So...I finally went to see Superman last night. Honestly? I really enjoyed it. And, if I'm being fair and objective, it
does have a higher rewatchability factor as a summer popcorn flick when compared to
First Steps. Why? Put simply, because it had tons of action--lots of knock-down-drag-em-out fight scenes from beginning to end. There was destruction porn and huge explosions. And that's exactly what audiences want out of a summer blockbuster. The
Superman film
looked and felt like a Marvel summer movie (which is not surprising considering that Gunn
literally took every cinematic nuance--and even actors!--he used for the
Guardians and recycled them for
Superman).
All that said...we really shouldn't be comparing the
Superman and
Fantastic Four films at all.
The remits for both films were very different. First Steps is actually a better-looking film, with far more convincing, solid performances from the actors.
Superman relies more heavily on spectacle and shock value. Both are excellent and deliver beautifully in their own ways. But the FF were
never going to be the "knock-down-drag-em-out" type of heroes like Superman. This movie's ticket sales are less than spectacular because the WOM is that the film is "great but boring." Well, "boring" compared to what? Boring compared to two other movies that immediately preceded
First Steps and were chockful of action sequences--in typical summer blockbuster fashion. However, the Fantastic Four are scientists and explorers first and foremost, and
First Steps 100% nailed this aspect of who they are. Therefore, anyone who says that
First Steps is "lacking action" actually lacks an understanding of who the Fantastic Four are.
In my opinion, Kevin Feige & Co. completely misread the room here. Now that I've seen all three films, I'm convinced that Marvel/ Disney made a grave mistake in placing
First Steps 2 weeks behind
Superman and
Jurassic World. It was a huge misstep for
First Steps (see what I did there

),
because it wasn't designed to be a summer popcorn flick. It is (appropriately!) a sci-fi drama that should have been slated for an early Spring or Holiday box office release.