Which is The BEST X-Men movie ?

[x-fan]

thats why they are opinions lol if we all agreed this board would be silent

peace

 

[Mar420x]

X2
X3
X1

 

[XCharlieX]

My fav is still x2... that was fine tuned.

 

[JimB]

I liked a lot X1, and I love X2, but right now X3 is my favorite; simply awesome. So:

1. X3
2. X2
3. X1

 

[taintedFB]

It's a close call.

X2 for me beats X3 because Cyclops lived and it was a more intelligent script.

Had Scott had a bigger better role in X3 and NOT died, it may have beat X2. Although the dialogue was pretty weak in many parts.

X1, I still love and is great for what it is... an introduction into this world and it had a tiny budget, so they did what they could.

 

[Jasmine]

X2 for me.

 

[spider-neil]

I'm stupified here. I cannot comprehend in any way how the 3rd is even close to being superior over it's predecessors. Seriously stupified.

X1 and X2 are great stories but when I picture xmen the comic on the big screen X3 is what I see.

X3 is a true comic book movie with comic book action. I've seen it twice and I'd going to watch it again

 

[pt_photo_inc]

I'm stupified here. I cannot comprehend in any way how the 3rd is even close to being superior over it's predecessors. Seriously stupified.

i figured it out finally.... if you read most of those "RATNER and X3 SUPPORTERS" post.. they cant defend him... they only try to bash singer... and the only thing they like about X3 is the visual aspects and the fanboy treatments... ie JUGGERNAUT *****, ANGEL, BEAST, FAST BALL SPECIAL, ICE UP! and they choose that OVER character depth, story plots, drama, struggle and any real substance... they use lines like "Ratners iceman fought and iced up... singers made walls.... pathetic" cause they are not smart enough to understand where singer was going with that... they dont see the Boy that would have been forced into being a soldier... ratner iceman shows no transitition... there was no STRUGGLE that forced iceman into the soldier and out of the boy. Singers iceman would have been bad ass... the ratner fans on here make me wish that there were breeding liscences issued... so we could make sure they were not allowed to reproduce

 

[pt_photo_inc]

X1 and X2 are great stories but when I picture xmen the comic on the big screen X3 is what I see.

X3 is a true comic book movie with comic book action. I've seen it twice and I'd going to watch it again

hey how did collosus carry the tv when he wasnt metalled up? why didnt leech try to take jeans powers? why is magneto allowed in public when he is a terrorist, and her is just sitting there playing chess? where did angel come from in the final battle? where did he go? did his dad apologize? why do you like ****ty movies just so you can see some fan boy bull****?

 

[Mike059jig]

X1 and X2 are my favorites...X3 just was fun to watch but just didn't feel complete and finished so quick......it felt like just an x-men episode rather than a movie

 

[JTStarkiller]

thats why they are opinions lol if we all agreed this board would be silent

peace

I know what an opinion is.

 

[spidey207]

X2
X3
X1

 

[chaseter]

X3
x2(really really close)


X1

 

[chaseter]

hey how did collosus carry the tv when he wasnt metalled up? why didnt leech try to take jeans powers? why is magneto allowed in public when he is a terrorist, and her is just sitting there playing chess? where did angel come from in the final battle? where did he go? did his dad apologize? why do you like ****ty movies just so you can see some fan boy bull****?

How was Nightcrawler already in the pit with the mutant kids at the Alkali prison before he Bamf'ed? Why didn't Deathstryke's hands not extend or show her cybernetic enhancements like in the comics? Why did they say William Stryker created Deathstryke when it was her father? Why did they show Deathstryke healing??? That isn't her mutation. I can nitpick too! It is load of fun If you want to compare bull****, think before you start throwing out insults about your preconceived notions.

 

[BMM]

How was Nightcrawler already in the pit with the mutant kids at the Alkali prison before he Bamf'ed? Why didn't Deathstryke's hands not extend or show her cybernetic enhancements like in the comics? Why did they say William Stryker created Deathstryke when it was her father? Why did they show Deathstryke healing??? That isn't her mutation. I can nitpick too! It is load of fun If you want to compare bull****, think before you start throwing out insults about your preconceived notions.

Actually, Lady Deathstryke was altered by Spiral in Spiral's mystical "Body Shoppe"--she was not altered by her father (she wouldn't have survived the procedure). She was augmented with cybernetics, talons, etc. by a six armed dancing/teleporter who typically serves the spineless Mojo (leader of the Spineless Ones) in another dimension referred to as the Mojoverse (good luck getting that in a movie, hence the reason her story was altered).

 

[TwilightPro101]

X2
X1
X3

 

[Sony23]

1. X2
2. X1
3. X3

 

[The Kid]

no matter who you are, you have got to admit wolverine was magic in x1. How'd they hit it on the head so well the first time in?.
from the gif thread

 

[tkenji69]

X1 was a long snoozer, X2 was a longer snoozer, so X3 was the best.

 

[tkenji69]

^^ hate to break it to ya but neither one of them were critically acclaimed masterpieces. X3 was more exciting then both of those put together.

 

[redlion2]

My ranking would be:
1.X3 Thank god, Kitty finally gets to do something more than just run through walls but is actually a very interesting character.
Bobby Drake literally goes from hiding behind a kitchen countertop in X2 and actually becomes Iceman and a vital force on the team in X3.
I absolutely loved the Beast, "Oh my stars and garters" brought a huge grin to my face.
Storm actually gets to become the warrior storm goddess in this one as well as the giving mother by the end of the film.

2.X2 Nightcrawler's intro has to be the coolest I've seen in any comic book film.

3.X1 The one that started it all. Magneto as a kid in the prison camp is one of the most powerful scenes in a film and it still affects me.

 

[skruloos]

^^ hate to break it to ya but neither one of them were critically acclaimed masterpieces. X3 was more exciting then both of those put together.

That's funny that you bring up critics. Which of the X-Men movies has the worst average critic rating as culled by RottenTomatoes from various reviewers around the country?

 

[britrogue]

Definately X3. The ONLY thing that lets it down is the length.

 

[tkenji69]

That's funny that you bring up critics. Which of the X-Men movies has the worst average critic rating as culled by RottenTomatoes from various reviewers around the country?

Yeah so... whats your point? X3 still has more action in it then the other two combined. He was only talkin about X1 and X2. OK I'll restate my comment ...None of the three are critically acclaimed and X3 still has more action then the other two combined.

 

[Dernhelm]

I enjoyed X3 the most