That's not accurate. Fox initially had no problem with Singer signing with Warner to do Logan's Run. When he decided to direct Superman Returns that's when Tom Rothman went nuts. He fired Singer from his involvement with the show House, got rid of his office at Fox, and canceled his production company.
I've never heard of this.
Who said it was a decision for me to make? Stop putting words into my mouth. I can still debate over whether it was smart for Fox to not give Singer what he wanted.
You're wrong. I discovered this forum well over a year before X-Men 3 came out. I read the commentaries between many posters in the X3 cyclops thread after the initial X3 script release in May of 2005 and remember such posters as Shadowboxing, thevileone, and Nell.
Your welcome to come up with more ridiculous conspiracy theories about me if it makes you feel better. I remember you suggesting that I was one of the writers of Superman Returns which is beyond preposterous since I've spent a total of 5 minutes in that thread for the past year. Not once have I defended Singer and his production team in any Superman thread.
Okay. In all honesty this still doesn't change how I feel about that scene.
How do we know that none of the people weren't injured in these jet scenes? Some of the people involved could have suffered internal injuries. It can take months and some times years years for the effects of these types of injuries to be revealed.
See above answer.
What? I have no idea where you're going with this. Comparing the variations in strength of a soccer player's kicks to a character that has a strength to lift 90 tons with the IQ of teenager is quite silly. I doubt that Juggernaut put a lot of thought into how much of his strength he wanted to use against Wolverine when he threw him. Whatever you're suggesting probably has no relevance.
Yes, it is dense just like diamond and it would take an incredible force to throw an object that dense through a ceiling. It would also take an incredible and equal force for Wolverine to immediately fall through another ceiling after juggernaut threw him. I'm still wondering what that force was.
For you it's a moot point but, not for me because even though we don't know the exact science of fictional adamantium we can make estimations about the nature of it's structural integrity.
That's a theory but, it's still not believable. Jean showing concern for a innocent civilian is a lot different from showing concern for the brotherhood. I will never accept this theory because Jean never showed any concern for the brotherhood or reason to join the brotherhood in the first place.
Your theory is completely bogus and you know it. If Magneto had this ability then why in the hell didn't he put temporary magnetic fields around his brotherhood members in X-Men 1 and 2. Why didn't he put they fields around them in X3 at the battle at Al-catraz. Furthermore, why not just fly all of them over to Al-catraz with the same Magnetic fields that Magneto uses to fly? If Magneto had this power there would be no reason to transport the brotherhood members over to Al-catraz with a brigde. Of course in reality Magneto does not have this power. He can protect only himself from harm with Magnetic fields. There is no evidence in any of the X-Men films that contradict how Magneto's powers work.
Of course they all fell over. That's why it was idiotic for Magneto to drop the bridge because some brotherhood members would have died and others would have been severly hurt.
I will admit that the possibilites are there but, the probabilities aren't and that's what I have a problem with. It's possible that the reason angel made it to the final battle because while he was at the X-Mansion his powers evolved to the point where he could fly faster than jets. That is also very improbable and laughable.
There's also a difference between logical rationalisation and your neurotic attempt to find something wrong with everything with all of my criticisms.
If this was true it still wouldn't change the validity of my criticisms and just for the record Nightcrawler had twice as many critical X3 posts as me and he stopped posting in this forum 8 months ago so there's nothing extreme about what I'm doing. Thevileone has been bashing FF1 since 2005 and he has 13,000 posts.
Okay. I can't prove that you lied but, there are to types of liars. There are those that say things inspite of knowing they're 100% wrong. Other liars make claims that they are not sure about. Whether the latter liars end up being right or wrong about their claims they are still being dishonest about the perspective on their claims. You fall into the category of the latter. You said you were sure that the mutants moved to the back of the bridge before it fell and you were proven to be 100% wrong because their is no scene in the movie when this happens. After I shot holes in that theory you were suddenly convinced that the front part of the bridge dropped first before the back part and there was no scene of that happening in X-Men 3 either.
You can tell me 100 times that you didn't lie but, the nature of your attitude towards my answers suggests something else. I truely believe you were just making this crap up while you debated me. You were either staling for time, hoping that you're theories would end up being true, or simply wishing that I would eventually tire of debating you.
I agree with most of this. All of these scenes could have been twice as exciting if more had been added.
How do we know they were unconscious? We don't know this. Maybe both of them watched most of the battle from outside after being scared of getting their asses kicked again. What's interesting is even if what you said is true both characters can be seen inside the house after Jean causes it to levitate.
If your theory is true what caused Quills and Arclight to immediately become conscious after going into unconsciousness.
Of course I don't buy your ridiculous theory. I do believe that Quills and Arclight being useless in those scenes is the result of Ratner's unique skill at making action scenes mindless.
Yes, Pryo was off on another mission but, wouldn't it have made more sense for the Magneto's right hand man to be by his side when he tries to convince the most powerful mutant on the planet to join forces with the brotherhood?
Furthermore, did Pyro's this mission even make sense and what did this mission accomplish for Magneto and the brotherhood? There were many mutant curing facilities set up around the US. How did the destruction of one help Magneto's cause?
First of all if you payed more attention you would have noticed that Arclight's power is the ability to create shockwaves. Shockwaves can destroy organic and inorganic materials so your theory is bogus.
Secondly, what you were suggesting was ridiculous because it would have made Arclight's power almost useless against other mutants. If what you were suggesting was true then what offense or defense was Arclight trying to use as she prepared for Storm's attack at Jean's house.
Why in the hell was Arclight even there at Jean's house if her powers are so weak? Also, why would Magneto promote an almost completely useless mutant like this to his elite force? I guess in some bizzare sense this makes sense because Magneto promoted an even more useless mutant like quills to his elite force.
Yes, juggernaut is dumb but, dumb to the extent that he throws Wolverine into the house twice after being told not to? I don't remember Magneto hiring ******ed mutants to join his brotherhood in X1 and X2.
t: 
