The Official Contest of Marvels 3 Discussion Thread

[Phaedrus45]

Keep
Amadeus Cho
Hiroim
Korg
Miek

Potential
Brood


Works for me.

 

[wiegeabo]

Does Cho bring anything to the game besides genius? Does he have tech, weapons, resources and what not? If not, I say potential. The rest are fine the way you have them.

 

[Franklin Richards]

He does do that whole "probability" thing. Throw a rock here, it bounces off this, a bucket falls on the head of the bad guy. Sort of a Deus Ex Rube Goldberg.

 

[wiegeabo]

Interesting...then keep. He'll be a challenge to write. And to write against.

 

[JewishHobbit]

Updated list...

Alpha Flight

1. Arachne
2. Aurora
3. Beta Ray Bill
4. Madison Jeffries (Weapon X)
5. Northstar
6. Sasquatch
7. Shaman
8. Snowbird
9. Talisman
10. The Master
11. U.S. Agent
12. Weapon Omega (Michael Pointer)
13. Wild Child

Avengers

14. Annex
15. Black Panther
16. Bloodwraith
17. Bulldozer
18. Captain America (Steve Rogers)
19. Captain America (Bucky)
20. Cloud 9
21. Constrictor
22. Crusader
23. Firebird
24. Grim Reaper
25. Hank Pym
26. Hawkeye (Kate Bishop)
27. Hercules
28. Hulkling
29. Iron Fist
30. Iron Lad
31. Iron Man
32. Jack of Hearts
33. Jocasta
34. Justice
35. Kang
36. K.I.A.
37. Klaw
38. Komodo
39. Living Lightning
40. Lord Templar
41. Luke Cage
42. Mandarin
43. Ms. Marvel
44. Patriot
45. Piledriver
46. Proctor
47. Prodigy (Ritchie Gilmore)
48. Pulsar
49. Purple Man
50. Quicksilver
51. Rage
52. Red Skull
53. Ronin (Clint Barton)
54. Sentry
55. Sersi
56. She-Hulk
57. Slapstick
58. Speed
59. Spider-Woman (Veranke)
60. Starfox
61. Stature
62. Taskmaster
63. Trauma
64. The Hood
65. Thunderball
66. Tigra
67. Ultra Girl
68. Vision (Original)
69. War Machine
70. Wasp
71. Wiccan
72. Wonderman
73. Wrecker
74. X-51

Cosmic

75. Air-Walker
76. Annihilus
77. Astra
78. Blastaar
79. Bug
80. Captain Marvel (Genis)
81. Chod
82. Darkhawk
83. Deathbird
84. Drax
85. Earthquake
86. Firelord
87. Gamora
88. Gladiator
89. Harvest (Phalanx)
90. Havoc
91. Korvus
92. Mantis
93. Marvel Girl
94. Maxam
95. Moondragon (Human)
96. Neutron
97. Nova
98. Oracle
99. Paibok The Power Skrull
100. Plutonia
101. Polaris
102. Praxagora
103. Quasar (Phyla Vell)
104. Raza
105. Red Shift
106. Rocket Racoon
107. Ronan The Accuser
108. Star Lord (Peter Quill)
109. Super Skrull
110. Titan
111. Ultron (Phalanx)
112. Vulcan
113. Warlock (Phalanx)
114. Warstar
115. Wraith (Zak-Del)
116. Zenith

Exiles

117. Blink (Exiles)
118. Holocaust
119. Hyperion (Exiles)
120. Mimic (Exiles)
121. Morph (Exiles)
122. Psylocke
123. Sabretooth (Exiles)
124. Sasquatch (Exiles)
125. Spider (Exiles)
126. Thunderbird (Exiles)

Fantastic Four

127. Agatha Harkness
128. Crystal
129. Diablo
130. Doctor Doom
131. Frankie Raye
132. Gorgon (Inhuman)
133. Grey Gargoyle
134. Human Torch
135. Invisible Woman
136. Karnak
137. Lyja Lazerfist
138. Marvel Girl (Valeria Richards)
139. Medusa
140. Morgan Le Fay
141. Mr. Fantastic
142. Nathaniel Richards
143. Psi-Lord
144. Psycho Man
145. Thing
146. Thundra
147. Trapster

Incredible Hulk

148. Abomination
149. Absorbing Man
150. Amadeus Cho
151. Bi-Beast
152. Boomerang
153. Doctor Sampson
154. Half Life
155. Hiroim
156. Hulk (Savage)
157. Iron Clad (U-Foes)
158. Korg
159. Leader
160. Maestro
161. Mercy
162. Miek
163. Mr. Hyde
164. Speedfreek
165. Super Adaptoid
166. Tyrannus
167. Vapor (U-Foes)
168. Vector (U-Foes)
169. Wendigo
170. X-Ray (U-Foes)
171. Zzzax

Potentials
Ant-Man (Eric O'Grady)
Ant-Man (Scott Lang)
Captain Britain (Kelsey Leigh)
Debrii
Doorman
Echo
Gorilla Girl
Guardian (James Hudson)
Hardball
Jessica Jones
Mr. Immortal
Mutant Zero
Pagan
Phobos
Brood (No-Name)
Madman
Protocide
The Ghost
The Presence
Scarlet Spider (MVP)
Scarlet Witch
Silver Claw
Squirrel Girl
Vindicator
Whirlwind
Windshear
Adam Warlock
Cosmo
G-Type
Groot
Hepzibah
Quasar (Wendall Vaughn)
Smasher
Blackbolt
Huntara
Jolen
Maximus the Mad
Nahrees
Red Ghost
Texas Twister
Vibraxas
Wizard
Woz

 

[JewishHobbit]

And the next list... which I'm guessing will be moved around a bit. And I'm off to work again...

