Yeah, I’ve only seen Phoebe in Bridgerton but she definitely didn’t give me any of the edge or spunk that Lois needs. Not that she needed to (it was a completely different character obviously) but even so, she didn’t impress me.
Weaving is great but something about her playing Lois just feels off. I think she would be better fit for a character like Poison Ivy.
Emma Mackey definitely has the edge for Lois but… maybe too much of an edge? I really like her but in the things I’ve seen her in, she doesn’t have that bubbly quality that I also want in a Lois Lane.
Brosnahan is the whole package. She has the look, the right balance of edge and spunk, and out of all of them, I would have to say she’s the best actress. Like I said before, the only risk you run with Brosnahan is her stealing every scene she shares with Clark.