The official INCREDIBLE Hulk thread...........

Status
Not open for further replies.
You see You use the word "God" like its meant to mean something, that word was used buy huamans long ago to describe beings who could do amazing things, Hell Hulk could be considered a "God", he has powers and abilties beyond most mortal men. God is a subjective term, anybody with great power and strength could of been worshiped as a god long ago.
Hulk's not a god, he's a monster. Simple as that. He's a very powerful monster, but he's not and never should be considered to be able to go toe to toe with Thor, Hercules, Ares, or any of the other name gods in the Marvel Universe.
 
Hulk's not a god, he's a monster. Simple as that. He's a very powerful monster, but he's not and never should be considered to be able to go toe to toe with Thor, Hercules, Ares, or any of the other name gods in the Marvel Universe.

You see you dont get it, in the Marvel U the "Gods" have limits to their powers and strength. Like I said before, God is a term that can be apllied to any being with amazing powers, that dwarf Mortal Men. The "Gods" in the marvel U are not all powerful, majority of them are not even semi-powerful. with you logic Hulk should lose a fight with Hercules wife Hebe, because she is a "God" and thus all powerful.
 
Just say it you are one of those guys that think Hulk should beat anyone and everyone. The truth of the matter is Hulk should not and should never even be on the top tier power list in the Marvel Universe. He's a big roid rage monster, but he should not be able to go toe to toe with Thor.
 
Thor and angry Hulk have been almost evenly matched since back when Kirby drew both titles, regardless of Thor being a god or not. There was even an early issue where fans of both characters were arguing in the street over this. It's part of what makes Thor respect his strength; he's one of the few mortals who can humble him in single combat. Maybe this would be a problem if we were talking about the original Norse Thor, but we're not. The Marvel Thor can be hurt, and Hulk's strength is potentially limitless if he's not knocked out early, so it can go either way. The only time I've called BS was when Red Hulk beat Thor, and that's because the reasoning for Rulk wresting control of Mjolnir from Thor was weak.

It sounds more like you have a problem with the Hulk. Somewhat justifiable, considering Hulk's general fanbase, but in this case it doesn't make your stance any less flawed than someone saying "Hulk should win every time against Thor 'cause I don't like blond-haired pansies with capes."
 
I'm on the side that says Hulk should be able to beat Thor, but these Hulk/Thor fights should be close. Instead, its gotten to the point where Hulk is guaranteed to be Thor the way fire trumps water. The fights are never close anymore. Hulk just beats Thor now. Yet get Wolverine to fight Hulk, and you're guaranteed a close "Match of the Millennium" styled fight where Hulk has to work for his win.

Hulk can beat Thor, and Thanos, and the Silver Surfer, sometimes, but damn it, at least make it look like a struggle.
 
I'm on the side that says Hulk should be able to beat Thor, but these Hulk/Thor fights should be close. Instead, its gotten to the point where Hulk is guaranteed to be Thor the way fire trumps water. The fights are never close anymore. Hulk just beats Thor now. Yet get Wolverine to fight Hulk, and you're guaranteed a close "Match of the Millennium" styled fight where Hulk has to work for his win.

Hulk can beat Thor, and Thanos, and the Silver Surfer, sometimes, but damn it, at least make it look like a struggle.

I agree with this, with Hulks unlimited strength he should be able to beat thor but ofcourse it shouldn't be easy and he shouldn't beat him every time.

It seems to me alot of people have jumped on the hulk hate bandwagon just because it's the popular thing to do and the term fanboy gets thrown about all too often. I wouldn't consider myself a hulk fanboy, I can see the flaws, accept he can be beaten but just seems there's two extremes when it comes to Hulk, people who love him and people who hate him.
 
Last edited:
Just say it you are one of those guys that think Hulk should beat anyone and everyone. The truth of the matter is Hulk should not and should never even be on the top tier power list in the Marvel Universe. He's a big roid rage monster, but he should not be able to go toe to toe with Thor.


That should be He's a big GAMMA RAGED MONSTER and what part of the madder the Hulk get the stronger the Hulk get is confusing you. He's lifted up a mountain for crying out loud. I agree that a Thor vs Hulk fight should be epic. not one page and done. Bah!
 
I'm on the side that says Hulk should be able to beat Thor, but these Hulk/Thor fights should be close. Instead, its gotten to the point where Hulk is guaranteed to be Thor the way fire trumps water. The fights are never close anymore. Hulk just beats Thor now. Yet get Wolverine to fight Hulk, and you're guaranteed a close "Match of the Millennium" styled fight where Hulk has to work for his win.

Hulk can beat Thor, and Thanos, and the Silver Surfer, sometimes, but damn it, at least make it look like a struggle.

