Homecoming Spider-Man: Homecoming User Reviews Thread *SPOILERS*

Rate Spider-Man: Homecoming

  • 10

  • 9

  • 8

  • 7

  • 6

  • 5

  • 4

  • 3

  • 2

  • 1


Results are only viewable after voting.
Saw this film a second time earlier tonight. It definitely held up on another watch. I enjoyed this more the second time around. :)

I'm still really firm about this being my third favorite Spider-Man movie though. Those thoughts have not budged or changed whatsoever.
 
Saw this film a second time earlier tonight. It definitely held up on another watch.

That's good to hear, I'm waiting a bit between watches but will definitely have another pass through it
 
Late to the party, but here it goes:
Wow. Finally.
We now have the best version of Peter Parker and Spider-Man that we could ever have hoped for. I did not expect the things I got from this film.
1) The Vulture. I didn't expect such a compelling and well-done villain! He hit all the right notes, you could understand his motivations, and he was honorable. I am so glad he wasn't lazily killed off, like so many other villains.
2) Humor. I wasn't expecting such a genuinely funny movie. Not silly to the point of me being unable to take it seriously, but just funny. The humor hit the right notes, and it led to something else...
3) Peter's life. The stress Peter felt about keeping true to his Aunt, his friends, his life as Spider-man, his commitment to Stark and his future....they were all palpable. You could empathize with him when he leaves a party to stop arms dealers only to hear his name being mocked over the PA at Liz's party! He did the right thing and felt like he was being punished for it, which is how life tends to go!
SPOILERS!!!

4) "The Final Chapter". Seeing Peter trapped in the rubble ala Amazing Spider-Man#33 was incredible. Seeing his hopelessness as he cries out for help, only for him to realize that he is on his own, that was beautiful. Well done, guys. Not as well done as...
5) Peter turning down his spot in the Avengers! I could not have been more happy about this. Seeing Peter depending on himself more, and going it alone after earning the respect he had been so desperately seeking, that was amazing.

Okay, I could be coy and cynical and focus on the ONE flaw I saw in the movie, but I won't. I think my only MINOR gripe would be the last scene where Spidey and Vulture fought. It was a little hard to follow visually, but I think that was the point. That's all I've got.

Not since Spider-Man 2 have I been this pleased with a Spidey film, and not since Guardians of the Galaxy have I had this much FUN at a comic film. It never felt like work.

Also, I have to grade this on the "parent scale". My children watched it on either side of me, completely spellbound and silent. This was my son's first Spider-Man film seen at the "big movie", and he LOVED it. My daughter saw The last 2 films with me, and loved this one. I love that my family got to see it, and even my wife loved it. So, they hit all the right buttons.

Now, bring on the sequel. My family will be waiting patiently.
 
Guess I'm in the minority with this one. Finally got to see it last night and went in with an open mind. I loved Tom Holland in Civil War and more Downey Jr./Keaton is always a good thing.

I liked it but I just didn't LOVE it. Lots of positives but lots of middle of the road/''blah'' stuff as well.

The Positives:
- Keaton - He never disappoints and his acting was top-notch. He was actually quite intimidating and was clearly having fun. I'm not sure why everyone is trippinig over themselves declaring him as one of the best villians of all time, but I do think Keaton elevated the material quite a bit.
- Holland is extraordinary. Funny, cute, awkward, yet fully commanding when he needs to be. He deserves to occupy this role for a long time and will only get better from here.
- Some of the supporting players were fun.
- Some good (if not outstanding) action set pieces.

Things I wasn't crazy about:
- The high school/John Hughes vibe they were apparently going for just wasn't there in my opinion.
- Hated all the IRON MAN suit nonsense with Karen.
- Aunt May felt wasted and the last moment didn't do it for me.
- The MJ thing was weak.
- It just didn't feel like ''classic'' Spider-Man to me. No doubt the point, but still...

----------------

I'm sure this works great as a Spider-Man for a new generation, certainly for kids and teenagers. However, while I'll follow the BATMAN character anywhere, I've realised that just isn't the case with SPIDER-MAN. I honestly didn't feel that much excitement when watching this. I can appreciate it as a well put together movie, but that's pretty much it.

It still doesn't come close to the Raimi series for me or made me feel as elated as I did watching the final swing during SPIDER-MAN (2002). This blows the AMAZING series out of the water, but simply didn't touch the original trilogy.
 
