Sequels Zak Penn's X-Mem - First Class: Your ideas.

odiin

Sidekick
Joined
Nov 21, 2006
Messages
3,867
Reaction score
0
Points
31
I must admit, when I first heard his idea of doing what is presumably a prequel featuring the (film version of the) original team, thinking a full-on sequel with the younger X-men (Iceman, Rogue, Shadowcat, Colossus ) would be better. But the more I got to thinking about it, the more I love the idea. I realized that not only would it be cool to focus on the original, smaller team , but it would be the perfect chance to show on film things that X-fans have been clamoring for for 7 years now:

- First off, we could see more comic accurate black and gold versions of the costumes like what they wear in the First Class comic, with these being considered their "original costumes" before they were modified down the road.

- Because Wolverine wouldn't be around yet, he wouldn't be able to take away from Cyclops' role this go around so Cyclops would have a much bigger role than in the previous films

_ This would be a great opportunity to introduce Gambit. Obviously the film version of the original team is a bit different than the comic book version with Angel and Iceman not coming around until later, and Storm instead being one of the originals. So if they decided that they wanted to have the same number of original members, even if the actual membership is a little different, they could introduce Gambit as the fifth original member. Now this could make things a little difficult for X4 being as how a lot of people wanted a Rogue and Gambit relationship, but I think it would be an interesting concept to have her dating someone 10 years or so her senior, and would probably make Iceman very jealous.

So what are your thoughts, and who do you think should be cast as the younger versions of the characters, and about what age do you think the characters should be?
 
How could Rogue be dating Gambit in a PREQUEL to X1. Rogue only arrived at the mansion in X1; in any prequel to X1, there would be no Rogue.
 
How could Rogue be dating Gambit in a PREQUEL to X1. Rogue only arrived at the mansion in X1; in any prequel to X1, there would be no Rogue.

I mean Rogue dating Gambit in X4 if and when that comes out. Like in X4 will "come back" to the mansion in X4 after being established as one of the original X-men in the prequel, and will meet Rogue there.
 
I like the prequel idea... but it still won't change the atrocity that was TLS... and it wouldn't feature any big gun villains... just a movie about nothing... we don't need to know how Xavier started the school... that was hinted at in TLS and will be more developed in the Magneto film when Charles and Eric fo their separate ways...so go with the sequel... and get it right to erase the mistakes of past films... prequels... while cool... will consist of recasts and won't change a damn thing.
 
I like the prequel idea... but it still won't change the atrocity that was TLS... and it wouldn't feature any big gun villains... just a movie about nothing... we don't need to know how Xavier started the school... that was hinted at in TLS and will be more developed in the Magneto film when Charles and Eric fo their separate ways...so go with the sequel... and get it right to erase the mistakes of past films... prequels... while cool... will consist of recasts and won't change a damn thing.

It... doesn't need to change anything. It would just be it's own movie. A film about the first class of X-men.
 
It would be a useless prequel.
We already were shown how Xavier's school came to be in the first movie.
The black and gold costumes aren't that intriguing. Doesn't matter if Cyclops got a bigger role, it still makes his death in X-3 pointless and ******ed. As for Gambit, the idea is kind of shiitty to me. Even without the Rogue relationship, it's ridiculous.
 
It would be a useless prequel.
We already were shown how Xavier's school came to be in the first movie.
The black and gold costumes aren't that intriguing. Doesn't matter if Cyclops got a bigger role, it still makes his death in X-3 pointless and ******ed. As for Gambit, the idea is kind of shiitty to me. Even without the Rogue relationship, it's ridiculous.

Agreed! Besides, Magneto would be the villain again and they really need some new villains.
 
I should be sincere and say that I'd see pleased a prequel movie, or a young x-men movie.... more than that, I'd say anything about x-men, as a group, I mean.

But my first desire is to see a X4 first. If we can get both in the next years, would be nice, but I really hope that a X4 is made one day (and I'm sure about it, but hate to wait, hehe).
 
Only thing i hate about prequels is that it messes everything up like Star Wars.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"