No way should Hulk be able to beat Thanos or Silver Surfer and argubly Thor. It would be different if Thor relied solely on strength but he doesn't. Mjolnir should be the difference maker but you have crazy writing like Loeb who makes Rulk be able to lift it and throw it to the moon when he's not even worthy to lift it off the ground, screw the magical laws of Mjolnir says Loeb. :doh:
 
I'm on the side that either Thor or the Hulk could win depending on a variety of factors because THAT'S WHAT MAKES A GOOD F***ING RIVALRY. The Hulk/Thor feud is a joke at this point because it's not a feud, it's a Hulk-will-always-kick-Thor's-ass-no-matter-what situation. Even worse, the rest of the Marvel universe is joining in on the fun. As great as it is to have Thor back and at a relative high in popularity, it's a pretty godawful time to be a Thor fan if you actually like seeing Thor win, ever. The last really great fight Thor had--and actually won--was the one against Bor in Thor #600. Even the Thor/Sentry fight in Siege was boring because I was just waiting for the Sentry to kick Thor's ass and move onto the rest of the heroes; and sure enough, Thor's easily tossed aside like a ragdoll, Asgard falls, and now all the heroes are up against the Void. It's pretty much a foregone conclusion that Thor's gonna look like a chump in any fight he gets into now.
 
Last edited:
The only person Thor beats the majority of the time is Hercules :( Because that's when Mjolnir decides to work :whatever:
 
JMS really handled Thor well. He was how he should be. THAT Thor I'd put against almost anyone.
 
JMS did write a great Thor, even though he steadily decreased his power level during his run. But he wrote that Bor fight, which instantly became one of my favorite comic fights ever, so he'll always have that to balance the scales. :)
 
World War Hulks #1 Preview

ivy53s.jpg


14e819g.jpg


After the jaw-dropping conclusion of FALL OF THE HULKS, secrets, mysteries and surprises galore are revealed in this giant-sized, bone-crushing, gamma-irradiated special featuring key players of the biggest Hulk-saga ever told: A-BOMB, COSMIC HULK, RED SHE-HULK, DOC SAMSON and DEADPOOL! What is the heart-breaking decision that Rick Jones must make? Is there a hero left in the dark abyss of Leonard Samson’s distorted mind? Whose appearance will shock the wild Red She-Hulk to her core? Can an ancient alien technology spell certain apocalypse to the world? Don’t miss out on this essential assembly of startling secrets in one of the greatest conspiracies in the history of the Marvel Universe!!! Rated T …$3.99
 
I'm on the side that says Hulk should be able to beat Thor, but these Hulk/Thor fights should be close. Instead, its gotten to the point where Hulk is guaranteed to be Thor the way fire trumps water. The fights are never close anymore. Hulk just beats Thor now. Yet get Wolverine to fight Hulk, and you're guaranteed a close "Match of the Millennium" styled fight where Hulk has to work for his win.

Hulk can beat Thor, and Thanos, and the Silver Surfer, sometimes, but damn it, at least make it look like a struggle.

No Hulk cannot beat Thanos. That is absolutely ridiculous. Thanos could just teleport Hulk to a black hole somewhere.
 
Ace I'm surprised you ever debated that. Thanos is a universal threat while the Hulk at his best is a planetary threat.
 
Last edited:
LOL I know. There was a whole thread about it a while back where some Hulk fanboy was adamant that Hulk could beat Thanos. I couldn't resist the urge to school him :D

Also Thanos could just drain all the gamma radiation out of Hulk and revert him to Banner.
 
THE GREEN ZONE: The End Of The Fall

29fp1lu.jpg


bdrzaf.jpg


CBR News: The final part of "Fall of the Hulk" has happened, and in a way, it seems like both the Fall and the Rise of the Hulks happened at the same time. With that chapter of the story put to bed, do you guys feel you've accomplished everything you set out to for the start of this story? Are all the pieces in place, so to speak?

Jeph Loeb: This is so delicately planned, and it had so many meetings and e-mails and outlines and late night Pak sessions that I would be surprised if there were any surprises! [Laughs]

Greg Pak: There's always little details and nuances that can come out while you're working on a script, but as Jeph says, we've got three writers hashing this thing out, and if any one of us tried to come out and do something totally different, that would jack up six or seven other books. We hammered out this story in a way that served the bigger purpose and this bigger story that we're all telling together. So we're always massaging things, but a big surprise would be a very big surprise for our collaboration.

There are so many pieces in play in the story, but one thing that stood out to me reading the final chapters was that the drive of the story was, "Who can outthink the other side?" We've got the Intelligencia with a master plan and Banner with a team following his super scientist whims. And, up until the end, it felt like Banner could actually come out on top. What was it that made Bruce fail in the end? Was the Intelligencia just more prepared? Was it hubris on Banner's part?

Jeff Parker: I think it was confidence on everybody's part. Everybody's turning out to be way more confident than in a typical hero/villain story. You've got the guy with a brain the size of a Volkswagen bug, and he's really using it. It makes it a lot more interesting when no one's doing anything obvious.

Loeb: Certainly in the case of what happened with the Red Hulk, you've got a couple of elements that are in play. While they were prepared for Betty to be part of the story, any time you introduce Betty into a Hulk story, you're going to shift everyone's priorities. So what Banner wants and what Banner can achieve are going to affected by his need to make sure that she's safe. That's an element that may trip them up or may help them out along the way. The second thing is that – and I think you used the right word with hubris – the Red Hulk really thought that the Intelligencia were following his battle plan. And they were following his battle plan. What he didn't realize was that he had been set up. The fact that they took him down at the last moment, even though he had a plan B with Deadpool in his pocket, means it just didn't work out. And now they'll all have to pay the price for that.

