Comics Storm VS Rogue

[Exploding Boy]

Like i've said before, storm can call a thunderstorm with a snap of her fingers, so i doubt she'd be near her...and who say's she can't move while calling one up?

Well no matter how long it takes her, it wont make a difference in the battle.

 

[mightiest_mortal]

i think it wud just be a one hit battle based soley on reflexes. Storms only chance would be to hit Rogue with an instantaenous bolt of lightning before rogue can take her out, and Vice Versa. The only thing is, i know Sunfires powers allow him to absorb different kinds of energy, such as solar energy and electro magnetic energy so im not entirely sure how a lightning bolt would actually effect her. If it doesn't.. Storms screwed. If it does, id say it was 50:50 whoever gets the first hit in.

 

[The Weather God]

i think it wud just be a one hit battle based soley on reflexes. Storms only chance would be to hit Rogue with an instantaenous bolt of lightning before rogue can take her out, and Vice Versa. The only thing is, i know Sunfires powers allow him to absorb different kinds of energy, such as solar energy and electro magnetic energy so im not entirely sure how a lightning bolt would actually effect her. If it doesn't.. Storms screwed. If it does, id say it was 50:50 whoever gets the first hit in.

But the comic said the lightning bolt diden't affect her. But I've said before....lightning isen't storm's only power, storm's got some serious power that will kill her in an instant. All she has to do is hold her down with a powerful wind force and let-her-rip.

 

[Mistopurr83]

I like these two women a lot. I consider them both to be top super vixens in the Marvel universe. I would rather not see them fight. I think that's a tough question to answer b/c when Rogue has additional permanent powers (Ms. Marvel or Sunfire's) she seems just as powerful as Storm.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Yes unless you tell me how she can dodge an air pressure attack.

People like you are the main reason I posted each of their powers as detailed as possible. With Sunfire's powers Rogue's mutant powers enable her to absorb solar and other radiation to generate the process of ionized matter (usually air) through a mentally-triggered unknown biochemical process so that it is converted to plasma, the superheated state of matter. So by Storm sending air pressure Rogue's way, she might actually help her out, LMAO

Face it, I love Storm and am aware of her power. I respect her for many reasons, but I actually think the new Rogue stands a better chance then the old one. Only because the new Rogue is elemental, Ms. Marvel Rogue would've only had strength, which is nothing when dealing against Storm.
The new Rogue very well may be able to kill the infamous "Weather Goddess"

 

[Rogue's Hand]

I don't like to get into these arguments but Storm could easily stay out of Rogue's reach with her much faster flight speed combined with hurricane force winds directed at Rogue.

If you want to base this battle on mere random comic events, then fine.

Then how do you explain this? Pre-Ms.Marvel powers

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Thankyou



No she can't

Yes she can, I proved you wrong a few posts up

 

[HandOfFate]

Okay, here the thing, if this was old school Rogue, I would could see her pulling off a slight majority (6 out of 10, giving her speed) but Rogue with Sunfire's power she loses most of the time.

Now that I think about it, even Ms. Marvel's power are iffy, seeing that Rogue was almost killed by a laser-like hand gun (See Uncanny X-Men 173)

This was pointed out on another board in a Storm Vs Human Torch debate. While Rogue might withstand the heat from a lightning bolt, she can't withstand the electrical shock, especially seeing that she now has normal durability (IIRC)

 

[Rogue's Hand]

i think it wud just be a one hit battle based soley on reflexes. Storms only chance would be to hit Rogue with an instantaenous bolt of lightning before rogue can take her out, and Vice Versa. The only thing is, i know Sunfires powers allow him to absorb different kinds of energy, such as solar energy and electro magnetic energy so im not entirely sure how a lightning bolt would actually effect her. If it doesn't.. Storms screwed. If it does, id say it was 50:50 whoever gets the first hit in.

Dude you are so on point!
You rock!

 

[Exploding Boy]

Okay, here the thing, if this was old school Rogue, I would could see her pulling off a slight majority (6 out of 10, giving her speed) but Rogue with Sunfire's power she loses most of the time.

This was pointed out on another board in a Storm Vs Human Torch debate. While Rogue might withstand the heat from a lightning bolt, she can't withstand the electrical shock, especially seeing that she now has normal durability (IIRC)

Well the Human Torch and Sunfire(Rogue) dont have the same powers

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Okay, here the thing, if this was old school Rogue, I would could see her pulling off a slight majority (6 out of 10, giving her speed) but Rogue with Sunfire's power she loses most of the time.

This was pointed out on another board in a Storm Vs Human Torch debate. While Rogue might withstand the heat from a lightning bolt, she can't withstand the electrical shock, especially seeing that she now has normal durability (IIRC)

I pointed out a back issue where Rogue laughed off a lightning bolt.
Pre-Ms. Marvel powers, so what makes you think she can't do it now?

