Comics Storm VS Rogue

[X_fan08]

agreed. rouge seems to be using these new powers pretty well too. and so soon. its inly a matter of time before sunfire becomes a problem for rouge and sunfire gets his powers back frm her like marvel did

 

[The Weather God]

I agree

and i said a heat-wave because i wasen't sure if we were talking about the Sunfire Rogue or the Ms Marvel one(which could beat her.)

 

[Rogue's Hand]

We are using the Sunfire Rogue as reference.

 

[HandOfFate]

We are using the Sunfire Rogue as reference.

Then in my humble opinion she won't win. Ms. Marvel's powers have a much better chance of winning against Storm.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Then in my humble opinion she won't win. Ms. Marvel's powers have a much better chance of winning against Storm.

How? Storm is an elemental based mutant, Ms. Marvel can't stand a chance. Atleast with the new powers Rogue can shoot flames at a distance, Ms. Marvel's powers would only be useful up close and I doubt Rogue is getting close to Storm.

 

[toya thegr8]

Is this even a question? Storm beats Rogue. Period.

@ The Weather God, don't worry about it, just state your choice and bounce. Goodness knows Storm's 1980s dialogue and her having a fan makes her an automatic loser.

 

[PhoenixWillRise]

Storm!

 

[X_fan08]

Is this even a question? Storm beats Rogue. Period.

@ The Weather God, don't worry about it, just state your choice and bounce. Goodness knows Storm's 1980s dialogue and her having a fan makes her an automatic loser.

but its fun to disscuss and tell others your opinion in detail, Ms toya.

and i think that sunfire rouge stands a better chance but rouge/marvel is a good choice as well. she stands a chance anyway.

 

[Nightwolf]

I like Rogue way better but Storm is too powerful and would never let rogue get near her. There's a reason why Storm was the second leader and Rogue is like 5th, behind nightcrawler and Havok. Storm has the better skills and a more varied attack.

 

[HandOfFate]

How? Storm is an elemental based mutant, Ms. Marvel can't stand a chance.

You should really factor in Rogue's enhanced speed and durability during this fight, it gives her a much better chance of winning.

Atleast with the new powers Rogue can shoot flames at a distance, Ms. Marvel's powers would only be useful up close and I doubt Rogue is getting close to Storm.

Flame blast Vs Lightning bolt, which strikes first?

 

[mightiest_mortal]

hmmm.. is there even any point doing a justified argument here?
Dark Storms even been brought up so think im on a losing case trying to convince anyone...

Rogue would win.
Before anyone says im biased because of my Sig, ive already explained that without any absorbed powers Storm would win, and even with Ms Marvels powers, Storm would probably win aswell.
People are seriously underestimating Sunfire. He is an Elemental much like Storm, and has had to wear costumes in the past to control and supress his energy because its too powerfull.
The only thing that is the deciding factor in this fight is that apparently, Storms lightning bolts dont hurt Rogue, even without powers aborbed (god knows how.. it makes no sense.. but it was backed up earlier in the thread..) Sunfires ability to absorb different kinds of energy probably only helps her.

Without her lightning Storm doesnt have another attack that would be instantaneous that could do enough damage to take Rogue out completely. Rogue does. Whatever attack or defense she could conjure up, Rogue would just incinerate her whilt she trying to do it. Instatneousness is the key.

You should really factor in Rogue's enhanced speed and durability during this fight, it gives her a much better chance of winning

Her speed and durability were from when she had MS MArvels powers, were basing Rogue on her current state with Sunfires powers. She wouldnt really need them any way to take out storm with her flame.

Flame blast Vs Lightning bolt, which strikes first?

Well, If Rogue is immune to lightning bolts, this wouldn't matter either. Storm wud be screwed.

I like Rogue way better but Storm is too powerful and would never let rogue get near her. There's a reason why Storm was the second leader and Rogue is like 5th, behind nightcrawler and Havok. Storm has the better skills and a more varied attack.

With her current powers, Rogue would not need to be that close to flame grill Storm + U dont need a varied attack if you can just instantaneously incinerate someone in one move.

How? Storm is an elemental based mutant, Ms. Marvel can't stand a chance. Atleast with the new powers Rogue can shoot flames at a distance, Ms. Marvel's powers would only be useful up close and I doubt Rogue is getting close to Storm.

With her current powers, Rogue is also an elemental.

Storm isen't just powerful, she's smart at using her power and that's another key thing that helps her win battles, even against mutants stronger then her.

Being Smart wont help her from being instantly incinerated.

she doesnt have to get rid of oxygen. it can be sucked out as she generates a vortex around rouge to suck the oxygen from her. i sae that on sky high..... heh he

Thatd take too long. Shed be incinerated whilst the "vortex" was sucking out the air.

Storm could create an electromagnetic pulse and drown out rogue's sheild, storm's already immuned to lightning so it won't hurt her one bit. But rogue isen't

With Sunfires powers Rogue can absorb electromagnetic energy. An electromagnetic pulse will just make her stronger.

She could just thin out the air to the point that Rogue couldn't produce a flame.

Storm Vs the Human Torch

As that fourth Page explains, Johnny only lost because he wasn't prepared to kill Storm, otherwise she wouldn't have stood a chance.
he says..
"One shot of Nova Flame, instant mutant crispy critter. Has to be that, nothing else will reach her. She loses. I win. its that simple. I live but she dies. Thats what im talking about."

 

[HandOfFate]

The only thing that is the deciding factor in this fight is that apparently, Storms lightning bolts dont hurt Rogue, even without powers aborbed (god knows how.. it makes no sense.. but it was backed up earlier in the thread..) Sunfires ability to absorb different kinds of energy probably only helps her.

