Which Hulk Is Stronger? (2008 or 2003)

[Raiden]

yeah 08 is more savage but that savageness doesn't necessarily manifest itself directly well with regards to strength. I mean he went all out on a barage against the abomination, and he shrugged it off, kicked him and the hulk was down for a good while (long enough to gain a decent sized lead if the abomination was concentrated on him).

I mean at his most pissed in the movie, he still wasn't able to knock out abomination cold and reverted to asphysxiation (sp?) to which he was still crawling about afterwards...

I think Abomination starts off as stronger than Hulk, and as Hulk gets madder and the fight drags on, he also becomes stronger, and he was able to defeat Abomination in the end. I don't see how the Hulk in TIH is weaker, since all Hulk incarnations get progressively stronger as it correlates with their temper level.

 

[Zig-Zag Man]

That scene where he screams after defeating Abomination when he's standing on him ... the movement and physical stature is so awkward and not possible. His elbows are like touching his back. Man, the whole physical stature and movements of the HULK don't have has much thought and detail as the one from Ang Lee's film. He moves too smooth. I like how in HULK, he was literally acting like a really strong child in his movements and mannerisms. When he threw something, he'd fall. It made him more relatable. Looked like when you see a child in their play room throw a fit, throwing around plastic toys. Looked so much more believable.

 

[Zig-Zag Man]

yeah 08 is more savage but that savageness doesn't necessarily manifest itself directly well with regards to strength. I mean he went all out on a barage against the abomination, and he shrugged it off, kicked him and the hulk was down for a good while (long enough to gain a decent sized lead if the abomination was concentrated on him).

I mean at his most pissed in the movie, he still wasn't able to knock out abomination cold and reverted to asphysxiation (sp?) to which he was still crawling about afterwards...

I agree ...

 

[Kirmit]

That scene where he screams after defeating Abomination when he's standing on him ... the movement and physical stature is so awkward and not possible. His elbows are like touching his back. Man, the whole physical stature and movements of the HULK don't have has much thought and detail as the one from Ang Lee's film. He moves too smooth. I like how in HULK, he was literally acting like a really strong child in his movements and mannerisms. When he threw something, he'd fall. It made him more relatable. Looked like when you see a child in their play room throw a fit, throwing around plastic toys. Looked so much more believable.

That's all well and good for a toddlerlike hulk but TIH is not a toddlerlike Hulk, he's still childish but much more mature in his mannerisms..

 

[Zig-Zag Man]

That's all well and good for a toddlerlike hulk but TIH is not a toddlerlike Hulk, he's still childish but much more mature in his mannerisms..

He's savage like ... he's looking for a fight almost. I like how HULK he's a repressed child, and he's new to the world. He isn't so much primative and barbaric as he"s confused and young, wanting to be left alone and only fights if he has to .... I thought TIH came off too aggressive at times.

 

[mcentepede]

Nobody wants to mention that Hulk 2003 had a give and take battle with some mutated puppies. He looked almost out of it after that one, also his frisbee tosses were mostly missing, so his ability to fight airborne foes was weak. Also Absorbing Daddy gave him some trouble, this took some steam out of him once again. The tank toss was impressive, but at 20 feet tall, he was as big as the tank anyways. Hulk 2008, is stronger...as much more damage is dealt out here...Nobody really gave him a good fight except for a naturally stronger Abomination, and Hulk is arguably weaker at that moment as Sterns gave him the Cure. Even then, he rejuvenates more and more and by battles end he bounds away seemingly in top shape again. Mind you he does this vs. a Stronger opponent and the Army(with Stark's weapons). A More impressive feat, than fighting a bunch of dogs and Nick Nolte. Also of note, his frisbee toss was spot on and nailed every airborne foe there was, nobody survived that.

 

[redlion2]

That scene where he screams after defeating Abomination when he's standing on him ... the movement and physical stature is so awkward and not possible. His elbows are like touching his back. Man, the whole physical stature and movements of the HULK don't have has much thought and detail as the one from Ang Lee's film. He moves too smooth. I like how in HULK, he was literally acting like a really strong child in his movements and mannerisms. When he threw something, he'd fall. It made him more relatable. Looked like when you see a child in their play room throw a fit, throwing around plastic toys. Looked so much more believable.

Hey, if you're going to criticise TIH for a lack of detail and thought to a scene, by all means be fair and criticise Ang's Hulk for the same thing. The gamma missile at the end fight doesn't even affect the rest of the environment. The trees don't even bend nor does anything move from the concussion.

 

[Anubis Raptor]

Hey, if you're going to criticise TIH for a lack of detail and thought to a scene, by all means be fair and criticise Ang's Hulk for the same thing. The gamma missile at the end fight doesn't even affect the rest of the environment. The trees don't even bend nor does anything move from the concussion.

Great point

 

[Anubis Raptor]

I still think LL's Hulk is stronger than Ang's. Simply because he overcomes Abomination's sheer strength. He becomes stronger than someone who is stronger than him. Someone who is larger, heavier, and way more powerful. It was like overcoming an injustice or a bully. Someone who you stand up to and realize there is strength in you that you didn't know you had in yourself. So ask yourself....how much more stronger can LL's Hulk really get?????

