Would you PLZ stop quoting with ur replies in there.. hard to quote back
I will Edit soon with response.
EDIT:
Maybe I find many ideas comic fans force onto a film to be crap, laughable even. Theres no reason for such a comic fetishism to the point of not letting the director create. I doubt myself someone would find this wrong.
So if a director cannot create somethign beautiful for the non fanatics, then i call that situation to be crap? Is this what youre teaching me what is fair? Hmmm.
You keep going back to saying fans want the comics adapted word for word. That's ultimately impossible. I told you that's not what they want. Read my post from the last page, ok. They want the spirit of the character and the fundamentals of their story to be left in tact. Why would a non-fan care either way if the character's the way they should be or not?
How is it ridiculous.. lol thats the most ignorant statement. You either take the crap comics can be responsible for, or you dont take any of them if thats the case. You are NOT forcing a crap film on me because of your ignorance, thats for sure. You have a warped view of how films are made and only trust your comics. Thats your fault, not the good films that come about due to it. This type of person deserves comics alone, and no films. They just dont appreciate them.
Don't tell me what I deserve. If wanting the character to be as close as possible to who they are in the book is wrong, like I said, go ahead and sue me. You'll be suing a hell of a lot of people while you're at it. It's just common sense that every issue can't be adapted so why are you sitting there telling me every comic is counted. That's why I said spirit of the character and fundamentals. I and every person alive knows that it's impossible to fit all issues into a film. All you can ask for is for the director to stay faithful to the spirit and the fundamentals. That's my personal preferrence, and if you want hollywood to forget all that, and deliver something nearly unrecognizable, then that's truly unbelievable. You don't honestly want that, do you?
Next time you want to see a cool live action movie, you might want to rethink your defiance and disrespect of what film entails. If it werent for them, you would still have flat pages with word bubbles lmao. If you so want respect you have to give it to the film makers, not just demand and expect them to just kneel before you when you have no clue what youre talking about with film.
No, the film's made for an audience and they need honest feedback to make their work the best it can be, not sycophantic adulation. If I don't like their movie, I'll say so. If I do, I will. That's just how I do it.