• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Fantasy Netflix's One Piece Live-Action TV Show

Honestly, from what little I know about the pacing and scale of each arc, leaving Alabasta out of this season and very likely giving it its own season is a smart choice from a storytelling perspective. Including it would’ve been much too unrealistic from a pacing and budget perspective.

The initial group is now established, so you use this season to further develop their camaraderie, spend more time together, go on their first adventure together and just be a family. Plus, it ends with Chopper joining the crew, which is the perfect ending point. Then, with season three, you have the real estate to tell this big grand scale epic with Alabasta.

I don’t know why I didn’t even think of them dividing it up that way, but it makes sense.
 
Well, Vivi has to be next, right? If not, I'm gonna punch somebody!

5h5Mgfcox0HaFrwb1k.webp
 

I love the production design on this show.
 
How did they get this show so right and Cowboy Bebop so wrong? 😭
Because the people who worked on the latter were “fans“ who thought they knew better and could improve upon the original, the tone and the approach was wrong, the characters were mostly miscast, it was made by pop culture geeks and not cinema buffs, translating a 26 30-minute long standalone episode format into a serialized 8-hour long episode format doesn’t work, and the original creator not being involved at all in the process of the making and production of the series. From top to bottom, it was a case of fixing something that wasn’t broken and the people involved making it being casual surface level fans and not hardcore fans.

If I had had my druthers, I would’ve preferred they had just left the original series as is and just created new stories set at different points in the timeline in between the episodes we already know. Have it be show-run by someone like Rian Johnson, who is a film buff and a huge fan of the series, and let each episode be directed by a different director with their own style, eye and approach.

For a few examples that I thought of as an experiment of what I think my version of the show could do:

-Have a slightly comedic Rashoman-style episode with Spike and Jet each telling their own version of how they met and humorously going back-and-forth, with each version of their respective tales being filmed ver similarly but with different details changed depending on who’s telling what, and the versions of themselves within their own stories occasionally breaking the fourth wall to push back against what the other person is telling. Set closer to the beginning of the show, but after the episode where Ed joins the crew. Maybe you could get someone like Shane Black to direct this one.

-An episode centered on Ein and finally figuring out who he is and where he comes from, starting initially with Spike being annoyed as usual by him laying on his stomach on the couch and getting mad and shooing him away. Then, at the end of the episode, after assisting Ein and learning about all the horrible experimentation he’s been through, he realizes how the two of them really aren’t that different from each other. When Ein decides to try and lay on the same spot, Spike decides to relent and let him lay on him, much to Ein’s delight and happy tail wagging, even deciding to pet him and give a little smirk. You could probably have this set not too long before the episode Ed and Ein leave the Bebop.

-An episode told almost entirely from the perspective of essentially the equivalent of two low-level cops who have a dream of starting their own detective agency and just wanting to be taking seriously. They investigate what seems like just a normal case that sweeps them into something much bigger than they bargained for. They initially just barely miss what went on, but as the episode goes on, they get better and better about getting to where they need to go quicker, so more of what actually is going on and the main characters is gradually revealed more and more from their perspective, like seeing gunfire illuminating a window from the outside or somebody getting thrown through a door. At the end of the episode, in the very last place they need to look, our two characters actually get there early and get to engage in the action themselves, even helping out and saving the main characters and the main characters returning the favor. It ends with them having a little exchange with the Bebop crew, they get commendations for their excellent detective work in finding and helping to stop whatever was going, and the episode ends with both of them having been promoted and starting their own detective agency. It would be directed by Edgar Wright with both characters played by Simon Pegg and Nick Frost. As far as timeline placement, this could probably go just about wherever, but probably somewhere in the middle.

These episodes could be live action, could be animated, could be whatever each director of each episode wants to do. Oh, and every single episode is standalone and no more than 30 minutes long, just like the original series. As far as the amount of episodes in the season is concerned, I’d say probably ten would be good number. You could even do more than one season, as the format and the non-specific nature of the timeline of the show allows for various and numerous stories to be told.

Anyway, just wanted to throw my ideas out there. Not saying that I am a great filmmaker or anything by any means, but even with my limited knowledge, if I had the filmmaking experience and the wherewithal, I could probably make something closer to what fans of the original show actually wanted. Not perfect, but closer, and sure as hell a better sight than what actually we got.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"