With Edwards' Godzilla..I thought that Shin Godzilla did a better job of just focusing on one region, and having the 'West Wing' style politics, hiding exposition and motivations in the jargon, while keeping a fast tempo. It does help that 'Shin' had something to say, responding to Japan's tsunamis and the government's lack of urgency.
I don't think Edward's Godzilla is a bad movie at all, but it's a movie that is..just lacking. To me it's a B minus.
It's not that it doesn't have enough Godzilla but the cut aways were problematic. The leads were mostly stiff and empty, and often dour. I want it to be dour, but let them act like human beings too!
If those things were just straightened out during the shoot, the movie would've improve by a whole grade.