Pak: I think we're in a world where people are trying to think six, seven, eight, nine steps ahead of time. To put it in a nutshell with Banner, he might have been able to figure out what the plan was, but sometimes the plan shifts. And when the plan shifts, there's a whole 'nother level of new decisions and choices and opportunities that are going to arise that are incredibly hard to figure out. So it's a moving target, and at a certain point it escaped him...or did it?!? [Laughs] That's always the question. We've each got another three issues to go in this storyline, and more will be revealed about what, exactly, people are going for and how and why. So what appears to be right now may or may not be. There may be more surprises in store.

Loeb: There is the old adage of "You may have won the battle, but it doesn't mean you've won the war."

Pak: There you go!

It seems that one key difference between the two sides of the conflict is that Banner largely kept parts of his master plan away from his allies while the Intelligencia, by dint of who they are and how untrustworthy some of their numbers can be, were all very much on the same page. Jeph, you said that throwing Betty into the equation can change things and maybe even be a liability. Is there something on the side of the villains – character flaws or what have you – that could be construed a chink in the armor of the Intelligencia?
Pak: Oh, yeah.

Parker: They're all bad with women...unlike us. [Laughter]

Loeb: As Greg promised, all the cards will be tipped over in "World War Hulks." The next three issues will tell the tale of everyone's victory and defeat. The only thing we've been careful about is warning people that you just don't know who your allies are. That will play an important part in what's to come. You may be rooting for the wrong side.

Pak: I always find it very interesting. Superheroes are fascinating in the sense that most superheroes have a vigilante streak. That's one of the central notions of superhero stories – they're civilians who put on costumes to fight crime without official sanction. That's one of the places they start from, and the implication of that is that you've got folks who decide they know what's right. In most superhero stories, they do. But when you have someone like Banner, who's as smart as the Hulk is strong and therefore possibly even more dangerous – when that person's convinced he's right, he may do things that he shouldn't do. I think that's an interesting theme to deal with then it comes to these kinds of stories. We want to explore at what point the means not only don't justify the ends, but the means become a corruption and become the end. Whether Banner will go that far, who can say? But he does have these tendencies, as we've seen in the past few issues, to go one step too far with how he treats everybody except Betty.

We've seen the first half of the Intelligencia's plan with the Cathexis ray turning so many people – heroes and regular folks alike – into Hulks. That fulfills the promise of "Incredible" #600. The other half of their scheme involves the revelation of The Eight and how this big machine all these brains have been hooked up to will come into play for the future. What's the next step in that large plan, and who are the final two members of The Eight?

Loeb: The one thing that's important to remember is that we have revealed that Stark was one of The Eight, so you have seven of the eight. So the question that remains for young Greg Pak is "Who is the eighth man?"

Well then...Greg?

Pak: [Laughs] I could tell you, but then I'd have to...you know.

Loeb: Same thing goes for who the Red Hulk is!

Pak: The Intelligencia have a very specific purpose and reason for being interested in The Eight. And that crazy machine they're all tied into has a very specific purpose. You'll learn alllllllllllll about that in "Incredible Hulk" #609, which is hopefully going to blow minds in both the fictional world and the real world. Don't you dare miss it, kids!

Let's talk about "World War Hulks" #1, where you're using an anthology to check in on a lot of the cast as you guys are ramping up for your next phase. How does that all come together with the rest of the story?

Loeb: We don't want to give away too much, but what we can tell you is that we all contributed into short stories which address specific characters involved in both "Fall of The Hulks" and "World War Hulks." It's kind of a neat little primer to get you into it the action as we get ready for "Hulk" #22 and "Incredible" #609.

Pak: And you're going to see some more work from the guys doing the back-up work and other tie-ins from "Fall of the Hulks" so far. You'll get Scott Reed, Paul Tobin and Harrison Wilcox as well.

Parker: I've seen the pages from Ramon Rosanas and Zach Howard that look great.

Loeb: There's also some cool stuff from Ryan Stegman. And Ben Oliver is doing, of all things, a Winter Soldier story about how he ties into all of this that's very, very cool. It came out of something that happened in "Gamma." That's a really beautiful story.

Head back for the GREEN ZONE next week as Jeff Parker takes us on a tour of Marvel's "Hulked Out Heroes" and Jeph and Greg provide a sneak peek at when the big answers will hit in "World War Hulks!"
 
Last edited:
Does any one still care about who red hulk is? As far as I'm concerned he doesn't even have an alter ego.
 
Nah, and I'm none too thrilled with Deadpool being shoehorned in either.
 
I was curious when it first came out, but I hadn't realized it has been draagged out for almost two years and we still don't know. And I'm willing to bet, that its a nobody who's been gone because they hadn't been worth seeing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"