I just saw this this morning, disappointed with it overall..
I thought after the first film Zombie was heading in a good enough direction, he was trying to
fill in the blanks with the Michael Myers character, it worked well enough in his first version of the film, but not for me in this one with the whole taking orders from his dead mother on a white horse & his younger self. On the plus side I loved how brutal Myers was.
I didn't like Dr Loomis at all in this film.. or really the first Zombie film either. He seemed like a grade A tool.. a big leap from Donald Pleasence's version of the character & a leap I don't care for..
Laurie Strode didn't seem right to me either, I always thought she
"should" be portrayed as a clean cut grade A student who eventually overcomes her fear of the Michael Myers character to stop him.. not one who becomes arguably even more mentally unstable than Myers..
I suppose the ending was the main thing that really bothered me with the Laurie Strode character..
While I do like the
filling the blanks idea in principle that Zombie seemed to be going for, I wasn't keen on how he went about it at all in this film. He should have just did exactly the same as he did with the first film. Take the original & put his own spin on the same film without distancing himself from it. He should have taken the original 2nd film (set in that same night) & show Michael making his way to the hospital hurt from a gunshot rather than presumed dead..
Part of the reason the first 2 original Halloween films where good/classic(s)/scary (& I suppose 4 & 5) where because Michael Myers was so mysterious he had little background story with blanks left unfilled.. despite the fact he'd been shot 6 times & survived he still seemed like he could be killed. I don't like this Jason like crap where it seems as though nothing can kill him.
Overall as I said I'm disappointed with this film & I hope its the end of Zombie's franchise.. his franchise is over for me anyway. I'm not even going to entertain another Rob Zombie Halloween 3 film if Myers is involved because there's no way he can still be considered alive, we would be crossing from Michael Myers to Jason territory with the repeated coming back crap..
I'll leave you with a few comment(s) on the film by a person who was in front of me as I exited the cinema:
"Rob Zombie should have his throat slashed"
"Ruined a classic.."
