Never, ever, Venom. I'm with Brian Bendis and Sam Raimi. Venom is a weak character that reeks of late 80s/early 90s sensibilities of style over substance. I'd much rather see Ned Leeds as the Hobgoblin: he has nearly the same dynamic in terms of being Peter's rival as reporter and costumed figure. However, Leeds has infinitely greater narrative depth. Eddie has a highly irrational disdain for Peter Parker, and that is his sole motivation. Not that you can't have a character purely driven by vengeance, but Brock's justification for vengeance is pure crap, which makes him an uninteresting figure. This is why Raimi wanted to avoid him and why Bendis did his best to keep Venom's exposure brief in the Ultimate series.
If one is going to spend the amount of time necessary to rewrite a character such as Venom, then they would likely be better off coming up with an original character. But lets pretend that someone did wish to undertake the task of recreating Venom so that he is a more dynamic character. Doing so would present two problems;
1) They focus more on his rivalry with Peter Parker, both in and out of costume and attempt to create a more compelling narrative by playing up those angles. If one pursues this path, then why not simply use existing characters that already fulfill that angle (e.g. The Big Man and The Hobgoblin).
2) They decide to create an entirely different motivation and origin in order to create a compelling narrative. This then brings up the question of why the writer would not simply opt to create their own fully fleshed out character.
So you either wind up wasting time using a weak character when stronger characters can do the same thing, or you end up basically creating your own character but slapping superficial elements on top of that creation so that it bears the likeness of another character. It just seems to be a wasted effort.
Great.
fair enough. I challenge you to come up with a reason how Mysterio (seeing that he's a fan favorite now) could be interesting as a main villain of a movie without coming up with motivations, plot points and character traits that weren't already in the comics
GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS!!!!!!!!! Let me handle this one.
Mysterio is my favorite Spider-Man villain. I really thought how to do him differently and thanks to the MCU, you can do it in the way I have him but change it a bit.
I had an idea where Mysterio is a Mutant. He is basically Spider-Man if Peter's Uncle didn't die. What did Peter do with his powers at first? Win money fighting. That's where I'm going with Mysterio.
Now Marvel can't use Mutants but you know what they can use? INHUMANS!!!! Mysterio is an Inhuman and has the powers to create villains and make illusions appear and feel real. He also can create smoke to give off that foggy look he sometimes has.
My take, Mysterio is a Magician who can't get work anymore. No one wants to hire him. So at first, he haunts shows of his competitors and the people who rejected him. He sees how much press and news he's getting of this strange haunting and decides to keep the show going and takes it to the streets of NYC.
One idea I have with a fight between him and Spider-Man comes from the Spider-Man 2 game. Mysterio creates the illusion of a robotic alien invasion.
One of my favorite illusions idea is this: what if Mysterio gave off the illusion OF THE GODDAMN MUTHA****ING STAY PUFT MARSHMALLOW MAN AND SPIDER-MAN HAD TO FIGHT IT!!!!! Clearly a nod to one of my favorite films in Ghostbusters and the fact Sony made Ghostbusters, Mysterio actually can do this in the film.
The third fact, Spider-Man figures out where Mysterio is and goes to his hideout and when he opens a door it leads straight into like a Circus. Again really Spider-Man 2 the game influenced. There's a fun house with the mirrors, there's an upside down house, and the final boss ends at the big tent with Mysterio also feeding into Spider-Man's thoughts with Uncle Ben in the audience.
I want to make Mysterio the Scarecrow or Freddy Krueger of Spider-Man foes but not just focus on fear and nightmares.
I have a sequel idea where basically Mysterio figures out how to use his powers to make everyone in the city feel be under his influence and my idea for that is of course he does and just about everyone in the island NYC is knocked out and the world they are in and Spider-Man must enter and fight, with the help of either Scarlet Witch or Dr Strange haven't decided which, is basically very Bioshock influence with Mysterio basically like the Andrew Ryan or Comstock of this world and all of the people are under the influence except for Spidey and one of his allies. We would have Avengers and Sinister Six members kind of like the Big Daddy's or Handymen in terms of boss fights for Spidey that are controlled by Mysterio. It's just ****ing epic.
I even have a third idea for Mysterio. Smaller but bigger. It's influenced by the Batman The Animated Series episode, Perchance To Dream but a little different.
Spider-Man wakes up to his worst nightmare ever. We see Avengers get killed by the Sinister Six, Green Goblin has killed Aunt May and MJ. And once Green Goblin goes up to Spidey and kills him, Peter wakes up again but this time, he wakes up in bed with Gwen Stacy. It's basically his best dream ever. Uncle Ben is alive, Gwen's alive, and he's not Spider-Man but Peter thinks something is wrong and in the third fact we find out Mysterio is the one giving Spidey these illusions and yea they fight.
THAT'S HOW I WOULD DO MYSTERIO AND WHY HE WOULD BE ****ING EPIC FOR A SPIDER-MAN FILM!!!!!