Jordacar
The Endless One
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2007
- Messages
- 6,147
- Reaction score
- 469
- Points
- 73
The finale was good for having to squeeze the whole 3rd act of the book into just 2 episodes. Some thoughts:
Overall, great show, great season, great adaptation, so glad it was saved from the chopping block. Looking forward to how they tackle Cibola Burn.
Remember Father Cortez? Anna shared a few words with him, and they have a ton of back-and-forth in the book. Did he die off-screen in the speed change like the blind guy? Pity to set both of them up and then just discard them like that.
I was annoyed when Clarissa went straight from a prison cell to the command deck. It was such a contrived way to get her in place. Truncating the story meant losing the whole mutiny and Ashford recruiting her and taking back the Behemoth, plus some great moral digressions about forgiveness between her and Cortez.
I also missed the rest of the fight between her, Naomi, and Anna. It's my favorite scene in the book, though cutting it down wasn't surprising.
The way they streamlined things also made Ashford seem like less of a callous psycho, which I guess is an improvement?
That was a nice hat trick they did with Drummer. Setting her up for the same last stand as Bull in the book before the last-minute save by Naomi. She's just too fun a character to let go of.
And I guess Bobbi is joining the Roci now? I don't mind seeing more of Bobbi, and I know she comes back in book 5. I guess it makes sense in the context of the show.
I was annoyed when Clarissa went straight from a prison cell to the command deck. It was such a contrived way to get her in place. Truncating the story meant losing the whole mutiny and Ashford recruiting her and taking back the Behemoth, plus some great moral digressions about forgiveness between her and Cortez.
I also missed the rest of the fight between her, Naomi, and Anna. It's my favorite scene in the book, though cutting it down wasn't surprising.
The way they streamlined things also made Ashford seem like less of a callous psycho, which I guess is an improvement?
That was a nice hat trick they did with Drummer. Setting her up for the same last stand as Bull in the book before the last-minute save by Naomi. She's just too fun a character to let go of.
And I guess Bobbi is joining the Roci now? I don't mind seeing more of Bobbi, and I know she comes back in book 5. I guess it makes sense in the context of the show.