Superman Returns SR the fourth best superheromovie of all time?

[FCEEVIPER]

1. Batman Begins
2. Batman
3. Superman Returns
4. Superman: The Movie
5. Superman 2
6. Sin City
7. V for Vendetta
8. Spiderman 2
9. Batman Returns
10. X2

 

[ChrisBaleBatman]

My top 10:

1. Batman Begins
2. Superman Returns
3. X2
4. Spidey 2
5. Hellboy
6. Batman
7. Superman: The Movie
8. Superman II
9. Sin City
10. The Rocketeer

 

[Junfan]

Wow...you thought Blade II was that bad? I wouldn't even put it in the same room as those other 3.

It probably doesn't deserve to be in the same room, you're right, however for all the good parts in the movie, I can't get past the stupid stuff.

In comparison to blade one, the CGI was VERY overused for fights that didn't need it, and in the first fight scene with the spotlights it's very poorly done. Blade one the CGI wasn't overused except for the very end.

The blood pack was just ridiculous imo, most of them didn't even have a "specialty", what was the goth girls purpose besides being killed? Or the Irish guy, or the guy from fast and the furious? At least Donny Yen had a sword specialty, and the big guy with the hammer at least was big and had a hammer

The blade and Nyssa thing felt forced.

I could go on and on.

I prefer Blade:Trinty to two, but one is my favorite.

 

[LostSon88]

1. Batman Begins
2. Superman Returns
3. Spider-Man 2
4. X2
5. Spider-Man
6. X3
7. X-Men
8. Hellboy
9. FF
10. The Punisher
11. Hulk
12. Daredevil

--Before anyone asks, the reason I haven't counted Superman: The Movie yet is cuz I have yet to really ever watch it in its entirety.

 

[ChrisBaleBatman]

I loved the Punisher, man. Granted, the first half was iffy.....but once that second half kicks into gear, man it was good.

 

[BatFitz]

If one uses IMDB as a reference (hey, one needs to use some kind of measure ) Superman Returns is rated the best Superman movie of all time, and the fourth best Superhero adaption.

I've probably forgot a couple of movies (have not included movies like Matrix and some similar which is not based on a comic).

So what do you think? Is SR one of the best superheromovies of all time? Personally I think it is one of the best, though my all time favourite is the original Superman movie.

But, in this list, where would you put SR? I would place it on 6. place, behind Spider-man (and on a side note let X2 and Superman swap places).

The list, according to IMDB;

1. Batman Begins 8.4/10 (86,494 votes)
2. X2 7.9/10 (53,016 votes)
3. Spider-Man 2 7.8/10 (59,918 votes)
4. Superman Returns 7.5/10 (19,452 votes)
5. Batman 7.4/10 (48,347 votes)
5. Spider-Man 7.4/10 (81,287 votes)
7. X-Men 7.3/10 (58,797 votes)
8. Superman (1978) 7.2/10 (22,914 votes)
9. X-Men: The last Stand 7.0/10 (34,359 votes)
10. Blade 6.8/10 (31,311 votes)
11. Hellboy 6.6/10 (22,040 votes)
11. Batman Returns 6.6/10 (32,065 votes)
13. Superman II 6.5/10 (13,386 votes)
13. Blade II 6.5/10 (22,702 votes)
15. The Punisher (2004) 6.2/10 (15,911 votes)
16. Fantastic Four 6.0/10 (23,873 votes)
16. Hulk 6.0/10 (28,373 votes)
18. Blade Trinity 5.7/10 (14,807 votes)
19. Daredevil 5.6/10 (27,839 votes)
20. Batmand Forever 5.4/10 (32,150 votes)
21. The Punisher (1989) 4.8/10 (2,700 votes)
22. Superman III 4.5/10 (8,359 votes)
22. Spawn 4.5/10 (9,431 votes)
24. Batman&Robin 3.5/10 (37,334 votes)
25. Catwoman 3.3/10 (14,272 votes)
26. Superman IV 3.2/10 (7,698 votes)
27. Captain America 2.6/10 (2,032 votes)

(Note, SR started out with a 7,9 average, but has fallen to 7,5. Only BB of these movies has managed to reach IMDB top 250 (88th. place))

This may just be me, but I think Superman IV should go above Catwoman and Batman & Robin just for the fact that Christopher Reeve is still playing him...

 

[ChrisBaleBatman]

Batman and Robin should be at the very bottom. That thing is the worst thing ever made.

 

[BatFitz]

I actually kind of liked Captain America...but I was a kid at the time and I don't remember anything about it....and I can't find it anywhere to buy

 

[Robin91939]

10.) THE PUNISHER
9.) DAREDEVIL (director's cut)
8.) SIN CITY
7.) X-MEN
6.) SUPERMAN: THE MOVIE
5.) X2: X-MEN UNITED
4.) SUPERMAN RETURNS
3.) SPIDER-MAN
2.) SPIDER-MAN 2
1.) BATMAN BEGINS

-R