Comics The Official ROGUE Discussion Thread

[emmymae]

You're a reasonable person and I think you're cool

 

[Canemacar]

I told myself I'd just leave Hand on Ignore, but s/he's just getting ridiculous now.

Really? I'm sorry I couldn't decipher it amongst all the Rogue slandering going on.

Slander is when you say false things about a person to defame them. I've not lied about how bad Rogue is; she's actually done the things I lambaste her for and she *does* have the behavior patterns I cite as reason for my dislike.

I don't expect for everyone to like Rogue but to have this muchhate towards one character is clearly a medical issue. Can posts in various other message boards also. In EVERY SINGLE ONE
he invades the Rogue threads in a weak attempt to rebuddle
good comments that people have made about her. He will literally
quote every single good comment made in her favor and start
this whole entire drama about how Rogue's character is tragic
and bla bla bla bla, bla bla bla bla. LOL<== For u again

Now *this* is slander. I don't irrationally bash Rogue on every message board I visit, responding to each and every positive comment with barbed ones of my own. Thats pure lie on your part.

I visit roughly 11 message boards on a regular/semi-regular/whenever-the-hell-I-feel-like-it, basis and have only talked about my dislike of Rogue on three of them. One of those message boards I used to visit (until last week) was a Gambit/Rogue fansite and I never once expressed my dislike of Rogue there. On comixfan, one of my friends is a dedicated Rogue-fan who I comforted a few times last month when all the recent crap was happening to Rogue.

I *highly* suggest you keep your mouth shut about things you know very little about (i.e. me).

I would hate to see the huge list of things she would've been blamed for if they were still a couple. Talk about drama, haha.

How about every instance of bad writing the character's ever had? Thats what Gambit regularly gets blames for with Rogue.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Really? I'm sorry I couldn't decipher it amongst all the Rogue slandering
going on. What's wierd is you've been posting here for quite some time
and if I recall correctly you've expressed yourself pretty well
in stating that you disagree with Rogue's leadership. I don't ever
remember you taking it somewhere else. I actually remember us agreeing
on a few things, but now all I see is "She's always whining", "She's left
him in Antarctica", "She's horrible at ______", come on man, LOL <=== Just for you

For the love of...

She *has* spent most of the past 15-20 years whining. She *has* left Remy in Antarctica.

This whole thing started out as a debate regarding whether or not she should be leader. Discussing a character's WELL ESTABLISHED emotional issues/instability and questionable choices is *kinda* relevant.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

I told myself I'd just leave Hand on Ignore, but s/he's just getting ridiculous now.




Slander is when you say false things about a person to defame them. I've not lied about how bad Rogue is; she's actually done the things I lambaste her for and she *does* have the behavior patterns I cite as reason for my dislike.




Now *this* is slander. I don't irrationally bash Rogue on every message board I visit, responding to each and every positive comment with barbed ones of my own. Thats pure lie on your part.

I visit roughly 11 message boards on a regular/semi-regular/whenever-the-hell-I-feel-like-it, basis and have only talked about my dislike of Rogue on three of them. One of those message boards I used to visit (until last week) was a Gambit/Rogue fansite and I never once expressed my dislike of Rogue there. On comixfan, one of my friends is a dedicated Rogue-fan who I comforted a few times last month when all the recent crap was happening to Rogue.

I *highly* suggest you keep your mouth shut about things you know very little about (i.e. me).



How about every instance of bad writing the character's ever had? Thats what Gambit regularly gets blames for with Rogue.

If this is the way you ignore someone
I'd hate to see how you give someone your full
undivided attention, LOL

 

[Snikt 6]

^ha, good stuff.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

No, not really.

 

[Snikt 6]

^Really.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Oh well, I suppose our respective definition of pwnage greatly varies, eh.

 

[emmymae]

Enough already. That's your interpretation. No one can prove otherwise to you. You stand firm.

Rogue quotes anyone? I can't wait for issue #200 coming out on June 20.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Enough already. That's your interpretation. No one can prove otherwise to you. You stand firm.

Rogue quotes anyone? I can't wait for issue #200 coming out on June 20.

Emmymae, don't waste your time,
it's like beating a dead horse, LOL
So as you were saying...
Your favorite Rogue quotes? I like her "live with it"
line she gave Cyke b4 going to fight the COTV t:
very badass

 

[Snikt 6]

That little red mad face sure looks angry........

 

[iamlegend]

Emmymae, don't waste your time,
it's like beating a dead horse, LOL
So as you were saying...
Your favorite Rogue quotes? I like her "live with it"
line she gave Cyke b4 going to fight the COTV t:
very badass

I love that quote too, because it'll be biting her in the ass soon. t:

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

I love that quote too, because it'll be biting her in the ass soon. t:

Probably.

