The Comics' Universe RPG Application

[Saved]

I'd think not, but dibs is a gentlemen's reserve of sorts. Also, Wildstorm is a sect of DC Comics, because my Heroes trade says DC Comics on it.

 

[Eddie Brock]

I'd think not, but dibs is a gentlemen's reserve of sorts. Also, Wildstorm is a sect of DC Comics, because my Heroes trade says DC Comics on it.

Yes, I know Wildstorm is a division of DC, but it's generally considered a separate publisher. Anyway, I suppose I don't have to say who I'm gunning for.

 

[Byrd Man]

Any particular reason behind these opinions? I'd really appreciate some counter-arguments to add to the debate.

Well, I'm mostly against it cause, like it was said before, it was mess with the whole tone and feel of these characters, they need the world they're in to be the same. Dr. Manhattan can't be the superweapon he is when ****ing Invincible and the rest of those guys are around.

 

[Saved]

Dr. Manhattan can't be the superweapon he is when ****ing Invincible and the rest of those guys are around.

Actually, that's the first good point I've heard.

 

[Batman]

Dr. Manhattan can't be the superweapon he is when ****ing Invincible and the rest of those guys are around.

Invincible is hardly comparable to a guy who can freaking grow on impact and create crystalized structures on the moon with little more than a thought, so, I think Manhattan's superweapon status would be fine. Just because he isn't the only powered hero doesn't mean he can't be the most powerful one on the face of the Earth. Besides, we could always say he was the only remaining superpower not-in-hiding between the purge and now.

 

[Spike_x1]

I'm with Byrd, but MB already knows that.

 

[SenseiofCheese]

The Watchmen characters are the way they are because of the law that was passed in their universe, outlawing vigilantes. The way they're written in the series is almost certainly the way people would try to write them, but that's not possible since they wouldn't BE that way to begin with if they were a part of this universe.

 

[Keyser Soze]

I think "Watchmen" characters should be allowed. If only to see how well they can be pulled off. The very thought of an MB-written Rorsach has me salivating. We've let everyone else and their dog in. What's the worst that can happen from including the "Watchmen" characters? The RPG dies? It could very well die anyway. But by including the "Watchmen" characters, at least MB and co can say they went absolutely all-out, and loaded this RPG with EVERYTHING they could possibly want, no holding back.

 

[Byrd Man]

Meh. I'm still against it. Doesn't hurt my feelings if you allow it. I won't pitch a fit and stomp my feet until they're banned. I'd still like to play Marv, although I'm damn sure I would make a perfect Comedian.

 

[Keyser Soze]

Meh. I'm still against it. Doesn't hurt my feelings if you allow it. I won't pitch a fit and stomp my feet until they're banned. I'd still like to play Marv, although I'm damn sure I would make a perfect Comedian.

I think you have the right attitude. It might not be your cup of tea, but nobody's forcing you to RP with Watchmen characters. I think it's best to let it go ahead. If it works, other players get to be happy campers. And if it doesn't, you get to say "I told you so."

 

[Batman]

The Watchmen characters are the way they are because of the law that was passed in their universe, outlawing vigilantes. The way they're written in the series is almost certainly the way people would try to write them, but that's not possible since they wouldn't BE that way to begin with if they were a part of this universe.

Rorschach didn't snap because of that vigilante law. Comedian was bat**** insane from the beginning. Manhattan really doesn't apply to the vigilante mold, given he was a goverment agent. Nite-Owl and Silk Spectre can find other, just as valid reasons to have given up. Laurie, specifically, has every reason to, given that she only came into the hero buisness because of her mother. And Ozymandias could have just as easily went public as a result of the purge of superheroes and supervillains.

Sounds pretty much to me like they could be the same, regardless.

 

[Byrd Man]

I think you have the right attitude. It might not be your cup of tea, but nobody's forcing you to RP with Watchmen characters. I think it's best to let it go ahead. If it works, other players get to be happy campers. And if it doesn't, you get to say "I told you so."

For now, I shall sit up here on my high horse and wait to say those magic words....

 

[SenseiofCheese]

Rorschach didn't snap because of that vigilante law. Comedian was bat**** insane from the beginning. Manhattan really doesn't apply to the vigilante mold, given he was a goverment agent. Nite-Owl and Silk Spectre can find other, just as valid reasons to have given up. Laurie, specifically, has every reason to, given that she only came into the hero buisness because of her mother.

Sounds pretty much to me like they could be the same, regardless.

Sounds to me like you're a filthy ****e!

But, really, there are completely valid reasons to include the Watchmen characters. And, if you do, I will still be taking part in this once it starts. That said, I just don't agree with having the Watchmen people in this shared universe.

 

[Batman]

Sounds to me like you're a filthy ****e!

You know you love it.

But, really, there are completely valid reasons to include the Watchmen characters. And, if you do, I will still be taking part in this once it starts. That said, I just don't agree with having the Watchmen people in this shared universe.

That's fair enough. Nobody has to like it's inclusion - I already expected that to be the case, even if a compromise could be reached.

As long as no one is actually bothered enough by it to leave the RPG and/or rant endlessly about it happening. That's my biggest fear, as far as this issue goes. I just want people to have fun, the more talented RP'ers drawn to the game, the more it becomes a great experience.

 

[Byrd Man]

That's fair enough. Nobody has to like it's inclusion - I already expected that to be the case, even if a compromise could be reached .

No.

Not even in the face of armageddon, never compromise.

I hadz to do it.

 

[Batman]

No.

Not even in the face of armageddon, never compromise.

I hadz to do it.

Sad part is, I freaking knew that would happen the minute I typed that, but left it in anyway.

 

[Keyser Soze]

So now that the "Watchmen" issue is (kinda) resolved, what about Jonah Hex? Would anyone object to me using time-travel shenanigans to get him into the mix here?

 

[Batman]

If there'd be no other way for you to do it, go ahead. Planetary is being allowed, and their whole gimmick is time-travel.

I just want to avoid as much of it as possible, so it doesn't become convulted. But if Jonah Hex is one of the only ones to use it, all is good.

 

[Johnny Blaze]

So...who here has their eyes on Hellboy?

 

[Catman_prb]

Nope. But John Constantine joining the BPRD? Maybe

 

[Batman]

So...who here has their eyes on Hellboy?

That'd be SuperFerret.

 

[Carnage27]

I have ideas in my head for a re imagining of the Turtles' origin, but I need to know, how many years has it been since the purge?

 

[Batman]

I have ideas in my head for a re imagining of the Turtles' origin, but I need to know, how many years has it been since the purge?

I was thinking about twenty years, roughly. But I'm open to suggestions for an alternative timetable.

 

[Carnage27]

I was thinking about twenty years, roughly. But I'm open to suggestions for an alternative timetable.

Perfect. Thanks, MB.

 

[Batman]

In the event that Watchmen characters are intergrated into this universe, I'm going to go ahead and throw down a dibs on Rorschach.

It may be low of me to do so... infact, I'm pretty sure it is. But dammit, it's Rorschach.