• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Captain Marvel The Rotten Tomatoes/Critic's Reaction Thread

The Last Jedi went through something similar, but that movie is waaaaaayyyy more divisive than Captain Marvel. This is just trolls being trolls. TLJ RT was a lot of trolling too but many regular folks and fans weren't down with it.

I'm one of those people who liked it but didn't love it. It had unnecessary plotlines (the whole casino planet thing), unnecessary or poorly done (the Leia in space bit) scenes but I loved how it went against all internet fan fiction and expectations and the theme of hubris, failure and learning from it.
 
Well you know, it's not the end of the world obviously, but maybe Marvel could've avoided this if only they had put more effort into their friggin first female-led movie instead of playing it so safe.

It pisses me off that I waited years for a Captain Marvel movie that I didn't even like. Screw you Marvel, now I'll have to try to avoid death for the next 4-5 years if I want to see the sequel.

It's woefully ignorant to assume a studio didn't put "effort" into something just because you didn't like it.
 
To make TDK higher than Godfather lol

There was also a campaign around the same time to tank the audience score for the Raimi Spider-man movies, so that they wouldn't be so much higher than the TASM reboot. Its why the first Spider-man movie to this day has 34 *million* audience "reviews", about 32 million more than all the rest of the franchise combined.
 
The Last Jedi went through something similar, but that movie is waaaaaayyyy more divisive than Captain Marvel. This is just trolls being trolls. TLJ RT was a lot of trolling too but many regular folks and fans weren't down with it.

Which is part of why I really, really hate these bigot troll swarms. On top of being, you know, bigots? They also provide a huge amount of smoke that chokes up and conceals real critique. Have a genuine complaint about a movie? Watch it get discarded because sexist jerks are sexist jerks. A movie does poorly for some real reason? Watch it get discounted as the fault of said bigots, rather than of the movie itself.
 
Which is part of why I really, really hate these bigot troll swarms. On top of being, you know, bigots? They also provide a huge amount of smoke that chokes up and conceals real critique. Have a genuine complaint about a movie? Watch it get discarded because sexist jerks are sexist jerks. A movie does poorly for some real reason? Watch it get discounted as the fault of said bigots, rather than of the movie itself.
I really hate how people are turning rating systems that worked for many years because people used them mostly honestly but now are organizing mobs, boycotts, and botfarms to ruin scores for things they don't like.
 
I'm glad the user score is going up, if ever so slightly, but I'm a little surprised this is down to 79% on Rotten Tomatoes. Ah, well. It'll be certified fresh and make money.
 
I'm glad the user score is going up, if ever so slightly, but I'm a little surprised this is down to 79% on Rotten Tomatoes. Ah, well. It'll be certified fresh and make money.
User Score went up 'cause Rotten Tomatoes deleted around 50k user reviews this morning...
 
Yeah, they should only leave the super positive ones so it becomes the highest audience rated MCU movie ever!! And we can pretend it's true!!!
There are certainly some troll reviews in the score because there are several that are nearly exact cut-and-pastes of one another while many accounts look to have been created only recently as they have no other review histories or their profile goes to an error page.
 
Yeah, they should only leave the super positive ones so it becomes the highest audience rated MCU movie ever!! And we can pretend it's true!!!

Dude you do know that 50K reviews equals the amount of total user reviews for Infinity War? It's pretty obvious this was just spamming by internet trolls who are pissed at Brie Larson for whatever reason.
 
Once again more hyper-sensitivity over RT scoring blah blah blah.

I like The First Avenger a lot, and I don't need Rotten Tomatoes to justify how I like it. It's at 80 now, but I recall when it came out it was hovering at about 78-79.

Also, look at Spider-Man, 2002 version. That movie was NOT 90 percent when it came out in 2002. It was closer to 80 percent.

I don't get all the hyper-sensitivity over Captain Marvel. Anyone who likes it is nothing more than a shill or pushing feminist propaganda. People who don't like it are male fascist chauvinists, blah blah blah.

It's just so weird. I remember when these movies were not the norm and it seemed unusual for critics to like them at all. Like X-Men 2 actually got fantastic reviews, especially compared to the first movie which critics didn't generally adore. Even the first Spider-Man movie only got I think 80% on RT at the time. Trust me, it's 90 percent now but back in the day it wasn't. And those were among the higher end ones pre-Iron Man/Dark Knight/Avengers.

The truth is, I thought Captain Marvel was decent superhero fare. Like superior to Iron Man 3 and Thor: The Dark World, but inferior to say Guardians Vol. 2, Iron Man, Thor: Ragnarok, etc.

Political agenda: Sure it was there. But I mean lots of popcorn entertainment shove in their political agendas in there. It's nothing new. I don't think it was a huge deal like it was shoved down our throats. To me that's the key. I don't really mind if there's a political agenda reinforced in a film that's opposite to mine so long as its still good and not shoved down my throat.
 

I might not have loved the movie, but its definitely a crowd-pleaser, so the Cinemascore doesn't surprise me in the least and honestly I' quite happy for it.
 
The LEGO Movie 2: The Second Part (2019)

The LEGO Movie 2 got better reviews, sequel to one of the most beloved movies of 2014, and it bombed. Also, look at the audience rating. 74 percent.

I rated the movie Captain Marvel movie 7.5 out of 10 in my own review, so honestly those average ratings from critics make sense.

My thought was the movie was decent but not spectacular. Some of the characters are badly written and so are some of the relationships. I didn't like some of the adaptational changes, but I generally liked it.

As far as the first female led movie from Marvel, um:

Ant-Man and the Wasp (2018)

Let's not throw The Wasp under the bus.

Fans need to stop being spoiled. These reviews are not so terrible. This isn't exactly a Batman v Superman situation. Or even Ghostbusters 2016.
 
Last edited:
TBH, I'm baffled that "Ant-Man and the Wasp" and "Thor: Ragnarok" got almost 90% at RT while "Captain Marvel", a much better film IMHO, struggles to get 80%.

Reading some of the reviews I'm starting to suspect that some critics are no better than the incel fanboys who review-bombed the movie. They just are more subtle about their sexism and misogyny.
 
I really hate how people are turning rating systems that worked for many years because people used them mostly honestly but now are organizing mobs, boycotts, and botfarms to ruin scores for things they don't like.
With all these kinds of feedback systems, they rely on people using them honestly. When that stops they become completely useless.
 
It's woefully ignorant to assume a studio didn't put "effort" into something just because you didn't like it.
No it's not, because I have seen the movie.

I can tell when effort has been put into a movie, even if I don't like it. This movie was fluff. Filler. A movie that Marvel made just because they had to make it. Almost everything about it screams "just let's get this over with".

As far as the first female led movie from Marvel, um:

Ant-Man and the Wasp (2018)

Let's not throw The Wasp under the bus.
I don't consider AM&tW their first female-led movie since Wasp was not the lead in it, but let's say it was... Marvel's first female-led movie was even more mediocre and bland than their second one.

I'm sensing a pattern here.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"