The remarkable turned inexplicable when Beaird was deposed in a civil case that Davis subsequently brought seeking redress and recompense.
After Mr. Davis was detained, did you have any blood on you? asked Davis lawyer, James Schottel.
No, sir, Beaird replied.
Schottel showed Beaird a copy of the property damage complaint.
Is that your signature as complainant? the lawyer asked.
It is, sir, the cop said.
And what do you allege that Mr. Davis did unlawfully in this one? the lawyer asked.
Transferred blood to my uniform while Davis was resisting, the cop said.
And didnt I ask you earlier in this deposition if Mr. Davis got blood on your uniform?
You did, sir.
And didnt you respond no?
Correct. I did.
Beaird seemed to be either admitting perjury or committing it. The depositions of other officers suggested that the property damage charges were not just bizarre, but trumped up.
There was no blood on my uniform, said Police Officer Christopher Pillarick.
And then there was Officer Michael White, the one accused of kicking Davis in the head, an allegation he denies, as his fellow officers deny striking Davis. White had reported suffering a bloody nose in the mayhem.
Did you see Mr. Davis bleeding at all? the lawyer, Schottel, asked.
I did not, White replied.
Did Mr. Davis get any blood on you while you were in the cell? Schottel asked.
No, White said.
The contradictions between the complaint and the depositions apparently are what prompted the prosecutor to drop the property damage allegation. The prosecutor also dropped a felony charge of assault on an officer that had been lodged more than a year after the incident and shortly after Davis filed his civil suit.
Davis suggested in his testimony that if the police really thought he had assaulted an officer he would have been charged back when he was jailed.
They would have filed those charges right then and there, because thats a major felony, he noted.