The "Detective Skills" thread

[uniqueweasel]

I wonder if perhaps some internal dialogue in a few scenes could perhaps explain how he has come to conclusions, without going all out dusting for prints and such.

 

[DrCosmic]

If you want a Sherlock Holmes effect... just ape Sherlock holmes

1) People walk in, and Batman starts saying things he can't possibly know about them, they ask why, and he explains stuff about their shoelaces and body odor and whatever. Booom.

2) In fights or action scenes, use slow mo and zoom to focus in on what Batman is noticing, then, things come to full speed and he does just the right thing to incapacitate/dismantle the problem.

Easy peasy. Of course, unlike the comics, you have to earn that, especially since most of the audience is familiar with the more... thuggish batman from recent movies and video games.

 

[Marvin]

It's the deductive skills we haven't really seen much of yet. Bruce as an analytical fellow, able to use forensics is all well and good, but that's not what sets him apart, it's his steel trap of a mind.

Deciding to acquire a super invention(probably from fox) that finds finger prints from shattered bullet casings isn't quite up to par imo. It just shows initiative and resource.

I agree the detective skills have been lacking but it really is the level of analytical thinking that's really missing I think. To know Bruce is the smartest in the room(and not just because he's in the know) is a trait I almost never see in these films. Especially when he's faced off with his rogues.
For example, imagine if it was Bane in that room interrogating joker? The bane that wasn't a henchmen by the end of the film that is. You would see a certain level of wits being fired right back at the joker, not just a lost hero screaming for answers.

Bats just seems way too off the curve at too many junctures. But, it does make for a more traditional kind of entertainment.

When bruce came running to fox to get him "back in the game", I officially gave up on the characterization, personally. Scott Snyder's current work is probably a good middle of the road.