In February, the Guardian published a deep investigation into Homan Square, a shadowy facility where the Chicago Police Department takes suspects without booking them, entering them into any official database, or giving them access to a telephone or their lawyer. A new Guardian report claims that more than twice as many people have been disappeared into Homan as officials initially disclosed.
The paper obtained documents showing that more than 7,000 people were detained at Homan between 2004 and 2015about 6,000 of whom were black. Less than one percent of those detainees were allowed to see their lawyers during interrogations. Attorneys described a system that seems deliberately engineered to make it difficult to find their clients; others said that they were turned around at the door. Try finding a phone number for Homan to see if anyones there. You cant, ever, an attorney named David Gaeger told the Guardian. If youre laboring under the assumption that your clients at Homan, there really isnt much you can do as a lawyer. Youre shut out. Its guarded like a military installation.
Spencer Ackerman of the Guardians earlier reporting on Homan detailed allegations of beatings and long, unexplained detainments with no access to counsel. One attorney described a client whose name was changed on his records before a transfer to Homan. He emerged from the facility with a head wound:
He said that the officers caused his head injuries in an interrogation room at Homan Square. I had been looking for him for six to eight hours, and every department member I talked to said they had never heard of him, Solowiej said. He sent me a phone pic of his head injuries because I had seen him in a police station right before he was transferred to Homan Square without any.
And as unsettling as it is to think that 7,000 people were subjected to such treatment without even being formally booked, that number is almost certainly low: those who were taken to Homan but not ultimately charged with crimes do not figure into the records the Chicago PD has disclosed thus far, meaning that many more detainees may be missing for the record.
Plenty of people agree that America should stop throwing every last shoplifter or weed-smoker in jail. On the right they get to talk about reducing incarcerations burden on taxpayers; on the left its a victory for civil rights. Now, even the countrys top law enforcement officialsthose who youd think would be driving mass incarceration in the first placeare getting in on the act.
This week, a new group called Launch of Law Enforcement Leaders to Reduce Crime and Incarceration, composed of 130 police chiefs and government prosecutors, announced its support for the criminal justice movement. Its members are no slouches: LAPD Chief Charlie Beck, NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton, and Washington, DC, Metropolitan Police Department Chief Cathy Lanier all belong to the organization, and Chicago PD Superintendent Garry McCarthy is its co-chair.
Tomorrow, Law Enforcement Leaders will convene at the White House to speak about reducing imprisonment while strengthening public safety (these are still cops were talking about). Among their talking points are a more treatment-focused approach to offenders with drug or mental health problems, reclassifying some felonies as misdemeanors, and ending federal mandatory minimumsall old sa****ses of the activist movement to end mass incarceration.
Its encouraging, and its also a little funny to see these particular people get behind this particular causelike McDonalds rallying against hamburgers. In a story about the new group, the New York Times acknowledges that police and prosecutors have a great deal of discretion in interpreting and carrying out the very policies theyre railing against, and makes the case that pressure to be tough on crime from the public and elected officials forces them into the current overly punitive model.
Good crime control policy does not involve arresting and imprisoning masses of people. It involves arresting and imprisoning the right people, McCarty said in a statement about Law Enforcement Leaders. Arresting and imprisoning low-level offenders prevents us from focusing resources on violent crime. It makes you wonder what inspired Bill Bratton to join. Through his tenures leading the NYPD and LAPD, and in his early advocacy for stop-and-frisk and broken windows policing, Bratton is something like the Michael Jordan of arresting and imprisoning low-level offenders. He must have been facing an awful lot of public pressure.
A school resource officer at Spring Valley High School in Columbia, South Carolina, tackled a girl who was sitting in her desk, dragged her across the room, pinned her, and arrested her, according to video footage of the incident. WISTV reported that the girl refused an order to leave class:According to Sheriff Leon Lott, the school resource officer was acting in response to a student who was refusing to leave class.I suggest watching the two videos. It may be true that the girl was in trouble, and she certainly disobeyed a police command. But its impossible to justify the act of violence that followed her refusal to move; the officer knocked her backward out of her desk and dragged her across the floor. To say she could have been seriously injured in the struggle is an understatement.