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Well the Human Torch and Sunfire(Rogue) dont have the same powers

"Rogue can generate plasma temperatures which match those that can be generated by the Human Torch, reaching about 1,000,000 degrees Fahrenheit at maximum level. She can also use her power in a massive blast similar to Johnny Storm's "Nova Burst". However, Rogue has much more control over the area of effect, enough to where one person may feel like they have been sunbathing all day to total incineration of another target." She actually has more control then Johnny

 

[The Weather God]

People like you are the main reason I posted each of their powers as detailed as possible. With Sunfire's powers Rogue's mutant powers enable her to absorb solar and other radiation to generate the process of ionized matter (usually air) through a mentally-triggered unknown biochemical process so that it is converted to plasma, the superheated state of matter. So by Storm sending air pressure Rogue's way, she might actually help her out, LMAO

Face it, I love Storm and am aware of her power. I respect her for many reasons, but I actually think the new Rogue stands a better chance then the old one. Only because the new Rogue is elemental, Ms. Marvel Rogue would've only had strength, which is nothing when dealing against Storm.
The new Rogue very well may be able to kill the infamous "Weather Goddess"

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, your anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

 

[Exploding Boy]

"Rogue can generate plasma temperatures which match those that can be generated by the Human Torch, reaching about 1,000,000 degrees Fahrenheit at maximum level. She can also use her power in a massive blast similar to Johnny Storm's "Nova Burst". However, Rogue has much more control over the area of effect, enough to where one person may feel like they have been sunbathing all day to total incineration of another target." She actually has more control then Johnny

Not just that but they have different aspects to their powers.

...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

You cannot be serious. A heat wave?

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, you anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did you just say HEAT WAVE????
You have to be kidding me. If Storm brings any type of heat into the picture she is commiting suicide. Her best bet is trying to make it as cold as possible, but even then she has to be ready for what's to come. Rogue has direct control over the temperature around her! Which means it can be zero degrees in the atmosphere, but Rogue will still be scorching HOT! LOL!
I'm glad I started this poll. I have point to prove

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, you anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did you just say HEAT WAVE????
You have to be kidding me. If Storm brings any type of heat into the picture she is commiting suicide. Her best bet is trying to make it as cold as possible, but even then she has to be ready for what's to come. Rogue has direct control over the temperature around her! Which means it can be zero degrees in the atmosphere, but Rogue will still be scorching HOT! LOL!
I'm glad I started this poll. I have point to prove

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, you anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did you just say HEAT WAVE????
You have to be kidding me. If Storm brings any type of heat into the picture she is commiting suicide. Her best bet is trying to make it as cold as possible, but even then she has to be ready for what's to come. Rogue has direct control over the temperature around her! Which means it can be zero degrees in the atmosphere, but Rogue will still be scorching HOT! LOL!
I'm glad I started this poll. I have point to prove

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, you anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did you just say HEAT WAVE????
You have to be kidding me. If Storm brings any type of heat into the picture she is commiting suicide. Her best bet is trying to make it as cold as possible, but even then she has to be ready for what's to come. Rogue has direct control over the temperature around her! Which means it can be zero degrees in the atmosphere, but Rogue will still be scorching HOT! LOL!
I'm glad I started this poll. I have point to prove

 

[The Weather God]

Not just that but they have different aspects to their powers.


You cannot be serious. A heat wave?

Yes! storm has control over the stars. Also that lightning bolt coulden't have been the strongest of storm's power, storm's even affected apocalypse with her lightning. But Seeing how smart storm is she could create a fog , then swallow rogue up in a fat juicy tornado or hurricane.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, you anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did you just say HEAT WAVE????
You have to be kidding me. If Storm brings any type of heat into the picture she is commiting suicide. Her best bet is trying to make it as cold as possible, but even then she has to be ready for what's to come. Rogue has direct control over the temperature around her! Which means it can be zero degrees in the atmosphere, but Rogue will still be scorching HOT! LOL!
I'm glad I started this poll. I have point to prove

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, you anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did you just say HEAT WAVE????
You have to be kidding me. If Storm brings any type of heat into the picture she is commiting suicide. Her best bet is trying to make it as cold as possible, but even then she has to be ready for what's to come. Rogue has direct control over the temperature around her! Which means it can be zero degrees in the atmosphere, but Rogue will still be scorching HOT! LOL!
I'm glad I started this poll. I have point to prove

 

[HandOfFate]

I pointed out a back issue where Rogue laughed off a lightning bolt.
Pre-Ms. Marvel powers, so what makes you think she can't do it now?

Uh...Storm has never hit Rogue with a lightning bolt. Storm rarely hit anything with a lightning bolt, she usually strike something with a bio-electric bolt.

A real lightning bolt from Storm has actually affect the Silver Surfer and believe me Rogue's Ms. Marvel's durability is not in his league.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Lol you really did a number on that one but now I'll let you in on something. I don't think rogue can grasp on to absord such presures of air. If you think she can. Prove it. I truly believe that storm can hold rogue down with wind force, just like i stated before, you never proved that she could handle strong air pressures of wind like that. she can't even handle storm's power. So no, your anwser hasen't changed my mind one bit because...... of course like i've stated before....that's not all storm's got. How about a heat wave.......

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did you just say HEAT WAVE????
You have to be kidding me. If Storm brings any type of heat into the picture she is commiting suicide. Her best bet is trying to make it as cold as possible, but even then she has to be ready for what's to come. Rogue has direct control over the temperature around her! Which means it can be zero degrees in the atmosphere, but Rogue will still be scorching HOT! LOL!
I'm glad I started this poll. I have point to prove

 

[The Weather God]

Uh...Storm has never hit Rogue with a lightning bolt. Storm rarely hit anything with a lightning bolt, she usually strike something with a bio-electric bolt.

A real lightning bolt from Storm has actually affect the Silver Surfer and believe me Rogue's Ms. Marvel's durability is not in his league.

I knew Ms Marvel wasen't strong enough to handle storm's true lightning.

 

[Exploding Boy]

Woow super double post