Guess I'm in the minority with this one.

I'm with you. There are parts I loved - Peter/Spider-Man, the struggles of his work/life balance, the villains - but a few parts I really didn't appreciate - the suit tech, most of the Iron Man interference and "MJ".

It is a really fun movie, but it seemed to drag a little in the second half for me. I actually liked the reveal of Toomes as Liz's father, as well as the background links to the MCU.
 
I liked it, quite a bit more than I thought I would. It felt like Spider-Man and that was important, Tom nailed it. Keaton was really good, that whole picking up Liz and the drive to the dance scene was incredibly tense. Vulture is definitely one of the best MCU villains (not a high bar I know) but man I was so pleased with him. I loved that he turned down the Avengers invitation at the end and of course probably one of the best scenes in the film...Peter lifting the debris ala "The Final Chapter". Freaking beautiful moment!
Amazing_Spider-Man_33.jpg


The things I didn't like.

Too much tech on the suit, more importantly....the A.I....get that crap out of my Spider-Man movie...so unnecessary... plus a lot of the gadgets he had felt like stuff Peter should make as he get's older. But that's the price of having Stark make your suit I guess.

Aunt May finding out he's Spider-Man already and that they played it for laughs.

The infamous "MJ" scene. Just made me cringe in the theater, felt so out of place.

No mention of Uncle Ben outside of that line to Ned.

Overall though, I liked it. Very much. Seriously though....PLEASE ditch that A.I.
 
Just got back, and like some others, I liked it, but didn't love it, and was actually disappointed with some aspects.

The cast were great, Holland is great as Spidey/Peter, I thought he was a bit more engaging in CW but here he did really well with what he wa given. Which was mostly great. You feel for this Peter when he has to leave a party to do something good and it negatively effects his personal life. Same with him missing the decathlon and making Aunt May worry. They got his life balance down really well and Holland was great.

I did like Tomei as May, but she wasn't given enough to do imo and she didn't feel as close to Peter as she was in the Raimi movies. Keaton was great, I actually normally find The Vulture Spidey's worst mainstream villain, but Keaton and this movi actually made me like the character. He was a really good villain with good motivations, and when he unexpectedly turned up at a certain moment it really worked. The subsequent car scene was probably one of THE MCU's best and most tense villain scenes.

Peter's school buddy was a mixture of funny and annoying, and I didn't like the changes to Flash or the MJ moment.

I thought the action was average and the final battle especially was quite disappointing. The barge moment was the action highlight. However, one of the best moments in the movie is when Spidey lifts the rubble after realising there is no one there to help him. It was the most powerful moment in the movie. And of course was similar to a certain comics scene.

I didn't like the suit AI at all, it just wasn't something I wanted to see in a Spidey movie. There wasn't also some spotty CGI and the score wasn't the best. I didn't feel it was quite as weightysnd emotional as the first 2 Raimi movies either. They are still the movie Spider-Man cream of the crop for me. I also feel barely any mention of Uncle Ben was criminal.

Overall though this has got Spidey back in track, it's a good start so hopefully we get a great sequel to follow. And I am really excited about Scorpion as the villain! 8/10.
 
Last edited:
Ever watch a movie that felt well done, but didn't really move you?

SMH is that movie for me.
Tom Holland's good as Peter and even better as Spider-man, but the movie felt a little lightweight.

I actually think GotG2 did a better job at balancing comedy with dramatic moments.

Keaton is good but suffers from maskless superiority-that is, when he's in his suit, he doesn't provoke as much fear as when he's without it.

Tomai is given little to do.

As for the supporting cast, they set the comedic tone well, but don't deliver the kind of dramatic weight that say-James Franco did in the Raimi movies.

I still liked the movie, but this falls in the camp of "watch with a friend on the weekend" rather than "resist urge to rewatch."
 
I just can't get this movie above a 7/10 no matter how I break it down.

This sums up why...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DC_AqezinXM

Jenny Nicholson nailed it and with humor as usual.

Homecoming was good but far from great. Peter's world is very "lovey dovey" and that fundamentally changes the character.

At the end she intelligently states why Raimi's Spider-Man films ARE better. Bravo.
 
I was planning on writing this review once I come out of the theater and the film was still fresh in my mind.