 

[Sava]

Hey, if you're going to criticise TIH for a lack of detail and thought to a scene, by all means be fair and criticise Ang's Hulk for the same thing. The gamma missile at the end fight doesn't even affect the rest of the environment. The trees don't even bend nor does anything move from the concussion.

pisst.... you know that Hulk was fighting absorbing man right?... what do you think happened when the bomb hit the ABSORBING man?...

 

[redlion2]

pisst.... you know that Hulk was fighting absorbing man right?... what do you think happened when the bomb hit the ABSORBING man?...

Riiight..sure, that's it..

 

[Kirmit]

pisst.... you know that Hulk was fighting absorbing man right?... what do you think happened when the bomb hit the ABSORBING man?...

This brings up a good point actually, if Banner's dad absorbed all the energy from the missile then hulk surviving it isn't really aa great a feat as people say it is.

 

[LostInnocence]

^ Uh oh, I think we've all hit an epiphany here!

 

[Zig-Zag Man]

Ummm yeah it is ... because either way he was hit with a nuclear missle. Those missles travel well over the speed of sound.

 

[redlion2]

This brings up a good point actually, if Banner's dad absorbed all the energy from the missile then hulk surviving it isn't really aa great a feat as people say it is.

Yeah, I thought Sava was being sarcastic but I immediately thought of the same thing.

 

[Sava]

Riiight..sure, that's it..

that is actually it, its right there, in the movie, Absorbing man cant control what he absorbs when he's fighting Hulk, so he absorbs the bomb and all its energy.

 

[Sava]

This brings up a good point actually, if Banner's dad absorbed all the energy from the missile then hulk surviving it isn't really aa great a feat as people say it is.

the great feat of strength isnt Hulk surviving the bomb, its Hulk literally using energy, his limitless energy to push his dad over the edge, give him so much energy that he cant possibly contain all of it, then the bomb hit and he dies.

 

[Kirmit]

Ummm yeah it is ... because either way he was hit with a nuclear missle. Those missles travel well over the speed of sound.

He wasn't hit by it though, the bubble was and if what sava says is correct then there wasn't nothing for Hulk to be hurt or effected by because it was all absorbed by his dad.

 

[Kirmit]

the great feat of strength isnt Hulk surviving the bomb, its Hulk literally using energy, his limitless energy to push his dad over the edge, give him so much energy that he cant possibly contain all of it, then the bomb hit and he dies.

Yeah I agree on that and love that part btw but some people use the fact he survived the blast as the great feat.

 

[redlion2]

that is actually it, its right there, in the movie, Absorbing man cant control what he absorbs when he's fighting Hulk, so he absorbs the bomb and all its energy.

So explain the concussive wave that expands outward after the missile detonates?

 

[Sava]

Yeah I agree on that and love that part btw but some people use the fact he survived the blast as the great feat.

well, they shouldnt cause i dont see how anyone could, his dad takes it all, there was nothing there to hurt Hulk, thats why he changes back to bruce.

 

[redlion2]

well, they shouldnt cause i dont see how anyone could, his dad takes it all, there was nothing there to hurt Hulk, thats why he changes back to bruce.

Nevermind I've read your response to Kirmit and that would answer my question as well......if I buy it.

This does open a whole new can of worms though for the pro-Hulk takes a nuclear explosion side

 

[Sava]

So explain the concussive wave that expands outward after the missile detonates?

maybe it was air being pushed back cause of all the energy released buy absorbing man after his death, why its green, probably cause it was gamma energy or something. or maybe they just put that in there for it to look cool, like how when things blow up in space you can hear the sound even though there is no air in space.

 

[ironwez20]

also criticize the 03 hulk for being incredibly stupid at times, you would think after he threw that tank that the soldiers would have broken legs or at least some kind of injury , but no they climb right out of tank, and all those flashbacks with the hulk nd his dad were unessary and stupid, and when he absorbed the missle he did explode and nothing and i mean absolutly nothing tokk affect. 08 hulk hulk had its moments but this hulk would beat the crap outta this hulk and ill tell you why. Hulk 03 woulda pissed his pants when come face to face with abomination i mean the guy was freakin strong hulk 08 beat the crap outta him, 03 hulk struggle to fight that dumb asorbing fater guy he was bassically getting the crap kicked outta him.

 

[ironwez20]

also criticize the 03 hulk for being incredibly stupid at times, you would think after he threw that tank that the soldiers would have broken legs or at least some kind of injury , but no they climb right out of tank, and all those flashbacks with the hulk nd his dad were unessary and stupid, and when he absorbed the missle he did explode and nothing and i mean absolutly nothing tokk affect. 08 hulk hulk had its moments but this hulk would beat the crap outta this hulk and ill tell you why. Hulk 03 woulda pissed his pants when come face to face with abomination i mean the guy was freakin strong hulk 08 beat the crap outta him, 03 hulk struggle to fight that dumb asorbing fater guy he was bassically getting the crap kicked outta him.