Kitty vs. Rogue

[Exploding Boy]

UHHHHHHHHHHHHHH what can comic rouge do that movie ouge cant? Thats a hard one. Maybe she can fly and shes about just as strong as juggernot. Yea so you still want to ask that question.

Just as strong as Juggernaut? Are you kidding? For one thing Rogue has no super strenght right now she has Sunfire's powers and even when she did have strenght she was class 50. Juggernaut doesn't have a strenght class because his strenght is almost unlimited. And Juggernaut is just a regular human in the comics now, no powers no gem.

In order to crush Rogue's heart, would her hand need to be tangible?

If so, Rogue could absorb Kitty's power of intangibilty the moment Kitty grasped her heart. Presumably Rogue's internal parts can't be touched either.

With Rogue it has to be skin to skin.

 

[ThE_PhOeNiX]

Just as strong as Juggernaut? Are you kidding? For one thing Rogue has no super strenght right now she has Sunfire's powers and even when she did have strenght she was class 50. Juggernaut doesn't have a strenght class because his strenght is almost unlimited. And Juggernaut is just a regular human in the comics now, no powers no gem.

With Rogue it has to be skin to skin.

Im talking comic rouge here. Have you not seen her take on juggs.

 

[Lightning Strykez!]

In order to crush Rogue's heart, would her hand need to be tangible?

If so, Rogue could absorb Kitty's power of intangibilty the moment Kitty grasped her heart. Presumably Rogue's internal parts can't be touched either.

First we need to determine if we're talking about the comic or movie versions of these characters.

Because in the films Kitty would kick Rogue's behind 10 ways to Sunday and laugh about it.

 

[Exploding Boy]

Im talking comic rouge here. Have you not seen her take on juggs.

That doesn't mean she has the same strenght as he does.

 

[Goddessreicho]

Either comic or movie I would have to give to Kitty. (Sorry Rogue fans)

The whole intangible thing renders strength useless. (Well, depending on how long she can hold her breath, right?)

 

[ThE_PhOeNiX]

That doesn't mean she has the same strenght as he does.

Dude i think you need to read the post over. I said shes ABOUT JUST AS STRONG AS JUGGS. JEEZ.

 

[Lightning Strykez!]

Dude i think you need to read the post over. I said shes ABOUT JUST AS STRONG AS JUGGS. JEEZ.

Meh, that's inconsequential.

We all saw how Kitty handed Juggs butt to him in X3. Brute force is a nonfactor against intangibility. Plus Kitty is highly intelligent--she'd outsmart Rogue 10 to 1 with or without preptime.

 

[Goddessreicho]

Kitty fought killer aliens and is a trained ninga (Comic)
Kitty is very smart on her feet, and ruthless (movie)
Kitty is can't be touched if she's smart about it (both)

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

she fought killer aliens? Man she could be a train mutant Ninja turtle

 

[javon]

First we need to determine if we're talking about the comic or movie versions of these characters.

Because in the films Kitty would kick Rogue's behind 10 ways to Sunday and laugh about it.

LMAO!!!! Your killing me! Bt yeah, Kitty would win all the way. Unless Rogue were to stay in the sky. Then she'd just be a scardy cat.
*Na-nana-na-na!*

 

[Avalanche]

Meh, that's inconsequential.

We all saw how Kitty handed Juggs butt to him in X3. Brute force is a nonfactor against intangibility. Plus Kitty is highly intelligent--she'd outsmart Rogue 10 to 1 with or without preptime.

Well, she didn't defeat Juggernaut. She couldn't, despite her efforts.

Leech defeated Juggernaut.

 

[Exploding Boy]

LMAO!!!! Your killing me! Bt yeah, Kitty would win all the way. Unless Rogue were to stay in the sky. Then she'd just be a scardy cat.
*Na-nana-na-na!*

Kitty could just run up in the sky(she can walk on air while phased).

I agree with LS. Movie or Comic or both? And If it's comic Rogue doesn't even have super strenght anymore. She has Sunfires powers.

 

[Mike059jig]

Next rogue is about to have emma frost diamond form and Cyclops Optic blast lets see Kitty go up against that

 

[Exploding Boy]

Next rogue is about to have emma frost diamond form and Cyclops Optic blast lets see Kitty go up against that

Umm easily? She can phase through diamond and optic blast so what's the differnce? Unless she has Emma's telepathy then she could beat Kitty.

 

[Darkie]

well if we are talking about the comics i think kitty would win but if rogue has the miss marvel powers....there's no chance for kitty

 

[Exploding Boy]

well if we are talking about the comics i think kitty would win but if rogue has the miss marvel powers....there's no chance for kitty

Can you explain why? If Rogue can't touch her strength doesn't make a difference.

 

[Mike059jig]

OK how bout x-men evolution rogue where she had cyclops power, multiple mans powers, Jeans power,and so on...in the episode where she lost her mind..now kitty face that rogue and bet without a doubt rogue will win using multiple mans powers at the same time with the others

 

[Goddessreicho]

In evo, Rogue coouldn't handle these peoples powers: Cyclops, Jean, and Storm. There was alot of screentime dedicated to her not being able to control it. (well...Cyke's power was absorbed pretty often so I'm sure she got better with it over time.)

So that leaves Mutliple Man. Again, with intagibility it won't matter how many mutiples there are, if none of them can touch her.


















But she would have to outfight and outsmart each and every one.
So in that retrospect, in could be tough. A better match would be Kitty vs. Jamie.

 

[Darkie]

Can you explain why? If Rogue can't touch her strength doesn't make a difference.

well rogue can kick her easily with her powers (miss marvel powers) if she has those powers she doesnt need to touch kitty

 

[Mike059jig]

You should take alook at the episode on how she multipyed using multiple man power and use the optic black using about 6 rogues and the other 6 using the telekenisis...the episode called turn of rogue or something like that..she destroyed wolverine using her powers to the fullest extent

 

[RaisingStorm]

Then Rogue could never touch her and all she has to do is rip Rogue's heart out or stick a rock in her brain and leave it there.

I think I love Kitty now

" No Rogue...you are not constipated, I left a present up your butt"

HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

 

[Goddessreicho]

Yeah I saw it. Your right, she kicked Wolvie's head it.

But he's not intangable, and he makes an easier target when using ranged powers.

Kitty has the ablity to rip out hearts, jiggle brain juice around...She's a totally tank.

Rogue would have to contain Kitty, make her not able to breath then kick her around. Kitty powers are connected to her lungs, so there's her weak spot.

 

[Mike059jig]

with multiple mans power how is kitty gonna know which rogue is which by the time she figures it out the others are all over her, Jeans TK and the Cyclops optic blast isn't gonna make things easier for her

 

[Exploding Boy]

well rogue can kick her easily with her powers (miss marvel powers) if she has those powers she doesnt need to touch kitty

The point is she can't touch Kitty if Kitty is phased

 

[Goddessreicho]

And Jean can't even control her Tk all the way, in all the universes. So neither can Rogue.

For Rogue to use tk to combant a phased kitty she would have to solidify ALL of kitty's molecules and prevent her from re-phasing.

Rogue's best is to cut off kitty's air supply. (Her powers work for as long as she can hold her breath, I think.) Other than that...she's ice skating up a wall.