Superman Returns The Official Brandon Routh IS Superman thread.

[Ruthmarks]

 

[IT is Batgirl]

*cough*

http://www.brandonrouth.com/gallery/index.php?cat=27

 

[JcDc]

Actually I always thought in the face Tom Cruise looks a little like a mix between Christopher Reeve and Scott Wolf

 

[superfever]

i thought he looks like harrison ford junior.

 

[Lone]

 

[Pickle-El]

Thoughts now?

 

[Captain Villa]

Thoughts now?

PROMISING

 

[Lobo]

He looks like Reeve

 

[Lone]

Naysayers got PWNED.

 

[Pickle-El]

Naysayers got PWNED.

 

[JcDc]

Naysayers got PWNED.

They will now deny like suckers

 

[drknight]

Lone][/b]
Naysayers got PWNED.

They will now deny like suckers

Just needed to do it.

 

[Lone]

They will now deny like suckers

Either that they'll just say: "I NEVER DOUBTED HIM FOR A SECOND!!!"

 

[Kolzig]

Damn Brandon looks good in the official pics.
Nice to see that the gym has bulked him up even more than before the role.

 

[superfever]

he is getting better and better. no doubt about it.

 

[Ruthmarks]

Either that they'll just say: "I NEVER DOUBTED HIM FOR A SECOND!!!"

No, they've just said he "looks too much like Reeve" or that "he looks too dorky" or something of that nature (one even complained that Clark Kent didn't look "cool" -- not quite understanding that CK isn't supposed to be the cool guy).

But the rant that takes the cake is the poor guy from CHUD saying that he looks "like a drag queen." That is probably the most singularly inane and ridiculous "criticism" that I've seen yet -- and one more reason why CHUD is going the way of AICN.

 

[StarvingArtist]

Ok, here's an idea. Would it be unreasonable to start a "naysayers not allowed" thread for people who are excited about this movie and want to discuss it rather then fight with people who nitpick and ***** about every little thing? These discussion boards have become just one big warzone and it's lost most of its appeal imo.

 

[terry78]

Ok, here's an idea. Would it be unreasonable to start a "naysayers not allowed" thread for people who are excited about this movie and want to discuss it rather then fight with people who nitpick and ***** about every little thing? These discussion boards have become just one big warzone and it's lost most of its appeal imo.

Nah, everytime someone suggests that the naysayers leave about a topic, they make it known that it's their right to debate it. So it wouldn't really do any good.

 

[Antonello Blueberry]

Nah, everytime someone suggests that the naysayers leave about a topic, they make it known that it's their right to debate it. So it wouldn't really do any good.

Probably because it is their right to debate and dissent.

 

[Ruthmarks]

Probably because it is their right to debate and dissent.

Very true. But too often the "right to debate and dissent" is used as a flimsy cover to "goad and trash."

Let me also add that a few people have made some very thoughtful comments on why they're concerned about the new film, and while I may not always agree, I can certainly see where they're coming from and respect that.

 

[JcDc]

As long as they aren't going to personal insults I don't mind the naysayers coming in. I mean guys, we have the ammunition. Routh looks awesome, the movie is coming a long, etc... I could care less if naysayers come in. They are just entertainment for me as they deny the obvious, Routh has the look and there is potential for this to be a good movie

 

[Captain Villa]

[/i]


Just needed to do it.

Looks more like "BRANDO".

 

[Lone]

Very true. But too often the "right to debate and dissent" is used as a flimsy cover to "goad and trash."

I agree.

Let me also add that a few people have made some very thoughtful comments on why they're concerned about the new film, and while I may not always agree, I can certainly see where they're coming from and respect that.

People like Alonsovich, Matt, The Incredible Hulk and I'm sure I'm missing a few names.

 

[M.E.H.Z.E.B]

Seeing the development of the "Tom Welling Should Have Been Superman" thread in the SV forums, and the stuff that go on over there, I feel that we should atleast try to keep this thread alive.

well, lets get to it.

 

[bweurk]