Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Superman Returns' started by Van Petrol, Apr 15, 2006.
To each his own. No problem there.
what? no damn you, I wanted a flaming war, lol, nah your both right
Do you have anyone specific in mind?
Yes Tom Cruise
Tom Welling (yes that horse has been beaten enough) and Nic Cage, I actually think he would have been a great mature Superman.
Well, can't say I share the sentiment, bro. Ok, Welling horse's dead, but Nic Cage? That guy's like the ugliest son of a biatch ever, not a single facial line remiscent of anything Superman-like.
I still think Cage would have pulled off Superman, do you also think Routh is the best Superman out there or do you think another person could have done this role justice.
The space suit is all kinds of great. Love it.
erm K-Fed as in Mr Spears?
Talking about Welling, I think that he would have made a great STAS or JLA superman.
[chandler_bing]Ok, we need a sarcasm smiley.[/chandler_bing]
Visually he would have made a good superman, but his acting and his voice just ruin it.
Cage... you just destroyed any respect for your opinion..wow
Oh, I'm sure there must be some unknown out there who could have done the role justice as well. In fact I'd be curious to see the tapes of other guys who auditioned for Ratner/McG movie, I'm sure you could find some close calls. But as far as Routh vs. Cage/Hartnett/Caviezel/whoever was rumored to play Superman goes, Routh wins by far. An unknown was the way to go in this case.
No. He makes a better teenage angsty clark kent. End of story.
No. Its because thats how you were first introduced to him. I bet if he were in Rouths position and you have never seen the guy act in Smallville you guys will be like all "Welling is superman".
If Welling was cast as 'Superman' of course the statement 'Welling is Superman' would make sense... but he wasnt.
Brandon was. We havent seen Brandon's acting yet but the fact that he was cast makes the statement 'Routh IS Superman' valid.
Well I'm just saying.
LOL, wow, like I could give a damn about an e-reputation
Harnett & Caviezel would have been poor as Kent and Superman, Routh has the CK look, but as Superman I need to see the movie before I can call him Superman, the pictures just don't move me, but its all good
But Nicolas Cage does? Cmon now..
to me he can play both apsects of the character, but thats my opinion and im sticking to it, so lets just keep it moving