You can say a lot about "Superman Returns". The movie failed to be received by the masses of the audience. Bryan Singer was a wee tad too stuck on making the movie one big homage to the Donner original(s). The story dragged, and was overall pretty thin. Too long for what it had going for it self. The editing (ESPECIALLY in the beginning) was rushed, and was a mess. The action was surely missing! Last but not least - You just don't bring back the worlds greatest superhero, after 20 years, and give him a son (as being the major twister of the movie!).
STILL! (and this really needs to be said)
1. Bryan Singers love as well as passion for the character was presented in a major way! It was surely there on screen. Superman had never (up until then) been presented with such dignity and Godlike presence. The movie had style, and was anything but cheesy.
2. The cinematography was b_e_a_utiful! The imagery was absolutely STUNNING in every sense of the word!
3. The effects was really ****ing good! They tried their absolute best. Even if some things failed to look real. Like Routh's face at times. But overall, it was pretty damn impressive. That saving of the plane (which we ALL know was the highlight of the movie!) was unbelievably AWESOME! So beautiful and badass, it played out. This, is undoubtedly stuff we'll see in masses in Snyders MOS though!
4. The overall production. The sets and art-deco style of it all, was so incredibly beautiful! the Wardrobe department did a great great job. Hands down for that one!
5. Brandon Routh's portrayal of Superman (people, he deserves kuddos!) was spot on imo! He had a great presence when in those tights. He wasn't afraid to be his own superman, and in other scenes it was like Chris Reeve being resurrected. It was quite amazing to see. I think he delivered a strong, dignified, Godlike Superman character, that we can all be proud of. His CK portrayal was good enough. But I would have loved to see him geek out even more. But that's NOT Brandons fault. It was the way he was directed. If anything. Brandon was the one_thing that DID work in SR!
For me, there's still something very right about Returns, when I put on that blu-ray and watch it on my 63 inch flat screen (like I did yesterday). Bryan Singer went into that movie with his heart in the right place. I sincerely don't think Bryan's SR deserves the downright HATRED that movie has gotten! In ways, when all is said and done, I think the movie is somewhat underated :-( I don't LOVE Superman Returns. But I'm still very fond of it! I'm not ashamed to admit it either. Bryan Singer did something very very right with this movie. I just can't place my finger on what exactly that is (and I don't care).
In closing! While I can't wait for Snyder's "MAN OF STEEL", and I get why they're going all the way back to the beginning, and giving this amazing character a whole new spin. I even get why they have recast Routh, as this is something entirely new and NOT to be related, in any way, to the old movies. That includes both the Donners and Singer film. But, can any of you make sense of WHY "Superman Returns" was never green-lit for a sequel, when ****ed up **** like "Fantastic Four" and dare I say "GhostRider" gets sequels!!???? Why does that seem so damn unfair to me? Is that justice? I'm glad we're getting a whole new superman. But, you could EASILY have made a sequel to Singer's Returns and made it absolutely KILLER! Anyway, the past is the past, and the future is the future. Bring on MOS!