Give me an issue number showing me Rogue absorbing lightning. Until then your just giving an opinion with nothing to back it up.

Now think about it. Storm has overpowered Polaris with her lightning bolt and Polaris is all about manipulation of EM fields. So, do you really think Sunfire/Rogue can do better then Polaris when it comes to absorbing EM energy?

As that fourth Page explains, Johnny only lost because he wasn't prepared to kill Storm, otherwise she wouldn't have stood a chance.

he says..

"One shot of Nova Flame, instant mutant crispy critter. Has to be that, nothing else will reach her. She loses. I win. its that simple. I live but she dies. Thats what im talking about."

Johnny was assuming that would work. There was no real way of knowning if it would.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Is this even a question? Storm beats Rogue. Period.

@ The Weather God, don't worry about it, just state your choice and bounce. Goodness knows Storm's 1980s dialogue and her having a fan makes her an automatic loser.

The point of this thread is because Storm fans are very bias.
Storm is basically an X-Men poster girl. Everyone loves her, I do also.
But I have reason to believe the new Rogue will have a chance in a battle with her. Storm is not an Omega, she might have Omega traits but she is no Phoenix. Rogue can also burn her to a crisp. With a nuke it's a wrap and you know it.

 

[The Weather God]

The point of this thread is because Storm fans are very bias.
Storm is basically an X-Men poster girl. Everyone loves her, I do also.
But I have reason to believe the new Rogue will have a chance in a battle with her. Storm is not an Omega, she might have Omega traits but she is no Phoenix. Rogue can also burn her to a crisp. With a nuke it's a wrap and you know it.

The fact that storm isen't an omega doesn't mean she hasen't been on that status, but that's for another discussion.

Give me an issue number showing me Rogue absorbing lightning. Until then your just giving an opinion with nothing to back it up.

Now think about it. Storm has overpowered Polaris with her lightning bolt and Polaris is all about manipulation of EM fields. So, do you really think Sunfire/Rogue can do better then Polaris when it comes to absorbing EM energy

That's a really good point, and i'm sure rogue isen't mastered at EM fields so it will be no contest in this situation.

Is this even a question? Storm beats Rogue. Period.

@ The Weather God, don't worry about it, just state your choice and bounce. Goodness knows Storm's 1980s dialogue and her having a fan makes her an automatic loser.

Sorry toya, but there's gotta be some stormfans bringing up facts for her in this dicussion.

 

[Mistopurr83]

Let's add photos to this thread.

 

[X_fan08]

The point of this thread is because Storm fans are very bias.
Storm is basically an X-Men poster girl. Everyone loves her, I do also.
But I have reason to believe the new Rogue will have a chance in a battle with her. Storm is not an Omega, she might have Omega traits but she is no Phoenix. Rogue can also burn her to a crisp. With a nuke it's a wrap and you know it.

storm fans are not bias. im not bias. wtf. explain poster girl for me. if u mean all talk n looks and no show then u are sadly mistaken. we know that she is not an omega, storm fans know this and why the hell would we compare this to phoenix> and u said she could nuke her too? r u serious,LMFAO!!!! in the aoa anniversary, jean returned as alpha mutant or phoenix.. whatever. when she was about to attack the x-men with her fire blast, sunfire tried to hold off her fire but could not withstand it cuz he was gettin burned the F*** up. We love storm too but that doesnt make all fans bias because we just high expectations like u and rouge or for any other character. and if we are bias, then why hold this thread to read our "bias" babble?

 

[S7ilver]

and if we are bias, then why hold this thread to read our "bias" babble?

Good point.

 

[Exploding Boy]

Im for Rogue in this fight, but saying she is immune to a lighting bolt is complete garbage. Sunfire can not absorb that kind of energy.

 

[The Weather God]

I think we have a clear winner for sunfire/rogue. Storm's lightning will strike Rogue faster then she could call up energy for a nuke blast.

 

[X_fan08]

Im for Rogue in this fight, but saying she is immune to a lighting bolt is complete garbage. Sunfire can not absorb that kind of energy.

thank u. i said that the lightning absorbed was dumb. marvel.com does say that she can absorb the electromag energy but fans go on there and add in. i need a comic issue stating this to make me a beliver.

 

[Kmack]

Storm.

 

[toya thegr8]

The point of this thread is because Storm fans are very bias.

Oh, so you create this thread to show that Storm fans are bias? So to prove myself not to be rabid to other character-fans I must say Storm loses no matter what? Er, nuh.

I'm pretty sure they're many, many characters that can destroy Storm, I just don't think Rogue is one. Rogue isn't going down like a punk, but Storm wins. Period. Of course it's only an opinion.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Oh, so you create this thread to show that Storm fans are bias? So to prove myself not to be rabid to other character-fans I must say Storm loses no matter what? Er, nuh.

I'm pretty sure they're many, many characters that can destroy Storm, I just don't think Rogue is one. Rogue isn't going down like a punk, but Storm wins. Period. Of course it's only an opinion.

I agree with you, it is an opinion but I don't agree when people say Rogue CANT beat Storm. As if she has no possibility of winning.
I do not agree with that at all.

 

[Exploding Boy]

thank u. i said that the lightning absorbed was dumb. marvel.com does say that she can absorb the electromag energy but fans go on there and add in. i need a comic issue stating this to make me a beliver.

Well Marvel.com also says that Shiro creates a force field that prevents air friction from effecting him. That makes him immune to Storms air attacks

 

[Tee21]

All storm would have to do is ionize the air and electricute her. CASE CLOSED!!!

Or she could just crush her with the ATMOSPHERE ITSELF--Jovia pressure anyone?? another case that's CLOSED

Or she could just fry her nervous system from the inside out. The ****'s REALLY closed then.

Hasn't Storm munipulated plasma as well???