Judging by the overwhelmingly positive response and high ratings (higher than SM2 mmk?) on most movie sites, I was prepared to do a detailed analyzed dissertation but here I am, trying to contemplate why most of the public is lying to themselves when it comes to a stylized Spidey, which is basically what this boils down to…

OK, first the positive:

I really did love Tom Holland as Peter, and his Spidey was great, had a lot of fun watching and listening to him interact with the people at school.

RDJ just for the hell of it, who doesn’t enjoy Stark’s comedic timing? I felt like it was great for the moments they had him, but I have my qualms about his utilization, more on that later.

Michael Keaton, talent doesn’t just vanish; he can still deliver the goods and then some. His motivations were believable and his intense dialogue with Peter on the way to the dance was some of the best scenes in the movie. I thoroughly enjoyed his performance.

I appreciated the light, fun tone of the film, definitely keeping in the realm of the MCU, Marvel scores with their comedy and popcorn aspect of an at times, an angst-ridden character. That was the theme they were going for. Some parts I didn’t quite get, will elaborate later.

Best scene, Spidey lifting the rubble when he realized he was truly alone, there, right there, that is the Peter/Spidey I recognize from the comics. It took me back to the Raimi trilogy.

Now for the negative…

Ned, Peter’s friend, was borderline annoying, he had his moments but it was forced humor I could do without.

Never once did I buy that Flash Thomson in this film was bullying Peter Parker or anyone. If anything, and this is a big flaw in the casting, Tom Holland is too good looking to be considered an “outcast.” Tony just wasn’t intimidating enough to play a bully. The actor playing him was meek it was ridiculous.

Too much reliance on Tony and Stark Co. to be "the real heros.” While I enjoyed Happy, I feel like Tony was shoehorned to be some kind of legacy character to Peter. Mentor? Alright, but he “saved the day” too much and this is a Spider-Man movie. In the trailer they made it seem like Peter was the one saving all those people on the ship from crumbling. Nope, MCU has a hard on for IM, understandable but it was severely obvious. Way too much tech.

I actually laughed at the scenes with Michelle, she seems like a new character that I don’t recognize in the movies, which didn’t make sense to give her the iconic initials of MJ. I still have issues with this and to this day, Kirsten Dunst remains the superior Mary Jane in spite of the past writing of the character. Mary Jane is a white, red-head bombshell with green eyes.

Pepper Potts? Why? How? Gonna chalk this up to a Gwyneth cameo no doubt that she was overpaid for.

The tiresome pace of the second half. Not enough action scenes, no I didn’t want everything to be exactly like the comics, but it would have helped to have Spidey actually do what Spidey does. They also didn’t reveal how long he’s had his powers or when, any flashbacks? Would have been great for his character growth. No it’s not ad nausem to see how he got his powers, it just would have made me care about Spider-Man as the hero more.

I feel like I want to rate this higher because I know it was trying, but it just doesn’t hold a candle to the Raimi films, especially not the first two.

Overall, I did enjoy the film, for what it was, and what it could be in the future. Tom is 21 but still looks young enough to carry Spidey for many sequels to come. I did love his efforts, Keaton, Favreau, the cast brought some decent things to the table but it for sure is not a perfect film, not worthy of the high praise its somehow garnered.

Fingers crossed for the next movies to deliver more promise. I’m giving it a soft 7/10.
 
Wow, thought I would be in the minority not loving this. Seems a few people didn't though.

I must say the more I have e thought about the negative aspects of my review, the more they bother me. As well we didn't didn't get a really epic web-swinging scene in the movie. Iguess I am just a classic Spidey guy.
 
Last edited:
Was just surprised I wasn't the only one blown away that's all.

It's okay. There's nowhere I can believe that The Dark Knight isn't one of the best movies ever made (even though I believe it's a very good one with some truly great moments) without being accused of trolling :)

I'd give SMH a 7/10, too. I think it replaces true depth with enjoyability.

The trouble with the "I want to prove myself" storyline is it allows for little suspense. Is Spider-Man going to really fail? And if he does, does that represent who he is?

In Spider-Man 2-
Peter loses his pizza job, his girl, his powers, his suit, and nearly loses his best friend. He fails to stop Ock from taking his body.