"The student was told she was under arrest for disturbing school and given instructions which she again refused," Lott said. "The video then shows the student resisting and being arrested by the SRO."
The video shows the officer approaching the girl sitting at a desk in a classroom. The officer grabs the girl's arm while putting his own arm around the student's neck.
The officer can also be heard threatening to arrest students for complaining about the girls treatment. Ill put you in jail next, he said in response to a student who quite reasonably exclaimed, what the ****?
According to activist Shaun Kings Twitter feed, the SRO has a history of violence toward the students, who are all terrified of him.
School and police officials are investigating the incident. Parents and students are outraged. They should be. Students do not lose their right to humane treatment merely because they are compelled to attend public schooling.
A former St. Louis prosecutor has pled guilty to Misprision of a Felony for covering up the vicious beating of a handcuffed suspect by a veteran St. Louis cop, according to a report from The Huffington Post.
Bliss Barber Worrell was assistant circuit attorney for the city of St. Louis in July of last year, when a veteran officer with whom she had a close friendship reportedly beat the hell out of a man arrested for allegedly fraudulently using the credit card of the police officers daughter. The beating was severe enough that the officer injured his own foot and may have chipped one of the suspects teeth by shoving his handgun down the throat of the handcuffed victim.
In the plea, Worrell says that she did not intend to bring any charges against the suspect in the incident, but that she was present when the arresting officer showed up at the warrant office and decided to help a new prosecutor file charges against the suspect. The report from the arresting officer did not match what she had heard from the veteran officer, but she failed to tell her supervisors what she knew about the incident and filed charges against the suspect anyway for receiving stolen property, for fraudulent use of a credit card and for allegedly attempting to escape while resisting arrest.
The veteran officer isnt named in the plea, but a St. Louis Post-Dispatch report notes similarities between the details in the plea and the circumstances of Worrells resignation from her position in the circuit attorneys office, when officer Tom Carroll was accused of assaulting 41-year-old Michael Weller after Weller allegedly stole and fraudulently used Carrolls daughters credit card.
Worrells plea explains that she was told by the veteran officer that other officers had participated in the beating, including the shift commander on duty that night.
The veteran officer also offered up a particularly cruel detail: that everyone was laughing at the suspect, who was screaming for help when he was brought into the police station, likely because the suspect was told during transport that he was going to get beaten.
Tammy Dickinson, U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Missouri, is prosecuting the case, and has indicated the investigation is ongoing and extends beyond this defendants role in covering up an egregious civil rights violation.
But if I'm her parents, I'm whooping her ass because she should have left the class when she was told.
The other girl that was arrested (why?) said on CNN Tonight that she didn't even know the name of the girl who was flung through the class like a ragdoll. It seemed like she was a very quiet girl (fairly new) who didn't socialize much with her other classmates.Maybe she was having some issues in her personal life?And on top of that they arrested one of the students who filmed the incident for "disturbing the school"![]()
The South Carolina deputy who slammed a disruptive student on the floor and tossed her several feet has been fired.
Other students in the classroom at Spring Valley High School caught the incident on video.
Richland County Sheriff Leon Lott suspended Deputy Ben Fields without pay, and then fired him Wednesday.
Fields violated police regulations when he threw the girl, the sheriff said.
Fields was the Spring Valley High School resource officer whose actions Monday were recorded by students and ignited a firestorm on social media. Among the criticisms: his admitted use of "muscling techniques" to get the student out of her chair.
But that's only one part of the story. Federal investigators have gotten involved. Another student arrested from the classroom has spoken out. And the sheriff is criticizing a South Carolina law that he says muddles the role of school resource officers.