Superman Returns The "what if" SR scenario game

[\S/JcDc\S/]

_________________________________________
_________________________________________

Ask a "what if" question regarding SR, then the next person should answer it and ask their own "what if" question.

If you find a previous "what if" question to be of interest you may bump it at anytime with an answer.
_________________________________________

_________________________________________


What if... SR is considered a GOOD film regardless of how it ties into Superman mythos?

Answer: ???

 

[The Kid]

Oldguy will cry I guess.

What if Tom welling played superman instead of routh?

 

[explode7]

That would be cool Welling as supes. Remember under the direction of BS who knows how great he could might act.imagine welling pumping iron for this movie he will be 100x times larger than routh pumping iron.

 

[Matt]

Opposite of JC's question...what if this movie is critically and publically trashed and pretty much just blows?

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

Opposite of JC's question...what if this movie is critically and publically trashed and pretty much just blows?

Hmm... All Superman fans will be disappointed and Singer will prepare for his life as a eunuch.

 

[explode7]

eunuch???

 

[Matt]

Hmm... All Superman fans will be disappointed and Singer will prepare for his life as a eunuch.

I wonder how many will eat their words and how many will live in absolute denial...sorta like with the kid...I argue that AT LEAST 75 % of the people who claim to like the kid, would've raised hell about it were it Jon Peters' idea.

 

[explode7]

What if JCDC just stop making SR threads? I don't even want to think that.

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

I wonder how many will eat their words and how many will live in absolute denial...sorta like with the kid...I argue that AT LEAST 75 % of the people who claim to like the kid, would've raised hell about it were it Jon Peters' idea.

Most don't claim they like the kid afaik. They just don't mind him if it serves a point to the story. Other than that, if the movie sucks imo I will say so first chance I get. I hope it won't though as I'm looking forward to it and have a good feeling.

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

What if JCDC just stop making SR threads?

People will rejoice

 

[explode7]

Especially Matt. Right Matt?

 

[The Kid]

What if the kid is superman's child?

 

[Matt]

Most don't claim they like the kid afaik. They just don't mind him if it serves a point to the story. Other than that, if the movie sucks imo I will say so first chance I get. I hope it won't though as I'm looking forward to it and have a good feeling.

After Welling was out of the running you had a "good feeling" law was being cast. I trusted you then and you broke my heart. I'll never trust your feelings again

 

[Matt]

Especially Matt. Right Matt?

Not so, I like JCDC quite a bit, we are Law brethern.

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

After Welling was out of the running you had a "good feeling" law was being cast. I trusted you then and you broke my heart. I'll never trust your feelings again

I still say "LAW WOULD HAVE BROUGHT JUSTICE TO SUPERMAN!"

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

Not so, I like JCDC quite a bit, we are Law brethern.

Ahh yes, the good ole' Law Brigade

 

[Matt]

I still say "LAW WOULD HAVE BROUGHT JUSTICE TO SUPERMAN!"

Yes he would've. The fact that Singer was too blind to realize it is strike one. If only Wolfgang Petersen directed...ahhh...in a perfect world.

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

Yes he would've. The fact that Singer was too blind to realize it is strike one. If only Wolfgang Petersen directed...ahhh...in a perfect world.

Well I'm fine with Singer and Routh but...

Besides Wolfie, I thought the rumor of M Night Shyamalan was interesting. If I remember right the casting rumor for an M Night movie was Jude Law as Superman and Bruce Willis as Lex. Would have been interesting.

Btw I liked Cavill a lot too for a younger Supes

 

[The Kid]

wtf? back on topic mother****ers.

What if King Kong fought superman? Ain't king kong got nothin on Supes?

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

What if the kid is superman's child?

The predicted outcome... I dunno, it could go to far for some fans. For me, I would have to see how it plays out. The whole piano thing sounds odd though.

 

[Matt]

If the kid is superman's son, I doubt they will kill him in a movie that will be at least partially marketed to children. Therefore I predict numerous ****ty sequels where the kid is always getting in wacky hijinks that Supes has to bail him out of (See Legend of Zorro)

 

[explode7]

What if the movie bombs?

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

If the kid is superman's son, I doubt they will kill him in a movie that will be at least partially marketed to children. Therefore I predict numerous ****ty sequels where the kid is always getting in wacky hijinks that Supes has to bail him out of (See Legend of Zorro)

GROSS

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

What if the movie bombs?

Whether the film is good or bad, I feel that's a possible scenario as the public never seems excited about the character of Superman as much as the anti hero's of late.

Anyways, if it sucks... It deserves to bomb. If it doesn't suck and bombs, or more realisticly doesn't do "GREAT" I think a sequel is still not out of the question if kids get into the merchandising aspect and DVD sales are good... Which is likely because most Superman fans which is a decent fan base will likely purchace SR if it is at least a good film.

 

[explode7]

But I didn't say "What if SR bombs" I said "What if the movie bombs" so it can mean any movie.