Marvel Knights

149. Black Widow
150. Bullseye
151. Daredevil
152. Elektra
153. Kingpin
155. Owl
156. Punisher
157. Shang-Chi
158. Typhoid Mary
159. Zaran the Weapons Master
160. Man-Thing
161. Gladiator II
163. Fu Manchu
164. Yellow Claw
165. Scorpio

 

[POWdER-man]

Marvel Knights

Keep
Bullseye
Daredevil
Elektra
Owl
Punisher
Shang-Chi
Typhoid Mary
Man-Thing


Drop (I just don't see any of these characters getting very far)
Black Widow
Kingpin
Zaran the Weapons Master
Gladiator II
Fu Manchu
Yellow Claw
Scorpio

 

[wiegeabo]

Marvel Knights

Keep
Bullseye
Daredevil
Elektra
Owl
Punisher
Shang-Chi
Typhoid Mary
Man-Thing


Drop (I just don't see any of these characters getting very far)
Black Widow
Kingpin
Zaran the Weapons Master
Gladiator II
Fu Manchu
Yellow Claw
Scorpio

I say keep Black Widow as a potential. She's a pretty good regular and might have access to good resources depending on location.

Yellow Claw may also be a potential depending on how strong his telepathy is and if someone can find a good bio.

Need a good bio on Scorpio before deciding.

 

[JewishHobbit]

Keep
Daredevil
Elektra
Kingpin
Man-Thing
Punisher
Scorpio (Jacob Fury)
Typhoid Mary - She's just been revealed to be Mutant Zero from the Initiative, but due to some open questioned still, I say take her from her appearances prior to the Initiative. I'm thinking that may have been around Daredevil 50 unless she showed up after that.

Potential
Black Widow

Drop
Zaran the Weapons Master
Fu Manchu
Gladiator II
Owl
Shang-Chi
Yellow Claw

Move
Bullseye - Keep, but move to Thunderbolts section.

 

[JewishHobbit]

I say keep Black Widow as a potential. She's a pretty good regular and might have access to good resources depending on location.

Yellow Claw may also be a potential depending on how strong his telepathy is and if someone can find a good bio.

Need a good bio on Scorpio before deciding.

Here's a good bio for Scorpio.

I think Yellow Claw sounds good also but couldn't find a good enough bio to give us levels of his telepathy. Due to that I say drop.

 

[JewishHobbit]

Other Possible Additions

Lady Bullseye
White Tiger
Black Tarantula

 

[JewishHobbit]

Provided W agreed with the rest of Powder's suggestions... here's where we stand thus far...

Definate Keep
Black Tarantula
Bullseye
Daredevil
Elektra
Punisher
Typhoid Mary
Man-Thing
White Tiger

Definate Potential
Black Widow
Lady Bullseye

Definate Drop
Zaran the Weapons Master
Gladiator II
Fu Manchu

1 Vote Keep/ 1 Vote Drop
Kingpin
Owl
Shang-Chi

1 Vote Keep/ 1 Vote Potential
Scorpio (Jacob Fury)

Still In Question
Yellow Claw


After we finalize this list, we might as well change the section name to Daredevil and just move the few that doesn't fit elsewhere.

 

[wiegeabo]

Scorpio is a potential.

Keep White Tiger and Black Tarantula.

Drop or potential Lady Bullseye.

 

[JewishHobbit]

Okay, updated the previous list. Yellow Claw still needs a definate placing from you, then we're just waiting on Phaed.

And just to keep things moving... once Phaed gives his input on the above section, the next section is MI:13. As of now there's only one name on it, so I went ahead and moved everyone that's in the book to this section so we can look them over. This is an easy section so I figured it'd be okay to just quickly go over it as well.

MI: 13
Black Knight (Dane Whitman)
Blade
Captain Britain (Brian Braddock)
Faiza Hussain
John the Skrull
Pete Wisdom
Spitfire
Union Jack

In which I say...

Keep
Black Knight (Dane Whitman)
Blade
Captain Britain (Brian Braddock)
John the Skrull - Another skrull, but one with more experience and just cooler all the way around. Good fighter too.
Pete Wisdom
Spitfire
Union Jack - He just had a cameo, but he's dating Spitfire and is a British hero. I figured this would be a good place for him to stay.

Drop
Faiza Hussain - Interesting powers, but she's brand new and there isn't much to go on as far as how her powers work.

