Dark of the Moon The Official Transformers 3 News And Speculation Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I only saw Watchmen for the first time last week. Didn't really like it that much, except for everything to do with Rorschach. He's great.

Star Trek is awesome.
 
Jake Cassidy & Marvin need to have their mouths washed with soap then sent to their rooms without supper to think about what they said.

if I could use the same soap to wash all the fanboy propaganda off of these internets I would gladly eat that bar of soap for dinner.
 
I didn't know constructive criticism was fanboy propaganda.
Spider-Man was a summer action film
Iron Man was a summer action film

Transformers 2 can only be considered poison.
It's in the same league as a Aaron Seltzer and Jason Friedburg "Movie"
 
telling people to wash their mouths out with soap as if some sort of taboo laguage or faul language left their lips for simply stating that they enjoy a (taboo) film, never actually saying it was "Critical Quality," yes strikes me as more of the same old fan boy propaganda.

Not sure how TF2 can be considered poison, you'll have to enlighten me on that one my friend.
 
constructive criticism is supposed to be contructive, as in providing a reasonable suggestion to improve

saying that someone is less intelligent or should have their mouth washed out for enjoying a movie that YOU don't like is "fanboy propaganda"
 
The way they said it just rubbed me the wrong way. Happy now? I'm sorry!
Marvin claimed "It was the only one he could watch again from 2009" as if it was the best movie released that year and superior in quality.

You are entitled to your opinion however.

EDIT:

Even if you claim it is propaganda you can't deny the fact that it was one of the worst and offensive movies released that year. It's not just bad, it's crude, sexist and racist.

Yet people tolerate this stuff, I don't understand why.
Horror and action films have suffered the same fate as of late becoming cheap and stupid.
 
Last edited:
Ill give you crude....not so sure about racist, considering the fact that the voice actors for the Twins came up with a lot of the dialogue on their own
 
According to the poll on the Revenge of the Fallen board... most people thought it was "awesome"
 
I will always maintain that film is subjective....I know a couple people that truly liked "In the name of the King" or as I like to call it, Turkish goes Medieval....if there are people out there that like that hunk of ****, then anything is possible
 
The way they said it just rubbed me the wrong way. Happy now? I'm sorry!
Marvin claimed "It was the only one he could watch again from 2009" as if it was the best movie released that year and superior in quality.

You are entitled to your opinion however.

wow, an apology on these boards, things must have changed since I left.

anyway we're all entitled to opinoins, it just seems whenever TF movies are the subject it most always turns into something else. Like when Ebert called the people(and there were lots) who enjoyed it "less intelligent."
That being said, I never said the film was the best of the year, just that it was the only one I could sit through again. Million Dollar Baby and Shawshank are among the films I consider "best" but I'd be hard pressed to sit and watch them at any old time.


EDIT:

Even if you claim it is propaganda you can't deny the fact that it was one of the worst and offensive movies released that year. It's not just bad, it's crude, sexist and racist.

Yet people tolerate this stuff, I don't understand why.
Horror and action films have suffered the same fate as of late becoming cheap and stupid.

This is where the argument loses me honestly, there is so much hyperbole thrown around when it comes to TF and bay in general(amost ironic considering how excessive his style is), but in reality there are actual films that hit the (negative) notes we all claim his films hit, and what's worse is that they usually get praised for it.

here are some of last years releases that are infact worthy of such sentiments.
{the very idea that this might get modded off is a testament to my point}

the hangover


crank 2


lastly district 9, nominated for best picture and perhaps the most offensive of all.
[YT]A4Sxu2OrPMM[/YT]
as i recall they clearly use the name of a former nigerian president with reference to the cannibal gang.

I'm perfectly fine with everyone hating TF films, everyone is entitled to an opinion, I would just rather people be honest and agenda less about it. To claim that it's because the Transformer films are:
Racist,
Offensive,
Crude,
Tasteless,
Devioid of traditional plot,
Undermines it's drama with gags,
Shaky cam to the point of making one want to throw up,
Too Sex Driven.

..etc the list on goes on, to front that that is the reason why the film is the death of cinema and in the very same year give critical acclaim to films that actually have these "flaws" in spades is beyond lame. all said films recieved a fresh rating if I recall correctly.

I've had enough of the hyperbole surrounding TF criticism, if ppl don't like the films they should just say so, as opposed to attaching their dislike of the films to "real issues"

the question I would throw to everyone else is, did these films also "offend" you or was there just something special about the level of offensiveness in TF...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
well said Marvin...people just want to hate on the Bay, and thats fine....cry Bay, cry while you sit in your gold mansion
 
Bay sits high atop his gold mansion paid for by the gullible fools who went to see his films refusing to increase their standards above the level of ******s

DISCLAIMER: I'm calling the standard "******ed" not the people.
 
if I want standards, Ill go elsewhere...if Im going to see a Bay movie, I know exactly what I am getting and, for the exception of The Island, I like all of his films

own 4 or 5 of them on DVD
 
Good for you. The guy used to make pretty average films but with Transformers he decided to absolutely bat **** insane. Why? No one knows...
 
The Rock

and in my general opinion, The Rock is in the top 15 of greatest action films
 
I see, what about the rock don't you like?
it's not my favourite but I've never heard anything bad about it
 
did you misread my post? I love The Rock....the only one of his films I do not care for is "The Island", I think it was trying too hard to be clever
 
no I read it fine, I'm just curious what if anything you would improve about it.
 
there really isn't anything to improve IMO...the story is outlandish, but not garish...cast is really good...Sean Connery is still the ****ing man
 
The Rock

and in my general opinion, The Rock is in the top 15 of greatest action films

While The Rock may not be in my top 15 list of favorite or greatest action films it's definitely up there on my list and I will argue any day of the week that the film is in fact a damn good to great action film.
 
I don't know what people's problem are here with people who like ROTF that know it wasn't a masterpiece,and why they won't let them have mixed feelings about it,for the most parts it's like you have to hate it because they hated it. :csad:

I'm tired of being forced to defend the movie.
 
You know what I say? I like tons of movies no one likes or think are "crappy" but to quote the grandfather from the little known film "Angus" "Screw em!"

I'm not gonna only like certain films cause people say I have too.
 
The Rock is 1 of the last great old school Die Hard style action movies imo. Before CGI took over.
 
Last edited:
The way they said it just rubbed me the wrong way. Happy now? I'm sorry!
Marvin claimed "It was the only one he could watch again from 2009" as if it was the best movie released that year and superior in quality.

You are entitled to your opinion however.

EDIT:

Even if you claim it is propaganda you can't deny the fact that it was one of the worst and offensive movies released that year. It's not just bad, it's crude, sexist and racist.

Yet people tolerate this stuff, I don't understand why.
Horror and action films have suffered the same fate as of late becoming cheap and stupid.

That's not fact. That's an opinion. What some people find offensive, others don't.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,390
Messages
22,096,209
Members
45,891
Latest member
Purplehazesus
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"