And I *still* can't believe why anyone in their right mind would think the scene was badass from Rogue's POV. Unless "badass" would be defined as "Character X telling someone else in an authority position to f**k off even though Character X is clearly wrong", of course.

Let us put the exact same scene in a slightly more cynical/realistic/real word setting.

Don Vercetti: OK, so what's your plan again?

Rouge: Well, we gotta find these people, but we need the best tracker available.

Don Vercetti: Huh huh. And your idea is to bring Hannibal f****n Lecter with you.

Rouge: Yes.

Don Vercetti: I suppose having him out there beats keeping him in our basement, but, huh, that plan won't backfire horribly because...??

Rouge: Well, here's the thing. We injected a him with a lethal virus that we can activate in about a second-flat.

Don Vercetti: So you're essentially holding a gun to his head and assuming it won't give him more of a reason to kill us all if, I'm sorry, WHEN he manages to escape.

Rouge: Yes.

Don Vercetti: About that virus, it wouldn't happen to be the one that's specifically designed to kill us all, right?

Rouge: The very one.

Don Vercetti: Meaning that if, I mean, when something goes wrong and Lecter escapes or gets captured, we're all as good as dead.

Rouge: Yes.

Don Vercetti: And that doesn't strike you as an insanely bad idea??

Rouge: You gave me the job!!! LIVE WITH IT!!!!!!!

Don Vercetti: ...

And keep in mind, that was just me paraphrasing the bloody thing rather than adding to it.

 

[Coldqueen]

*waves to everyone before running away*

 

[Rogue's Hand]

Probably.

And I *still* can't believe why anyone in their right mind would think the scene was badass from Rogue's POV. Unless "badass" would be defined as "Character X telling someone else in an authority position to f**k off even though Character X is clearly wrong", of course.

Let us put the exact same scene in a slightly more cynical/realistic/real word setting.



And keep in mind, that was just me paraphrasing the bloody thing rather than adding to it.

It has yet to bite her anywhere.
She's not dying. And from the looks of things
her recent ways have really made HER fans happy,
and that's truely all that matters. When it's your fav
character's turn to flex, make sure you have your pompoms up
for him and don't be such a grinch. Rogue is giving all us
Rogue fans what we want. And guess what? It ain't stopping t:
Props to Cyke tho for giving her permission to pick her own team.
Guess that came back and bit him in the ass too

 

[iamlegend]

It has yet to bite her anywhere.
She's not dying. And from the looks of things
her recent ways have really made HER fans happy,
and that's truely all that matters. When it's your fav
character's turn to flex, make sure you have your pompoms up
for him and don't be such a grinch. Rogue is giving all us
Rogue fans what we want. And guess what? It ain't stopping t:
Props to Cyke tho for giving her permission to pick her own team.
Guess that came back and bit him in the ass too

Just read the spoiler.

Spoiler

It very much will be biting Rogue hard soon, seeing as how Sabretooth is going head to head with at least a few members of the team soon. That, and Mystique, Lady M, and Karima all seem to be at least temporarily signing up with the Marauders.

Yeah, great team structure.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

It has yet to bite her anywhere.
She's not dying. And from the looks of things
her recent ways have really made HER fans happy,
and that's truely all that matters. When it's your fav
character's turn to flex, make sure you have your pompoms up
for him and don't be such a grinch. Rogue is giving all us
Rogue fans what we want. And guess what? It ain't stopping t:
Props to Cyke tho for giving her permission to pick her own team.
Guess that came back and bit him in the ass too

The point is that *NO ONE* had any business trying to look cool after making that Creed command decision because, get this, it's a BAD one.

Damnit, it's not about *her*. Or Cyke.

It's about pulling that stupid stunt and getting away with it.

 

[OutcryX]

Holy SH_T!!!! Darth!! you're back!!! *tears of joy*

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Holy SH_T!!!! Darth!! you're back!!! *tears of joy*

Nice of you to hold the fort. t: t: t:

 

[emmymae]

Enough, we got the point already.

Rogue quote: "Vengeance oughta be mine, wouldn't you say?" X-Men #196

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

...???

What does that have to do with anything?

 

[emmymae]

I was calling for Rogue quotes as a positive alternative. Rogue's Hand kindly obliged. So I was following suit. (Ha,ha card term.)

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Fair enough.

Thought you were trying to use the quote to make a point...

 

[Coldqueen]

...it was a point.

Emma is coming after you, Darth. Run. Hide.

Rogue fans are DIE HARD.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

"I want that thing off my lawn."

Said 'thing' being either enraged Rogue fans or the Southern Belle herself. t: