No he doesn't. GSP is a much smaller shorter dude. Silva is huge and cuts down from over 220 lbs. GSP never gets anywhere close that. It's not a good match-up IMHO. I want to see the Jones fight, but Jones himself still has guys he has to beat as well specifically Rashad Evans and likely Dan Henderson. If that works out and Silva has no one to fight, I'd say yes make that fight, but that's a big if.
GSP is not that small. He walks around at 220 lbs and stands at 5'11. Silva walks around the same weight but his height is listed at 6'2, which I find bogus. I've met Randy Couture, Chuck Liddell and Anderson Silva. And neither Couture and Silva are 6'2. Liddell is the only guy out of the three that is truly 6'2.
And that's beside the point. Beating GSP would boost his resume probably above Fedor's by just having that win. GSP is a dominant champion in his division and a fellow P4P'er. Not to mention, fans have waited for that for years now.
Silva has accomplished a lot more as champion than GSP. Unlike GSP, while champion he went up in weight class twice and won both those fights by knockout in the first round.
If anything GSP is number one on the P4P list. The welterweight division is stacked (lightyears ahead of the middleweight division). Wins over Josh Koscheck, Thiago Alves, Jon Fitch, Matt Hughes, BJ Penn and Sean Sherk solidify that. I'm sorry, but you're delusional. GSP has faced the tougher competition in a deep deep division. When he gets back, he'll add another big name to that list in Carlos Condit, and then probably Nick Diaz.
You WISH Silva's resume was that prestigious.
In my opinion, Silva has to face GSP before his career comes to an end. If not, GSP will be known as GOAT 10 years from now.
Fedor's fight with Arlovski wasn't THAT iconic, sorry.
Yes, it was. It was a fight that fans wanted for years, but was labeled to be a fool's dream considering Fedor was at Pride and Arlovski was under the UFC banner. Then, Andrei walked away from The UFC and went on a five fight win-streak -- taking the universal spot as the #2 heavyweight on the planet.
When the fight was announced, the MMA community favored Arlovski (as the one to beat The Last Emperor). Unlike Cro Cop, Andrei had sharp and fast hands, a World-Class Sambo background and a legendary trainer at his corner.
You can downplay it all you want but Fedor-Arlovski was that iconic, especially on how the fight ended.