This Has To Be Gwen...

[CAH]

OK, so over in the "Spider-Man 3 TV spots" thread we were discussing the picture below from the new TV spot that just came online today, and some believe it to be Gwen Stacy, others think it is Aunt May.

If you look at the girl's hair, your first impression is going to obviously be that it's Gwen, because not only is that hair blonde (atleast it looks that way) but it's also not put up like Aunt May's. Secondly, look in this TV spot, at about 00:05 seconds, and you'll see that the person handing the ring to Peter Parker is not Aunt May, because look at what she is wearing...when Aunt May says "Give her this..." she is wearing red, and the person at 00:05 seconds handing Peter the ring is wearing a greyish-blue colored shirt...and when Peter looks up at her teary eyed, you see the let down blonde hair...it HAS to be Gwen. Now, I don't know why Gwen would be giving Peter back that ring while he's all teary eyed (Dark Parker probably proposed to her) but you can obviously see that it HAS to be Gwen.


I just wanted to put an end to this argument.


CAH

 

[CAH]

Plus, when you look at teary eyed Parker taking the ring, he is wearing different clothes than the ones he was wearing during Aunt May's "Revenge is like a poison" speech...so yet another fact to prove that it's Gwen.


CAH

 

[rashad]

I knew it was two different scenes when I first saw it.

 

[Visionary]

Looks like Mary May Stacy.

 

[Dope Nose]

is anyone else not seeing a photo?

 

[Spider-Gamer]

is anyone else not seeing a photo?

Good ol' red x for me!

 

[Spade]

Does that work, for those who can't see it?
http://i12.photobucket.com/albums/a205/DarthVader28/RingWho.jpg?t=1167714085

 

[Dope Nose]

thanks ChibiKiriyama, that works.

 

[Spidey-Sean]

I don't think Peter is wearing different clothes though, looks like a white dress shirt and the same tie in both the "revenge" speech and the mysterious ring sequence. But it does look like whoever hands him the ring is wearing a puffy shoulder, light blue shirt, and that's definitley not Aunt May unless she was wearing that underneath her red overcoat thing.

But why would Gwen give Peter the ring? Peter looks distressed to me; maybe a mistake he made by asking her instead of MJ while under the influence of the symbiote? She's giving it back possibly.

 

[Stewie840]

Mhmm, it's gwen, trust me

 

[Untilteld]

who cares?

 

[YodatheHobbit]

who cares?

People?

 

[jimmy]

Looks like aunt carnage to me.

 

[NewYorkSpider]

Gwen

 

[GoldGoblin]

But why would Gwen give Peter the ring? Peter looks distressed to me; maybe a mistake he made by asking her instead of MJ while under the influence of the symbiote? She's giving it back possibly.

^Maybe evil Peter proposed to her.

 

[Spider-ManHero12]

it either could be gwen or aunt may but aunt may did not wear her hair down in that scene.

 

[dark_b]

its not aunt may. isnt here a scene also with peter crying?

 

[Ankara]

Columbia is keeping a tight lid on the third movie's story line, though it is known that Gwen is the third part of a love triangle and that the character does survive.

Its Gwen

 

[Naite22]

I knew it was two different scenes when I first saw it.

Not to sound like a mr. know it all... but I did too

 

[Venom'sDad]

That is not Gwen... that's Theresa Russell..... or that's Ursula.

 

[The Lizard]

It's wannabe actress Brooke Adams finally getting some screen time as Felicia Hardy!

 

[The Joker]

That is not Gwen... that's Theresa Russell..... or that's Ursula.

While I doubt it's chocolate cake girl, it could very well be Mrs Sandman. Raimi said Sandman is seeking Peter's forgiveness.

This could be Mrs Marko pleading on behalf of her husband.

 

[Venom'sDad]

That's the very reason why I said that DocOck, because Sam said that Sandman seeks his forgiveness, and she may be doing that in Flint's behalf. Also because, Gwen is presented as a true Blonde, this person we see is a Dirty Blonde.

The reason I mention Ursula is because Sam mentioned she will again bring some sense of sensibility back to Peter... which that scene could very well be that.

 

[Visionary]

Damn...they've confused us all.

 

[Carnotaur3]

I think it's possible that Peter shows the ring to Gwen. Aunt May does indeed give it to him, but the editor manipulates to footage enough from a different scene (probably because someone liked these shots better for the trailer).