Drizzle
Manifesting that Emmy
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2007
- Messages
- 36,489
- Reaction score
- 39,311
- Points
- 118
Agreed about Joel and Tommy. I do believe they're going for more realism and I'm good with that. Admittedly, perhaps wrongly, I think the appearance of Abby already looking like she's fully in Part II mode had me side eye what's going on with Ellie so far.I see and thanks for helping me out.
I can get what you mean. I think it's them going for a bit more a realistic appoarch. I thought the training early on really emphasized that. Ellie's skilled. But she's also a tiny person who's been living a pretty easy life all things considered thanks to the community.
I also think it's playing up the paternal nature of Joel and Tommy which I do really like.
Yeah I gotta echo what many are saying in here, this was a fantastic episode. I played the 2nd game in 2023 and got the platinum, so it's still quite fresh in my mind, but I do like the creative choices and changes they made here.
The casting is all brilliant, but Isabella Merced as Dina definitely stole the show, which is no easy feat with this cast. I already can't wait for more and I really wonder how much of Abby's story we're due to get this season.
I found Ellie's immaturity and carelessness in this premiere so utterly odd (in an apocalypse situation that she grew up in no less) that I thought this must be intentional to further the dynamic between her and Abby. I'm glad to see someone else feels that's the way it's going.Agreed about Joel and Tommy. I do believe they're going for more realism and I'm good with that. Admittedly, perhaps wrongly, I think the appearance of Abby already looking like she's fully in Part II mode had me side eye what's going on with Ellie so far.
If the show changes it up a bit and has Ellie slightly less mature, maybe a bit more naive, to further highlight her change and to match Abby's brutality, that's a welcome addition to the character.
Pobably more in the game. I think that flashback right after the events of the first season was intentional as its important to humanize and give her a sympathetic early on bc there will be a break between season. Not sure how they will break down the seasons but I suspect we will see more of her perspective once Ellie gets going on her journeyYeah I gotta echo what many are saying in here, this was a fantastic episode. I played the 2nd game in 2023 and got the platinum, so it's still quite fresh in my mind, but I do like the creative choices and changes they made here.
The casting is all brilliant, but Isabella Merced as Dina definitely stole the show, which is no easy feat with this cast. I already can't wait for more and I really wonder how much of Abby's story we're due to get this season.
I found Ellie's immaturity and carelessness in this premiere so utterly odd (in an apocalypse situation that she grew up in no less) that I thought this must be intentional to further the dynamic between her and Abby. I'm glad to see someone else feels that's the way it's going.
Some people want a total video game adaptation. I saw some one complain about Tommy’s wife because she is black. I am looking forward to seeing Abby’s fighting style in live action. Can’t wait to hear the complaints of her not being muscular and hardcore.
Also, I haven't played part 2, though I know the beats, but how exactly does Ellie know the truth of what happened with the fireflies?
Also, how do those who played it feel about them giving Abby's crew set up this early in the story, rather than introducing her as a more mysterious character later on??
Throwing in that opening was my one big issue with the episode. I thought that it felt too leading and scared that you wouldn't understand what's going on. You kinda need to reveal it this season because of the structure of releasing a TV show I think, but I would have preferred holding onto the specifics a little while longer.
I saw a comment on TikTok that said speculated Abby's motivation was revealed right off the bat to prevent Kaitlyn Dever from getting the same kind of threats online that Laura Bailey did, which seems farfetched but who knows.
I guess it's more obvious to those who know what's going to happen but to me it felt like if Game of Thrones season 3 had opened up on a scene with Walder Frey, Roose Bolton and Tywin Lannister meeting up and saying "So we gotta do something about Robb Stark".
Gonna ask you to explain and unpack this.Good start of the season, but Bella Ramsey as Ellie just isn't it.
Not only she looks nothing like Ellie from the games, but she doesn't even get her mannerisms either. If anything, she comes off as an annoying angry boy.
I adore both games and have played them numerous times. The show nails every other aspect from them, except Ellie's casting.
Which is a shame, because this could've been a 10/10 video game adaptation.
P.S Isabela as Dina is great.
Catherine O'Hara keeps losing husbands left and right haha. I am curious about what the hell happened between Eugene and Joel.