 

[wiegeabo]

I'll say drop Yellow Claw. I keep thinking we had problems with him in a prior contest because information was so lacking.

 

[Phaedrus45]

The characters I added are listed under Marvel Knights in 2005:

Keep
Blade - If we do Marvel Horror, he could be moved there
Cloak
Daredevil
Elektra
Ghost Rider - Is under Marvel Knights for a while...but, if we do Marvel Horror, he might be better there.
Kingpin
Man-Thing
Moon Knight
Nick Fury
Punisher
Scorpio (Jacob Fury)
Steel Wind - From Ghost Rider, she seems pretty bad-ass. But, like above, do we want Ghost Rider under Marvel Horror?
Typhoid Mary

Potential
Black Widow
Dagger

Drop
Zaran the Weapons Master
Fu Manchu
Gladiator II
Owl
Shang-Chi
Yellow Claw

Move
Bullseye - Keep, but move to Thunderbolts section.

 

[Phaedrus45]

I saw Blade was now under MI:13. I still consider many of those characters in different categories, and not really sure we need a section for MI:13, especially since that series has only had about 7 issues. Other team books, like Thunderbolts, is more widely established. I would even suspect by the time another season comes after this, MI:13 might not exist anymore.

 

[JewishHobbit]

I'm okay with Steel Wind. And I say lets go ahead and do a Marvel Horror section. We can move Steel Wind, Ghost Rider, and Man-Thing there. Based on your previous list for it, and the next list "Midnight Suns" now would be a good time to compile that list.

As for MI:13, I think it's good because there are a lot of British/European characters and this book compiles them all, as apposed to them being scattered all over. I think if someone were looking for one of those characters right now, they'd look for an MI:13 section. So I say leave it be and if/when we do another season we'll divy them up if needed.

 

[JewishHobbit]

HEY!!!! Why are we all Side-Kicks!!!

 

[JewishHobbit]

Okay... updated Marvel Knights. I divyed them up because MK is really just alternate stories and such now. We'll discuss Thunderbolts, Misc. and Marvel Horrors as we come to them, but since we're already past Daredevil, is there any additions anyone wants to make to that section?

Daredevil
Black Tarantula
Daredevil
Elektra
Kingpin
Typhoid Mary
White Tiger

Thunderbolts
Bullseye

Marvel Horror
Ghost Rider (Johnny Blaze)
Man-Thing
Steel Wind

Misc.
Cloak
Dagger
Moon Knight
Punisher
Scorpio (Jacob Fury)

Potential
Black Widow
Lady Bullseye

 

[Phaedrus45]

I'm okay with Steel Wind. And I say lets go ahead and do a Marvel Horror section. We can move Steel Wind, Ghost Rider, and Man-Thing there. Based on your previous list for it, and the next list "Midnight Suns" now would be a good time to compile that list.

As for MI:13, I think it's good because there are a lot of British/European characters and this book compiles them all, as apposed to them being scattered all over. I think if someone were looking for one of those characters right now, they'd look for an MI:13 section. So I say leave it be and if/when we do another season we'll divy them up if needed.

Ok, so we should call it maybe MI:13/Marvel UK...that sounds good to me. We should put Death Head in it, and I'd want to take a look at various other groupings, like Motormouth and Knights of Pendragon, I guess. I did bring my handbooks to work with me; so, I'll get a look through them in a bit.

 

[Phaedrus45]

Oh, and since Lady Deathstrike is still brand new without any real info, I say we don't include her this go-round. She's still a bit of a mystery.

They are working on my phone lines at work; so, I will be losing internet connection from time to time. I have some UK names though, to float past you guys:

The Agent (Rick Mason) - I thought he showed up in MI:13 recently. He might be more of a probable; but, thought I'd float his name on here.
Albion - From Knights of Pendragon
Captain U.K. - Female who looks pretty neat
Cerise - Not sure if we want to include Excalibur characters here or not
Deaths Head (Minion)
Hurricane - Pretty neat looking character from Captain Britain
Killpower - From Marvel UK comic
Kylun - Probably under probable...included because I think he was here last season, did pretty good; but, is an Excalibur reference
Meggan
Motormouth
Digitek - pretty bad-ass looking character

 

[Phaedrus45]

Keep
Albion
Black Knight (Dane Whitman)
Blade
Captain Britain (Brian Braddock)
Captain U.K.
Cerise
Deaths Head (Minion)
Digitek
Hurricane
Killpower
Meggan
Motormouth
Pete Wisdom
Spitfire
Union Jack

Potential:
The Agent (Rick Mason)
John the Skrull - As mentioned, I think we have quite a few skrulls already.
Kylun


Drop
Faiza Hussain

 

[JewishHobbit]

Okay, we can go that route. I'm all for Death's Head and I've just recently discovered that UK line, so there's some good stuff there. I'll be leaving for work soon, but maybe on my lunch break or after work I'll get a good list going with those.

 

[wiegeabo]

Oh, and since Lady Deathstrike is still brand new without any real info, I say we don't include her this go-round. She's still a bit of a mystery.

So let's just use the old Lady Deathstrike.