• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Thursday Aug 14, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST. This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

The Dark Knight Rises The Official Harley Quinn Thread

Who Should Portray Harley Quinn?

  • Amy Acker

  • Fairuza Balk

  • Kristen Bell

  • Zooey Deschanel

  • Anna Faris

  • Sarah Michelle Gellar

  • Brittany Murphy

  • Pauley Perrette

  • Christina Ricci

  • Marley Shelton

  • Other

  • Amy Acker

  • Fairuza Balk

  • Kristen Bell

  • Zooey Deschanel

  • Anna Faris

  • Sarah Michelle Gellar

  • Brittany Murphy

  • Pauley Perrette

  • Christina Ricci

  • Marley Shelton

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Rachel McAdams could make a good harley and i can see her as a good harleen quinsel... just a thought
 
I like the idea of Rachel Macadams as Harley but idk if she'd be up to it, i just dont see her doing a movie like this. But i like taht idea.

Here are my suggestions on who should play her:
1. Mena Suvari (i know it was already suggested)
2. Tara Reid? -I know she can play the ditzy Harley but the Doctor part i could see her as a serious person though so i'd say she'd work.

AS for Brittany Murphy i could see her as Harley but what about Harleen? I do like the idea though since Crane is a whackjob now to bring this character to Arkham and run the place and she could go crazy somehow.
 
^Like Falcone said, the nuts are running the nuthouse. That's been a staple of Arkham Asylum for years.
 
I like the idea of Mena Survari.

Tara Reid.... I don't consider her much of an actress. I've never been impressed by her.
 
Bullseye said:
I like the idea of Mena Survari.

Tara Reid.... I don't consider her much of an actress. I've never been impressed by her.

Neither have I because she was just horrible in most of the stuff she was in, but if she did try i could see her be a serious Dr. Harleen, and then anyone could be pulled off the street to play a psycho ditzy Harley and she could be herself from then on.
 
If Tara Reid actually tried to act an takeon some diffrent roles than the same thing, then I might consider her as good possiblity for Harley.
 
McAdams is one my favourite actresses and I really would hope that she would consider a role like Harley.
 
I'm still all for Sheri Moon Zombie
Fits (how I pictured Harley anyway) perfectly, plus she can actually act!
sherimoonzombie-misc2.jpg

1000corpses-baby3.jpg

1000corpses-baby6.jpg



In this pic; I could easily picture it being a screen of her coming home from working at Arkham, drenched from the rain:
TOOLBOX_MURDERS-11.jpg
 
Bullseye said:
I have decided on my top four choice's for the role of Harley Quinn:

Alison Lohman
alisonlohman2664ik.jpg





Other honorable mentions are Elisha Cuthbert, Alyson Hannigan and Zooey Deschanel.
Alison Lohman was actually my choice for Babs but she's getting older now. To bad.
 
x-periment said:
Sheri Moon would be great!!!

I'd agree. When I watched "House Of 1,000 Corpses" I felt like I WAS watching Harley Quinn whenever she showed up on screen.

jag
 
Okay, so I'm totally still against having Harley in this film at all, but if she were to be...

After seeing Superman Returns, I'm convinced Parker Posey could pull it off.

Of course, I don't know how she'd look as a blonde or anything, but she's got the character pretty well.
 
sheri moon WAS Harley quinn in devils rejects!

^
watch the movie and you WILL be convinced
 
shaggyaggie457 said:
After seeing Superman Returns, I'm convinced Parker Posey could pull it off.

Of course, I don't know how she'd look as a blonde or anything, but she's got the character pretty well.

I disagree. They're two totally different, divergent characters altogether. Posey's Kitty Kowalski is a direct nod to Valerie Perrine's Ms. Tesmacher from the 1978 "Superman" film. Both of those characters were dim-witted women who really loathed Lex underneath the surface (to the point that they couldn't stop themselves from insulting him), but were too attracted to his power and wealth (and too afraid to be alone) to follow their hearts true calling and do the right things with their lives.

Harley Quinn on the other hand is just as much of a deranged nutjob as The Joker is, which is why she fails to recognize him as a psycopath. She's completely devoted to him, almost to the point of sycophantic worship, and kills and dies (sort of) for him. They're like a matched set of lunatics. Very different character from the character Posey portrayed in "Superman Returns". Besides, Posey has already done Blade and now Supes and going for the tri-fecta probably isn't on her or any filmmaker's agenda.

At any rate, this is all circumspect because Quinn most likely won't (and shouldn't) be in the next Bat's film, anyway.

jag
 
Marvel Man said:
Have to agree could care less
well... i only chose her out of the top of my head because she has the voice and the big eyes just like harley..... maybe she could act lik her who knows really?

but shes my second choice.........and NO WHERE NEAR as perfect as sheri moon would be<<<<PERFECT:up:
 
xwolverine2 said:
well... i only chose her out of the top of my head because she has the voice and the big eyes just like harley..... maybe she could act lik her who knows really?

but shes my second choice.........and NO WHERE NEAR as perfect as sheri moon would be<<<<PERFECT:up:

I know im jsut saying id rather have the joker, Harley Quinn just isnt one of my favorite Batman characters.
 
No more Parker Posey please, she helped ruin Blade 3, she almost killed Superman for me, I like her but please don't allow her to destroy another Comicbook film!
 
Marvel Man said:
I know im jsut saying id rather have the joker, Harley Quinn just isnt one of my favorite Batman characters.
i completely agree with you^:up:

No more Parker Posey please, she helped ruin Blade 3, she almost killed Superman for me, I like her but please don't allow her to destroy another Comicbook film!
i dont even remember her in blade3....and in supes she provided the comic support which she did perfectly... i have nothing against her.

but yeah.... she shouldnt play anyone in BB2
 
xwolverine2 said:
i dont even remember her in blade3....and in supes she provided the comic support which she did perfectly... i have nothing against her.

She was the head vampire girl.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
201,960
Messages
22,042,941
Members
45,842
Latest member
JoeSoap
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"