In Homecoming, sure he has victories and failures. But it seems it's built around "Can Spidey become an Avenger?" rather than "Can Spidey balance his life with superheroics" which I think is more compelling.

Also, the "happy moments" montage was so similar to the one in SM2 that I wonder why other people haven't pointed it out.
 
Was just surprised I wasn't the only one blown away that's all.

Why would you be surprised? Name me one celebrated CBM that doesn't have some detractors.

In Spider-Man 2-
Peter loses his pizza job, his girl, his powers, his suit, and nearly loses his best friend. He fails to stop Ock from taking his body.


Two things;

1. Why are you putting SM-2 story details in spoiler tags? The movie has been out for over 13 years.
2. When the heck did Ock take his body in that movie?
 
^ To Harry.

But anyway, I think Homecoming succeeds on a comedic and occasionally exciting level-but the Raimi films have more nuance, IMHO.

As much as I feel like I'm whining about Homecoming, it's still the best Spidey film in over a decade.
 
Peter losing his powers in SM2 was one of the dumbest plot points in the entire Spider-man series. Made zero sense. It was just there due to plot convenience reasons. I hated that aspect to SM2(which I'm rather lukewarm on as a whole anyway).
 
Eh I don't think it's worse than turning Spidey into MCU version of Deadpool.
 
Peter losing his powers in SM2 was one of the dumbest plot points in the entire Spider-man series. Made zero sense. It was just there due to plot convenience reasons. I hated that aspect to SM2(which I'm rather lukewarm on as a whole anyway).

Peter losing his powers is ripped straight from the comics. The emotional stress of being Spider-Man ruining his life made him physically ill to the point that it affected his powers.

And it's a medical fact that emotional stress can make you physically ill. It made perfect sense.
 
Wow, thought I would be in the minority not loving this. Seems a few people didn't though.

I must say the more I have e thought about the negative aspects of my review, the more they bother me. As well we didn't didn't get a really epic web-sites scene a in the movie. Iguess I am just a classic Spidey guy.

I was waiting for a scene like that too.
 
Just saw this today.

As expected, I enjoyed it but it wasn't the best. Tom Holland is a great Spiderman. Came off believably as young, insecure and yet totally full of himself. I liked his friend too, his 'guy in the chair.'

Keaton was good, as usual, but to me his transition at the start to 'bad-guy' was awfully quick. But, they didn't have much time to do it in, so I can forgive it. He was intense in that car scene and his motivations were believable. The end fight scene felt a bit rushed though.

Happy I was not happy with. He wasn't paying attention at all to Peter and seeing where he was going. He had a 'brush off' mentality that didn't do the character any justice.

Then Stark, I always like him, but I would much rather there wasn't so much of an Avengers tie-in. It felt less like a 'Spiderman' movie and more of an Avengers movie.

I did like that Peter turned them down at the end. At least for the moment, and that it caught Tony and Co. flat-footed as well. Pepper and the ring were some nice touches.

I don't think it was worthy of top-billing though. She was like third or forth in the credits for less than three minutes of screen time which was a WTF for the other actors who had put a lot more time in.

Best scene was Peter saving himself from under the rubble. Like Iron Man, the suit is not who you are.

Weakest scene was the boat save. Not because Peter didn't save the boat, but because it was basically unsavable. The keel was sliced in half, so that thing should have gone down no matter what Peter or Tony did. Both halves should have sunk at different rates as well, and no matter how much you weld above the waterline, if you don't seal the hull then it's just one piece going down instead of two.

Another reason why it's the weakest, is that it was basically a rip-off of the Spiderman 2 train scene.

I did like this MJ, but I wish there had been more of her in favor of the 'popular' girl.

Another thing I liked about Stark was his reference to Peter's IMs. Right there you knew that though Happy was not reading them, Tony was.
Although, after the boat scene he's all over Peter for not leaving the Vulture alone. However, he never said that they (the Avengers or the FBI) were taking care of it. He just left Peter thinking that no one was handling it and that then he (as Spiderman) should.

He left Peter thinking he wasn't being taken seriously, when all Tony had to do was tell Peter he would look into and not to worry about it.

Anyway... I liked it overall. I was laughing and chuckling quite a bit, especially with the end scene! Aunt May standing in the background and then going, 'what the F-' and then cutting to the credits was sweet.:woot:
 
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"