A film that unfortunately isn't as good as its predecessor. I appreciate and support the direction it wanted to go in, but the execution was lacking some. The relationship drama between Peter and MJ, first of all, was pretty boring. I thought the inclusion of John Jameson as a walking plot device to drive the two of them apart was unnecessary and made things more complicated than they really needed to be. It did nothing but make both characters look bad for attempting to pursue a relationship in spite of him (especially MJ, who gleefully left him standing at the altar when she could have simply called off the wedding before it got to that point).
I like that Peter's superhero activities were negatively affecting his personal life and I thought the film did a very good job of getting that point across. I thought the idea of him being able to suppress his abilities was pretty damn creative. However...the fact that he chose to do so knowing full well that Octavius was on the loose, doing God knows what was incredibly irresponsible of him, not to mention stupid. I realize that might have been the point, but they took it too far. Octavius isn't just some thug; he's a freaking genius, a violent one I might add, who took it upon himself to rob banks and take old women hostage. Peter choosing not to pursue him in favor of stealing a girl away from another man makes him look like a terrible hero. (Failing to act while someone was getting viciously beaten was pretty crappy of him as well.)
Speaking of Octavius...not only is he incredibly overrated (the character and the actor), but perhaps he isn't a genius after all, because he did some pretty stupid ****. As part of an agreement he made with Harry Osborn, he had to find Peter and force him to tell him where Spider-Man was. So instead of...I don't know...asking Harry where he lives (he knows they're buddies), he (for some reason) decides to wing it and try his luck at bumping into him on the street or something. As luck would have it, he finds Peter, and the first thing he does is toss a ****ing car through the window of the coffee shop he's in. Not too long after that, he tosses Peter into a brick wall and just stands there and watches as the building falls apart on top of him. What the ****? I'm also curious as to why he made a deal with Harry when he could've just threatened him and saved himself the time.
That fight between him and Spidey on the train was beyond awesome, though. I don't think any other superhero film has topped it yet.
I lost all sympathy for Harry the moment he made that deal. Was he honestly willing to put half of New York in danger just to settle a grudge with Spider-Man? What an *******.
Also: how did he know where to find Octavius? He didn't know he had MJ, and therefore wasn't concerned about her safety, and the plan was always to bring Spider-Man back to Harry's place to exchange him for the Tritium.
Lastly: I had a problem with how the film defines being a hero. It's not a curse. It's not all about giving up your hopes and dreams. It's about doing the right thing. It's about being selfless. It's about using your gifts responsibly and doing your part to help your community. Sure, sometimes you might have to make some sacrifices, but that's what comes with the job; it's not the job itself.
Man...I can tell the guys behind Smallville were a part of this. It really shows.
5/10.