, Question Authority is one of the best JLU episodes.

"The plastic tips at the ends of shoelaces are called aglets. Their true purpose is sinister!"

 

[Mystirious]

He was amazing

 

[Anubis]

Well, over all, she's liked, but not as the Question.

Spoiler

hehe, dick.

Duela Dent

 

[TheCorpulent1]

Never gave the slightest f*** about her.

 

[SuperFerret]

I have no clue what that is.

 

[Anubis]

Do you know what her deal was?

She was from the Crime Syndicate Earth, and her dear old "dad" was none other than the Jester.....aka the good joker......yeah.

If you've noticed, I just did the first three characters from the original thread, just female versions.....that's what I'm reduced to.

 

[TheCorpulent1]

Yeah, I know her deal. I just don't care. She's an imitation character--a little mini-me of the Joker the same way X-23 is a meaningless Wolverine clone, only Duela's even further diluted by the fact that she can't even use the Joker's schtick because she's a hero.

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

HOLY and i thought i was going to get crap for bringing up "THE SHROUD" but you went waaaayyy back BATMAN!

freaking baby girl who pretended to be the jokers daughter but really was

dead beat dad 2 face's who then joined the

who then changed her name to

and we all know who did a better job with that name!

...............all that for HELL NAAAAWWW!!! she sucks!!

* oh and caught that little gender role reversal thing. i dig it!

 

[Mystirious]

Well, over all, she's liked, but not as the Question.

Spoiler

hehe, dick.

I totally ship Huntress and Renee together

Duela Dent

She was a pretty fun wacky character

And I'm still that they killed her off during Countdown

 

[Roose Bolton]

Good thing countdown got to her before I could

 

[Anubis]

I wish they'd explore the Crime Syndicate Earth more. I've always found the concept of all of Gotham's crazy's being the good guys and Batman and Robin being the bad guys to be interesting as hell.

 

[CLARKY]

Carter Hall is supposed to be a sophisticated gentleman and a archeologist, not the snarling Wolverine rip-off that the hack of all hacks Geoff Johns turned him into. Just like with Barry Allen and Hal Jordan, the character Johns wrote named "Carter Hall" has nothing to do with the real character that Gardner Fox created.

Because he is violent andbrutal does not make him aWolverine rip-off at all. Boring admittedly. Not to my taste maybe. Not to yours surely. But a rip-off?! In fact I even find it interesting, he needs to temper himself, he is like an old-school barbarian, I don't know, it rings a bell, for me.

The other Hawkgirl/Hawkwomen are a mixed bag. Silver Age Shayera is okay, JL cartoon Shayera is lame, and the latter day Hawkworld Hawkwoman is annoying. Kendra sucked.

JL cartoon Shayera is boring?!?!? In what aspect??

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

I wish they'd explore the Crime Syndicate Earth more. I've always found the concept of all of Gotham's crazy's being the good guys and Batman and Robin being the bad guys to be interesting as hell.

i wholeheartly agree with that! that would be awesome!!

 

[Mystirious]

I wish they'd explore the Crime Syndicate Earth more. I've always found the concept of all of Gotham's crazy's being the good guys and Batman and Robin being the bad guys to be interesting as hell.

I'd love a mini series or something set on that Earth about the parallel versions of the heroes and villains there

Good thing countdown got to her before I could

You monster

 

[Anubis]

Well, guess nobody likes her....except Mysti, but she likes anything with a vagina.

Spoiler

She's not REALLY the Joker's daughter you know.....

Hourman II

 

[Wesley Dodds]

I really like Rick. He's just a really good guy, it's cool that he's actually in a healthy, happy marriage too. Weirdly refreshing in comics.

 

[Mystirious]

Well, guess nobody likes her....except Mysti, but she likes anything with a vagina.

I was going to object but then I realised that yeah you're totally right 'Nubsy

The clown thing is a plus as well. Clowns are hawt

Spoiler

She's not REALLY the Joker's daughter you know.....

Oh snap

Hourman II

I dig Rick

He's a genuinely nice person and pretty bad ass too

 

[Hush]

Hourman II is ****ing awesome. Totally amazing character that needs an ongoing.

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

all freaking Hourmen are Awesome!! Cause like Missy Elliot said "i dont want any 8 minute man!"

* if i get some tequila in me it can last longer than a hour ,but then i wonder why i am in an alley and where are my clothes and cops are around! hahahahahahahaha

 

[Anubis]

Huh, tequila actually does the reverse for me. ......

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

Huh, tequila actually does the reverse for me. ......

rookie!