If she were to die in the second film and then be brought be back as a clone in the third movie would just be ludicrous (no offense to you) it would just defeat the purpose of the Cat.Stacey's message . and I don't think the clone saga is the way to go.
I'm just afraid Peter will make a deal with the devil if that happens haha jk
Careful now, you don't want to be saying things that actually make sense here.
t:And yet you're the one who said that Peter's story was one of tragedy, not a moment, not one aspect, his story, to which even you yourself pointed out the very UNhopeful ending of. Peter sells his marriage and his unborn child to Mephisto. That is not the act of a man with hope, that's the act of a man who has given up, a man who has become so beaten down by all the tragedy and unhealthy guilt in his life, all the pain, that he just can't take it again.
I wouldn't say Spider-Man is a love story. But his love plays a huge part . it is also one of the things that makes him relatable to his fans .trying to juggle his work, responsibilities,friends,and trying to have girlfriend at the same time Just like you said .It plays a big part in his character.
I'm sorry, but since when does someone have to EARN happiness through pain? He's a superhero, he puts his life on the line everyday, and suddenly he has to suffer in order to, at some undetermined point in the future, find some kind of glimmer of happiness that most likely won't even last. No. No. That's unacceptable. I'm all fine with some pain for my hero, I think it's a neccesary evil for the hero to find himself and to propel the story foward, but, if we're all being honest here, Gwen's death does neither. It's pointless, and it's meaningless, and the one purpose it would serve, Peter understanding that he can't be in a relationship as long as he's Spider-Man, is pointless, because you all want Peter to hook up with Mary-Jane.
I'm not going to lie to you that sounds like a decent story-line. But I highly doubt they will kill off aunt may.
In what way has it been "built up", besides the Captains message? Which could be interpreted, mind you, as him telling Peter not to let Gwen get involved in his heroics, which actually makes sense, if you consider the situation of Gwen wanting to run up there and help Peter, and himself doing exactly that, and getting fatally wounded. But let's play devil's advocate here for a second. Say he did. Now, if it was MJ in this movie, and we had the exact same situation, would you still be clamouring for her slaughter? Hmm? Did you do that with MJ when the Goblin threw her off the bridge? We're you chanting "KILL HER! KILL HER!" while the Goblin held Mary-Jane by the throat? No. Because it didn't happen that way in the comics.
Lol that's not what I meant, I just mean that you really feel for this guy, and you are glad that he is happy. You can't enjoy the sunny days without some rainy ones, y'know. I didn't mean that anyone is undeserving of happiness. I also want to point out that I have said before, I do not want MJ in this trilogy. While I dont want that, I still would like to say something for the sake of discussion. You said earlier that you need hope, love, and innocence to really live. So, why wouldn't you want Peter to be with MJ, if she makes him feel better and happier. Maybe Pete could realize that after Gwens death, he was sad and miserable and refused to see any other woman, but his relationship with MJ grew, and he realized that he had feelings for MJ, and he knew MJ had feelings for him. Then at the end he ends up with MJ, because she makes him really happy and he thinks there is no point in living if you are going to be unhappy all the time.
If Gwen's going to die, Peter getting with MJ negates the whole point it. That doesn't mean I want Peter miserable, it means I want Gwen's death to matter. Peter doesn't have to be hopeless. In the possible second trilogy he can begin a relationship with someone more on his level, someone who won't be in danger by him being Spider-Man, like Black Cat. Or introduce Ben Reily, and he becomes Spider-Man, leaving Peter to try with MJ.
Who said Gwen will die for nothing? They could definitely have her death have a huge effect on Peter while still having him get with MJ eventually. I just think that they simply don't have the time. If Peter never meets another girl that he can be happy with and he chooses to push people away from him, he will end up killing himself (maybe a bit exaggerated lol but you get the point). There are other ways to make Gwen's death matter besides having Peter push everyone away from him.
