The wraparound story is from the director of Deadgirl. I really liked Deadgirl, so I was looking forward to this. It seems like too many of these shorts are about a guy videotaping a female's body parts and then Horror happens. That is not a story. However, it soon gets weird, then it gets stupid, then bad voice acting turns it to crap and it ends really stupid. The wraparound story sucked on the last one too. This was all over the map and seemed to be mostly filler (not a good idea when its a short). I really wish they'd knock it off with these wraparound stories because they have to really reach to get where they want to go.
The first complete short is from director Gregg Bishop, who I'm not really familiar with. It's a mockumentary about a loser who becomes a famous magician. This was goofy (and predictable), but entertained me more than the vast majority of segments from this series. Because the idea was that the magician had people filming him, they were able to take a more traditional filming style with the climax scene. It felt like some of the old anthology tv series in that it wasn't "horror" in the sense that VHS stories usually are...just a stand alone story that deals with a Horror concept.
The next story is from Nacho Vigalondo (Timecrimes, Open Windows). It's a sci-fi story about a guy trying to invent something. I can see where the people who loved the first few would hate this one now...but I actually liked the concept behind this story as well. It kept my interest. This gets pretty crazy, and really kind of stupid...but again...I was intrigued by the beginning and I smiled at the absurd end...so that counts as entertainment.
The next story is from the directors of Resolution...one of the best Horror movies in years (and my favorite film of ANY genre last year). It's about skateboarders filming their stunts. This is the most similar to the previous VHS films...introduce some people we don't like, then have a Horror genre type event happen to them. Yeah...I tried to like this one but didn't. It's just a dud.
This question comes up a lot for me in found footage...but who in the heck edited these shorts? They are supposed to be evil tapes or whatever...did Satan take the time to switch camera shots etc?