- Joined
- Sep 14, 2008
- Messages
- 40,446
- Reaction score
- 6,223
- Points
- 103
That's what I love about Scream 4. The supposed "next generation" all die.
(Williamson intended Kirby to die)

I thought Kirby could have been the killer in this movie. Had potential.
Well, there's some good news for you, then...I still facepalm about them killing Kirby and in such a mundane way. A type of wound that any final girl could survive, and at the hands of her incel crush.
![]()
[Damn, apparently I have a lot of thoughts about this movie. This has to be my longest post here ever.]
Well, I didn’t enjoy this as much as I thought I would. Felt undercooked. One of the biggest issues was that a lot of the characters just weren’t given enough time. Since the focus was on the two sisters mainly, I feel like the other new characters got like two scenes each before Ghostface got to them. The killers were also a little easy to predict, not because of their motivations but because of the actors that they got for them. The meta commentary also felt half-baked this time. Another issue for me was that Melissa Berrara’s acting was just… not good. It was especially bad in the hospital scene where she’s telling her sister why she left. Everyone else was acting circles around her. As for the rest of the new cast, I thought Jenna Ortega was great and should’ve been the lead and the twins were charming in their brief screen time but the rest of the cast didn’t leave much of an impression. Kyle Gallner and Dylan Minnette were practically cameos.
Speaking of Dylan Minnette, his death was brutal. After his mother died, I didn’t think he would die too. I thought he would just open the door after the fakeouts (which were done well and kinda funny) and find her body. The knife visibly moving through his throat was just so. That said, I didn’t like the logistics of some of these scenes. Like the backup taking forever to arrive and Judy getting killed in broad daylight and no one hearing her. The hospital scene also bugged me because that entire floor was completely abandoned. I know the sheriff said something about a private floor but still. Literally one guard? And the whole situation with Dewey not thinking to take the mask off when the killer was incapacitated and instead going back alone to shoot the killer just… it felt like a slightly convoluted way of making things happen. I just think the scene didn’t flow naturally.
I also didn’t care for Sam being the daughter of Billy. It’s an interesting idea but I don’t think it was done well and although it was a nice surprise seeing Skeet Ulrich again, the visions were very sparsely used and ultimately pointless. I did like the way they handled Dewey and Gale. Sidney was a total badass and I loved how over she was with all this **** but I do wish she had a more meaningful role. She just showed up wanting to kill the new Ghostface. Still, whenever any of the trio was on screen it was great.
As for the new killers, like I said they were easy to predict just because the actors playing them had that vibe to them. And their motivations were kinda flimsy. With the past killers, there’s always a movie related motivation that’s kinda meta and then another personal reason with at least one of the killers that pushes them off the edge. Anger, abandonment, revenge, jealousy, stuff like that. This time they just wanted to give moviemakers a new plot. There’s no personal connection to any of the victims which kinda made it feel hollow. They wanted to kill so they sought out the sisters and got the original trio back to Woodsboro. And also, after the reveal when they’re all jokey jokey and telling everyone what their plan was, that felt very been there, done that this time. I know that’s sort of the pattern for these movies but Ghostface was really threatening throughout the movie and I wish they had continued being a little creepy at least.
So yeah. A little bummed that I didn’t enjoy this as much I wanted to. Really enjoyed Ready or Not and had high hopes for this but even though I didn’t dislike it, I also didn’t love it. I might have to see this again but as of now, I think I enjoyed 4 more than this.
It also didn't really help that they mentioned my biggest issue with the Scream franchise, "Ghostface" is kind of lame because it's always someone else; a copycat killer. When they said he or she isn't a Jason or Michael Myers, I was just thinking yup that's exactly why I'm not a big Scream fan. (Even though I like the movies)
Thanks for the heads up. Really want to see this again.Btw, Paramount+ added it today! Pretty darn quick, IMO.