Agreed. If we are going to praise Black Widow's suit for looking practical than I feel that Whiplash is open to the opposite scrutiny. Again I think he upgrades his weaponry and he gets the jump on Tony while he is outside his suit. But with his chest exposed if he got hit by one of Iron Man's sniper rounds it's over and like AVEIT said, IM survived a tank round.
Exactly, I think the Black Widow costume is fantastic and I have no criticisms of that, but the Whiplash one just doesnt look practical to me so far, and he doesnt look like someone who could give Iron Man a good challenge to me.
Well it's not really the creative team or Favreau that would be to blame if you don't think they have put a lot of thought into him when he was actually like this in the comics for the most part. They basically took what was already created. Once again it comes down to you not being imaginative enough and assuming the only possibility for this fight is that Iron Man shoots a repulsor beam once and kills Whiplash and it's done.
I dont need to be imaginative enough, i'm not being paid to work on the movie the writers are the ones who need to be imaginative. I just dont think Whiplash as a bad guy was a good way to go. All i said from the start was I hope they come up with a practical and logical reason for Whiplash to give Iron Man a challenge rather than "Well if IM blasted him straight away there wouldnt have been fight."
Give it a chance, if they fail and come up with something stupid for the fights then have at it and tear it apart but I just don't think it's going to be all that bad.
I am giving it a chance, as I said above, I love the BW suit, and I have said I liked the new armour, and the cast is superb, i'm judging the whole movie as I havent seen it, its just that, SO FAR (as in my opinion could change) I am not happy with THIS aspect of the movie.
No, my point was if you can't suspend your disbelief, then why would you go to see it at all? I never said you shouldn't go see it. But honestly, if you've judged the film off of certain known facts that you don't like, that's one thing. You've already judged this as a mistake and you don't know anything. You don't know how or if they can pull it off, the film might just surprise you.
I havent judged the movie, have you heard me say it will be crap? No, I have simply said that, SO FAR, I dont like the Whiplash suite. You'd think I was going round telling people the movie is crap, I havent at all.
That's the whole idea, maybe the whips ARE something special.
They need to be, but IMO them repelling repulsor blasts just wouldnt look good, but who knows, it may do.
he wrotte a fair post. he said that he thinks the suit doesnt work based on what he saw so far.
he said nothing against the whole movie or that he will not see it.
everything he said is hes opinion based on the two pics from whiplash.
i dont understand how this is suspend your disbelief. does this mean that a pregnant girl can defeat iron man and if they explain it that then it works? because of a banana?
what i think suspend your disbelief means. it means that Tony Stark was able to build a M1 suit in a cave. that in the IM universe there is technology where a heavy and i mean really heavy suit can move faster then a human. suspend your disbelief? its when tony stark is in a hard metal suit and falls down from the sky. and he f.... survives. thats suspend your disbelief IMO. that he survived. does the IM suit have airbag? ha ha. but hey i accept this. because its a comicbook movie.
you know what can not happen in a comicbook movie? when tony stark is in hes car driving a flying pig can not fly over hes head. a strange example? of course it is because i made it up very fast. a flying pig would be stupid and would not fit inside the universe.
IMO it has nothing to do with suspend your disbelief that the terminator didnt kill connor. it was lazy writting. and IMO if whiplah can survive in a fight with this this suit then its lazy writting .
this is my opinion based on the pics and based on the first movie. in the first movie we saw what IM is able to do. it doesnt mean that i will hate the movie.
its a forum and we are debating. we are not hating.
Exactly, I simply hope the writing is good enough to make it believable that, in that suit, Whiplash can pose a threat to Iron Man.